Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Oneway versus McNaughton

Posts

Oneway versus McNaughton

#1

Oneway versus McNaughton

Starry Chan

Because of my trouble with the Oneway Easy-Core #2 support blade, I start thinking about the need for the support blade.

With the McNaughton coring system, the cutter blade is supported by the gate near the entry point. There is no support as the blade is pushed into the bowl blank. With the Oneway, the cutting blade can also be supported by the support blade or the support blade post at the entry point without advancing it as the cut progresses. It looks likes that the Oneway blade is also constructed heavier than the McNaughton blade so it should be able to cut without the support blade under it. The cut will definitely be more stable if the support blade is advanced. However, I am wondering whether the support blade is really needed.

Starry

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#2

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

Dick Coers

Really needed? No. Want less vibration and smoother cut? Yes. I have the Woodcut, and isn't as glamorous and expensive as the two systems you mentioned. But, you get very predictable cuts and good results. No support arm with it.

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#3

Re: Support post height?  ??

Doc Green

Starry, Have you checked the height of the support post and support blade? The support blade is curved to match the cut, and if the height is off, it could rub against the kerf.

McNaughton vs. Oneway. I voted for, and purchased Oneway. No regrets and no issues. But, of all woodturning operations, I like coring the least. ~Doc

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#4

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

robo hippy

DO NOT CORE WITH THE ONEWAY WITHOUT THE SUPPORT FINGER!!!!!!!! High level of danger of blade bending/breaking if you do. You can core with the Woodcut without the support finger, but the biggest blade they have is 5 inch radius. Even with some of the softer woods, you will get chatter. This is a short arm lever, and just like with hand held turning tools, if you hang out too far, you will get chatter. Their 5 inch blade is right on the edge of hanging out too far. You can hang out farther with the McNaughton. You have an in line long lever arm, with most of it on the back side of the support gate. As with the Woodcut, the biggest blades are right on the edge of hanging out too far.

robo hippy

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#5

the February issue of American Woodturner...

GaryG in MD

has a very long, highly descriptive, and overall excellent article on how coring systems work and has a detailed comparison of the three widely available systems. After you read that, you won't have any more questions. (It should be in the mail shortly.) ...GG

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#6

Re: the February issue of American Woodturner...

Tim Aley

I got mine today and there is also a great article on wood bleach! ;)

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#7

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

Dale Bonertz

I agree with Robo. You asking for trouble using the oneway without the support finger. I have used all three and they all work well within their designed limitations. The woodcut only goes so big for a reason. I heard they are trying to make a larger blade for their system but so far nothing and again for a reason. The system won't handle it. The oneway will not work well without its support finger and may be down right dangerous. McNaughton can also only go so big in each blade range for a reason. Coring is one of many processes in turning that no one should push the limits of the tools ability.

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

#8

Re: Oneway versus McNaughton

Vince Welch

Hi Starry,

Reed is totally correct! You want the support arm with the Oneway! Some some of the coring systems offer more than one shape you may be able to core with. When it came down to it... I realized that I was going to be coring bowls... not platters or anything else. The Oneway coring system was a perfect fit for my application and it never has failed me. However, the key I have found to success with this unit is 400-500 speed, keep the cutting VERY VERY SHARP always, and keep the chips blown out. Also, do yourself a favor and use this or any coring on wet wood if possible. Going in I thought "do I really need this?" After having purchased this system I seen clearly and quickly how this system paid for itself and has done so many times over. JMO. Vince