Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

LED Work Light

Posts

LED Work Light

#1

LED Work Light

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Craft Supplies USA is now advertising a woodturners LED work light that looks interesting. One selling point is an LED bulb with a life of 50,000 hours. I contacted Craft to determine the source and cost of replacement bulbs in the event of bulb beakage from flying wood, dropping on the floor, etc.

I was informed that these bulbs are soldered in and there are no replacements.

Am I overly concerned about turning a new LED work light into a $70 paperweight? How tough are these bulbs?

Re: LED Work Light

#2

Re: LED Work Light

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Bulbs? Well not quite a bulb. LEDs are made with the same semiconductor technology (although not Silicon, other semiconductor materials) as other chips that are in everything (cell phones, cars, appliances, and yes computers).

These devices are "solid state," meaning no tubes, filaments, gases, or fragile glass bulbs. In and of themselves LEDs are quite robust, certainly when compared to any other modern lighting technology I can think of. There are of course complementary parts in the entire system - and I can't speak to the details of these. However, overall I would think that an LED light source (i.e bulb) would likely be the MOST robust lighting source.

That doesn't mean that I would be willing to pay $70 for a light (or it's replacement). When that fails there is no simple replaceable part like a light bulb.

Henry

Re: LED Work Light

#3

After using the IKEA LED lights......

JamieDonaldson

...that were all the rage recently, the actual light output left much more to be desired. I can't tell if the Craft Supply unit has more than a single LED, so I would want to see a sample in operation before shelling out that many bucks.

Re: LED Work Light

#4

$70.00??

Jorge

I did get one at Lowe's a couple years ago, is is an exterior flood light, it works very well and I know it was under $20.00 or I would not have it. I has something like 50 little led's.

The light color is very wood, but things I sand late at night, they look good under the light, next day with day light I can see sand paper scratches, so no working late for me...

Re: LED Work Light

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: LED Work Light

Brad Vietje

A few thoughts:

I would not buy anything like this that could not be repaired or replaced. I only buy rechargeable batteries, for example. Anything else would be considered disposable, which I abhor as wasteful.

There are some very good LED's on the market with standard E-26 screw-in bases, just like the incandescent bulbs we all grew up with. They are also available in other base designs, such as MR-16, Gu-10, etc... I would find a few "bulbs" I like, and use them in some sort of lamp you already own. Some screw-in E-26 base LED's are encased in hard frosted plastic shells that do look a lot like incandescent bulbs.

I'd go check out the light quality in a shop with a live demo -- you could even bring in a piece of wood sanded to 220 or so, and make sure the color and the detail you need to see can be seen. Scratches, BTW, show up better under un-frosted lights -- the closer to a point source (tiny light source) the more the scratches stand out.

I'd be picky about color temperature, which is achieved a little differently when it comes to LED technology. You may find that in order to create a 2800K or 3000K output, they use a mix of diodes with various outputs, and the end result might not be exactly what you want.

There may be some wavelengths that show scratches more clearly than others, so a little research might be helpful here. Even if Black Cherry looks greenish-brown, if you can see the scratches at the lathe before the finish goes on, that might be a good thing (?) at least as a special-purpose inspection light.

"Warm White", usually in the 2700 - 2800 K range, can be quite yellow in LED's, and sometimes a fairly icky yellow at that.

Color Temperature: If an incandescent bulb is yellowish, we tend to think that's "warm", while a bluish cast (4000 - 6000 K) is described as cool or cold toned. These are holdovers from the art world, where the colors of snow and ice are considered cool, and those of sunsets are considered warm. These terms describe the colors reflected or transmitted, but not those not emitted, so they are almost completely backward as far as light sources go. In the physical world, white and blue light are emitted from objects much hotter than those emitting red, orange, or yellow.

CRI: Color Rendering Index is a numeric scale that describes how colors are rendered when illuminated by that light source. A higher number means the colors seen under that light are more like the true colors seen outside in daylight (which is quite blue, BTW, but that's another matter...) In other words, if reds come out looking a little too dark, or yellows slightly greenish, the CRI would be lower than if they reproduced just like the original. This is important in selecting lights for a gallery or a public display, and less so for shop lighting. A higher number means closer to the original.

My 2 cents -- and probably only worth 50% of that!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: LED Work Light

#6

Re: After using the IKEA LED lights......

George Guadiane

I still use my IKEA lights, but I have seen and used the new one. The magnet is STRONG and the light is near blinding. I was VERY impressed. If I didn't already have an EXTRA half dozen or so of the IKEAs, I'd be all over this lamp.

Re: LED Work Light

#7

Re: LED Work Light

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Thanks to all for the input and LED education. I had made up my mind to pass on this tempting LED light and then George threw in his "glowing" recommendation. Now, I have a decision to make.

Re: LED Work Light

#8

Re: LED Work Light

Jeff Smith

For what it's worth, I replaced the bulb in the Moffet light that's mounted to the headstock of my lathe with an LED bulb from Lowes that I thought was exorbitantly priced at nearly $30.00. It's got the output of about a 75 watt tungsten bulb, better color balance and it's lasted for nearly two years now. I had been replacing the 60 watt tungsten bulbs every three or four months. I don't remember the brand, but it came in a round plastic tube and looks like a regular bulb from the front, but the base has what looks like a heatsink just above the threaded base. If it lasts long enough to recoup the investment, I'll look for another one.

Re: LED Work Light

#9

Re: LED Work Light

Jerry Klug

I have mounted an Ikea light on my bandsaw to illuminate right at the blade. It makes seeing the cut very clear and bright. The only problem is that I keep bumping the light stem (neck?) when I pass the bandsaw. I have limited room in my shop. I have been surprised that each time I turn the thing on that it still works. When I hit it the sound is a loud clank of the bulb housing bouncing off the blade guard. I consider these lights pretty tough.

LED lights are steadily becoming better bargains as more come into the market. Reminds me of the flat scteen TV pricing.

Re: LED Work Light

#10

Re: LED Work Light

walta

I have a pair of IKEA LED lamps on my lathe.

Today I worked in the Craft Supplies booth at the woodworkers show teaching newbie’s to turn pens each lathe had one of their lights. The goose neck is nice and long and stays in place. The magnetic base looks like it came from a dial indicator with a release lever. The light is a good color and quantity. I could clearly see the sanding scratches when present. The light head is slightly smaller than GU10 without the socket and shorter than MR 16 with a socket. So making the Led replaceable would make the head bigger. The larger the head the more it is in your way. If the LED lasts ½ the 50000 hours claim and you operated it 5 hours a week will you be alive in 2109 to look for that old fashion GU10 LED bulb?

Led lights are unlikely to fail from vibration or a short fall.

Craft Supplies did not ask me to write this.

Craft Supplies has never paid me any money.

Craft Supplies has given me and my club gift certificates

Craft Supplies has allowed me and my club to promote my club in there booth at the Wood working show.

Walta

Re: LED Work Light

#11

Dick Hines

Re: LED Work Light

Dick Hines

I have of of the LED lights but like my Moffatt ones better. The switch died the first week. I did learn dot to use regular bulbs in the Moffatt. They get to hot. I went to fluoescent bulbs. Not because Uncle Sam think's it's a good idea. The regular bulbs get so hot chips will start to smolder.

Re: LED Work Light

#12

Re: After using the IKEA LED lights......

Steve Mushinski

Jamie,

They are very directional but I have to say I like mine very much. They are not going to light up a large area but I love mine on my bandsaw, drill press and I found I needed at least two on the lathe.

For 15 bucks one cannot complain too much.