Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

sharpening vs cutting

Posts

sharpening vs cutting

#1

sharpening vs cutting

John Lucas

I know the sharpening test is going to be fun and I'll probably learn some things but. there are 3 or 4 factors that are probably just as or more important. Well you do have to be able to get a decent edge for these to be a factor but my initial tests show that there is very little difference in the cut quality on many woods.

The 3 things that are related to sharpening are, angle of attack of the blade, how acute the cutting edge is, and how it's pushed through the wood.

A really sharp blade will of course be better for each of these but the fact remains if you approach the wood with a poor cutting angle and a blunt edge forcing the cut against the grain you will not get a good cut.

So first things first. Skew the cut if possible. This will always give a cleaner cut than if the wood hits the blade perpendicular to the edge. The more skewed the cleaner the cut (but of course it's slower). The less skewed the faster the cut but less clean.

An acute edge will cut cleaner and easier than a blunt edge. I don't think Blunt is the proper word for that but let's just say a 25 degree edge will cut cleaner than a 55 or 75 degree edge. There are reasons for these angles and you can't always have the best of 2 worlds and still have a bevel rubbing cut.

Cutting downhill with the grain and not forcing the cut are possibly more important than the other 3 although they are all very closely related. Always try to cut down hill with respect to the grain if possible. On turning this is usually cutting from the high point to the low point on spindles. Bowls and hollow vessels vary on grain direction so look closely. DON'T FORCE THE CUT. Slow down, relax, let the too do the work. If you are pushing the tool into the work you are not getting as clean of a cut as you can. Sometimes simply speeding up the work will let you cut at the proper speed. Too slow and you tend to push the tool through the work.

If you do those 3 things then you will have a good clean surface that needs little sanding. The sharpening techniques I'm exploring simply add to these to make turning more fun.

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#2

Re: sharpening vs cutting

waltben

I've not your plethora of sharpening gizmos, but the one thing I've found that gives my edges an edge is honing. I don't use slip stones - just a cheap & very old bench top grinder with two sewn cloth wheels and diamond rouge. My tools are almost all 2030, powdered or similar hardness, and I'll spend a a minute or two buffing/honing each after grinding until I can't see much of the grinding lines any more. Several folks have told me that this improved edge doesn't last but a few minutes, but I disagree. It certainly lasts much longer than it takes to make it and really improves cutting performance. Since I've multiple gouges of the same size and type, I use each until I need to resharpen all. Lets me turn non-stop for an hour or so at minimum, no matter what species of wood.

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#3

Re: sharpening vs cutting

robo hippy

Yea, it is a mixed bag of skills. If it isn't sharp, you will have to sand a lot more, no matter how you present the tool to the wood.

A scraping cut, either with a gouge or a scraper is basically the cutting edge 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood, or scraper flat on the tool rest, or gouge with handle level, and both flutes pointing at the wood. Scraping cuts will 'pull' the fiber, and is much more prone to tear out.

Shear angle is the critical thing here. Scraping cut = 0 degree shear angle. Most shear cuts are around 45 degrees or so. I like higher when I can get it, and find a fluteless gouge from Doug Thompson (also bowl skew from Dave Hout, and to a lesser degree, the skewchigouge) with a ) profile on the nose, and you work on the lower 1/3 of the blade. This same cut can be done with a scraper with the same nose angle. With this nose profile, it is easy to get a 70 degree or higher shear angle. The higher the shear angle, the more gentle the cut is as it does a better job of getting under the wood and 'lifting' the fiber up as it cuts rather than pulling. I compare it to speed bumps in the parking lots. If you hit them straight on (scraping cut) there is a big bump. If you hit them from an angle, the bump is smoothed out a great deal (shear cut).

The difference in shear cuts is bevel rubbing and non bevel rubbing (some times called a shear scrape). In my experimenting, with wet wood, there is little difference in quality of cut. With dry wood, again, not a lot of difference. With soft, punky and highly figured wood, the bevel rub produces a much cleaner surface. I guess the bevel rubbing cut actually helps hold down the fiber as you make the cut where the non bevel rubbing cut does not.

I don't think 'shear scrape' is an accurate term. 'Scrape' implies 0 shear angle to me. Not sure what to call it though.

