sharpening vs cutting
John Lucas
I know the sharpening test is going to be fun and I'll probably learn some things but. there are 3 or 4 factors that are probably just as or more important. Well you do have to be able to get a decent edge for these to be a factor but my initial tests show that there is very little difference in the cut quality on many woods.
The 3 things that are related to sharpening are, angle of attack of the blade, how acute the cutting edge is, and how it's pushed through the wood.
A really sharp blade will of course be better for each of these but the fact remains if you approach the wood with a poor cutting angle and a blunt edge forcing the cut against the grain you will not get a good cut.
So first things first. Skew the cut if possible. This will always give a cleaner cut than if the wood hits the blade perpendicular to the edge. The more skewed the cleaner the cut (but of course it's slower). The less skewed the faster the cut but less clean.
An acute edge will cut cleaner and easier than a blunt edge. I don't think Blunt is the proper word for that but let's just say a 25 degree edge will cut cleaner than a 55 or 75 degree edge. There are reasons for these angles and you can't always have the best of 2 worlds and still have a bevel rubbing cut.
Cutting downhill with the grain and not forcing the cut are possibly more important than the other 3 although they are all very closely related. Always try to cut down hill with respect to the grain if possible. On turning this is usually cutting from the high point to the low point on spindles. Bowls and hollow vessels vary on grain direction so look closely. DON'T FORCE THE CUT. Slow down, relax, let the too do the work. If you are pushing the tool into the work you are not getting as clean of a cut as you can. Sometimes simply speeding up the work will let you cut at the proper speed. Too slow and you tend to push the tool through the work.
If you do those 3 things then you will have a good clean surface that needs little sanding. The sharpening techniques I'm exploring simply add to these to make turning more fun.




