Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Posts

I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#1

I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

John Lucas

I had an epiphany or at least something like it the other day. I have always had a hard time chasing threads in less than perfect woods. I can do it quite successfully in Box wood, Cocobolo, Blackwood, Osage, etc. I have trouble in maple and other woods that aren't as hard as the above.

I was rereading an article about turning threads on a metal lathe. You always cut on the backside of the thread going essentially downhill on the metal. It occured to me that I might be pushing the thread chaser and basically scraping on the uphill grain of the front side of each tooth.

Anyway I tried my theory today and concentrated on letting the wood pull the cutter more than me pushing. It worked. I was able to cut clean threads in Cherry and yellow heart. I have cut good threads in yellow heart before but not cherry. I may try some maple tomorrow.

What do you all think. Am I stating it correctly or am I just guessing at what's happening.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#2

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

john Veerkamp

Our local club thread expert always instructs us to let the wood pull the cutter in. So what you're saying makes sense.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#3

Steven Antonucci

sounds feasible


Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#4

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Josh Bowman

Whoa dude! You've ruined my day! I've been practicing cutting threads with my new uni-chaser from Ashley Iles for the past couple of weeks in some maple scraps and other crappy wood. Now I find I can't use that wood?

John, sarcasm aside. :D ......I have only watched you at our club and Mahoney at TAW cut threads along with some videos and AM NOT close to expertise of you.

But being new at this, I feel I have a voice, since I'm very mechanical/scripted in how I go through the process. I have successfully cut threads in maple and other junk wood laying around the shop. I do have to be gentle and let the tool kind of lightly follow the threads or keep myself in sync with the threads, like my metal lathe does. If I drag or push, I scrape the threads off. I also find I have to significantly rotate the cutter downward so the scraping action is not too aggressive. I actually look forward in cutting some good wood. Now all that said, my first box I cut as seen on our clubs web site WWW.TriStateWoodturners.com, I wound up balding the threads on the original top and had to re-cut a new one. I'm guessing that's the risk of using junk wood. I find my best threads are when I can get down the rhythm, of which I don't have.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#5

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

John Lucas

Josh Having cut threads with the Baxter threader which will cut clean looking theads in most woods it's a little dis heartening to get a less than perfect thread. I have chased threads in a fair number of woods but there is always some chip out here and there on the threads. Overall the threads look pretty decent and of course work, it's just that I'm after the "perfect" thread. Yea right.

When you chase threads in woods that are good for that such as Box wood it's like eating your favorite food. It's very easy, the threads look perfect and they fit like a glove. Of course when you then step down to maple ( and there are hard and soft varieties) the immediately it gets harder. Most of the maple and cherry I have is of the soft variety and I guess that's why I have problems.

I'm also using homemade tools that may or may not cut as well. The seem to, but then I don't have a good comparison. I do have some antique ones that I could use but dont' have the same thread pitches. I'll try that in the next day or so.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#6

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Fred Holder

John,

You are right, the wood should always pull the chaser after you've finally gotten the threads struck, simply, gently place the chaser into the grooves and let the grooves in the wood pull the chaser along. Be sure to pull the chaser out as you cut into to recess you've cut at the back of the area to be threaded.

I have found that it is easier to cut threads in side grain for softer woods. I've successfully chased threads in side grain pine. I don't know how well they would stand up with use, but I tried if just to see if it would work. The theory is that you are cutting threads part of the time in end grain wood and part of the time in side grain wood. You might give this a try on some of the softer woods.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#7

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Josh Bowman

Ahhh, there's your problem......"the perfect" thread". Your standards are just too high ;). Look forward to seeing you in March as TSW. I like to hear what you learn about the chasing.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#8

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Pete in Holland, MI

When single-point thread cutting standard 30 degree threads on a metal metal lathe, you set the compound (angled slide on a metal lathe) to 29.5 degrees. Each pass, you advance the cutter on the compound till you reach depth. Several passes are needed to single point cut threads. The idea is that you push the cutter into the right side of the thread with the left side of the cutter to cut a near flat shaving, while the right side of the cutter slightly shaves the previous thread. Trying to push the cutter straight in to the stock tries to take a v-shaped shaving and will result in some pretty crappy threads.

It's suprising how many people who "play" around on a metal lathe cannot cut a single-point thread. Guess I got rasied old school.

Pete

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#9

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

John Lucas

Pete That's what I read the other day. Makes sense but I can't figure out how that interprets to chasing threads in wood although technically with each pass except maybe the last few I angle the cutter a little more. You start out catching the thread with the cutter at an angle to the wood. ONce you have a thread started you gradually increase the angle of the tool so the threads cut further back on the tenon until you eventually reach a flat thread. So in theory we could be cutting less than 30 degrees with each pass.

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

#10

Re: I'll pick your brains on thread chasing

Dale Miner

In metal work, if the tool were advanced straight into the stock, the tool woulld cut a shaving on both sides of the groove. The two shavings would crowd each other on top of the tool, essentially leaving no way for the shavings to clear. The result is the tops and sides of the threads become torn and ragged.

With wood, the ability of wood to crumble allows the shaving to clear the groove easier, even if cutting on both sides of the groove. However, if single point threading wood on a metal lathe, I would still advance the tool at the 29.5 degree angle.

I do have some home made chasers, as well as store bought, and have a home made thread mill. The mill does cut better than the chasers, and it does cut on both sides of the groove at the same time. The milling cutteer takes many many small bites as it cuts the thread, and I give the many small bite issue credit for the better quality threads.

Even when milling threads though, better wood yields better threads.