Then, there is learning to control the tool through the cut so you have a smooth even surface with minimal start and stop marks, and minimal bumps and humps to sand out. This is all holding the tool steady, and learning to move with your body. This is where Tai Chi comes in. I took it up long after I started turning. Gee, I already do these moves as I turn. Just have to add the breathing part.

robo hippy

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#4

Brad Vietje

I'd Add Another Factor

Brad Vietje

I agree entirely John. I'd add another consideration, though. The size of the tool and/or curvature of the cutting edge also has a role to play.

The nose radius can be important, and a smaller radius means a tighter curve at the tip, and in the end, a smaller chip, or cut. Since smaller cuts take less force (like adding skew angle), there is less cutting resistance, fewer torn fibers, less vibration, and a cleaner cut.

This applies to the inside flute radius of a bowl gouge as well as the shape of the tip of a spindle or detail gouge. A V-flute can be used like a very rugged 1/4" or even 1/8" gouge, if it is shaped so you can get that small radius at the bottom of the flute in there to make the cuts. That's why some people can make tiny details on delicate work (like goblet stems) with nothing smaller than a 5/8" bowl gouge, which they can also use to rough out big bowls.

Interesting stuff!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#5

Boy do I agree.   


Re: sharpening vs cutting

#6

Re: sharpening vs cutting

robo hippy

The reason I prefer a broader nose on my tools for finish cuts is that they have a larger sweet spot for cutting, while the more pointy tools are great for getting into tight spots, but not as good for general finish cuts, because of a smaller sweet spot. The more pointy they are, they better suited they are for dropped handle cuts where more cutting is being done with the wing rather than the nose of the gouge, and again, a bigger sweet spot.

robo hippy

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#7

Re: I'd Add Another Factor

Lloyd in Mississauga

I agree with that one as well. Most of my bowl gouges so far have been more of a U-V cross. I have gotten very use to being able to open the tool and increase the cutting edge to the wood as the flute size changes. I got a broader U fluted bowl gouge and when I first started using it, it was supper aggressive for me. I was not use to using such a broad cutting edge and could not seem to close the tool down enough.

After using it more, I found other uses for that style of flute that works better than the tighter U-V style for me.

Sharpening gets you to the game, and then tools presentation to the wood starts bringing you points. No sharp tools, then tool presentation is not going to get you too far.

Lloyd

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#8

Re: sharpening vs cutting

Don in Central Illinois

As John Jordan said at a demo, "An almost sharp tool will almost cut."

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#9

The wider cutting edge on the tip .....

JamieDonaldson

...of my Thompson U 1/2" gouge makes a great tool for small spindle work like finials. The wider tip radius is less subject to catches than the more pointy tips of regular spindle gouges.

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#10

Re: The wider cutting edge on the tip .....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

Catches? Jamie, you get catches?

I use my 2060 1/4 inch bowl gouge for spindle work quite a bit. Maybe it's because I do more bowl turning than spindle turning and am used to bowl gouges.

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Can of worms ???

Jesper, Denmark

John, I think you are opening a can of worms here. The subject can be just as many faceted as the discussions of tool steel on the Neanderthal forum. There are many more aspects to this than the three you mention.

Just a few:

The angle of attack between the cutting edge and the wood IMHO is the major factor in cuts without rubbing the bevel. The relief angle betwen the cut wood and the back of the tool ahds no real influence, hence the acute vs stump sharpening angle should not have any influence.

The Michaelson grind is given many "features", but is it not really just a way to present a stump angled (60°) tool at a more acute angle by having relieved the back to be able to rub the bevel?

Stump angled tools work better in bowl turning than acute angled spindle gouges. Slim, acute angled spindel tools tend to vibrate under load - which is generally not a big problem in spindle turning, but a major factor in taking large cuts in bowls. Detail spindle gouges tend to have smaller flutes and more metal behind the flute - to avoid vibration??

We have a motley group of around 20 turners here, who meet informally about once a month at a workshop in Copenhagen. Of these, many do show their techniques and demonstrate informally. One common factor is that all of the demonstrated techniques seem to work - and that they all use different tools and sharpen differently and preent the tool differently to the wood. Tools vary from latest and greatest technology to home made from old pipes and (hopefuly annealed) old files.

Typically, when we turn, we cannot see what the tool is really doing - only the result. Tool presentation is done by feel for the sweet spot and watching the result on the other side of the bowl. This makes geometric anaylsis of how and why very difficult.

Re: sharpening vs cutting

#12

Wally, I have heard stories about..

JamieDonaldson

.. catches from other turners, and some of those reports have had more graphic details than I choose to know about! :D