Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

sharpening system testing

Posts

sharpening system testing

#1

sharpening system testing

John Lucas

As of yesterday I now have the 4 most popular sharpening systems and I will be testing them against each other. I don't expect to have a winner because they are so many other factors such as cost, sharpening other tools besides turning, life of the stones, belts, etc but I think it will be a great learning experience for me and of course I'll share it.

I can say that I am really impressed with the CBN wheel so far. There is apparently a break in period for the wheel and I'm told I'll like it even more once the grit settles in. Right out of the box it runs absolutely true. The bushing that came with it fits perfectly (god I love sliding metal parts together that have no slop). It cuts almost aggressively. It's a 180 grit wheel but cuts faster than my 100 grit white wheels. I'm told that will change slightly when it gets broken in. It will supposedly cut a little less aggresive and give a smoother edge, both good things.

I did have to move my Oneway jig slightly to better align with the wheel. I also had to grind some screw stampings on my wheel guards to put them back on. You don't need them now because this thing can't explode like a grinding wheel. However I have kids over occasionally and this thing is heavy enough that the grinder takes a long time to run down and don't want someone touching the wheel accidentally.

What I would like is some help evaluating the various system. I have A Tormek wet wheel grinder, a Lee Valley 1" strip sander, a Slow speed grinder with white wheels, and the CBN wheel. What would you test? give me your pros and cons of the various systems, and how do I evaluate the actual cutting results? This is not going to be a scientific, engineering full blown write up. Based on the nature of my skills it's going to be seat of the pants, and probably subjective but I'll do my best. Feel free to write me personanly rather than clog up all of this space. If you own one of these systems or even another system let me know the pros and cons so I have a better understanding of what to look for.

Re: sharpening system testing

#2

Alan Zenreich

Re: sharpening system testing

Alan Zenreich

So you need a new hobby, eh?

You are going to evaluate the different machines, but at the same time complicate things by comparing the flat, concave and convex grinds possible.

Then you'd need to compare each of the grinds on each type of tool profile, and see how they work on each type of material for each type of cut.

I'm so glad you're retired... this could be a full time job.

You are welcome to visit my shop to add to the confusion. Along with a slow speed bench grinder, I also have a 2"x72" belt grinder (my favorite) with an 8" serrated rubber contact wheel (though I also have a flat platen that I rarely use)... and a JoolTool. They are three very different approaches to sharpening and metal shaping.

Re: sharpening system testing

#3

Re: sharpening system testing

Bill Howatt

I think Leonard Lee of Lee Valley fame uses an electron microscope but I don't know how you would turn one. :)

Good luck on the project and I agree that it certainly might turn into a very ambitious one given all the factors involved.

Bill

Re: sharpening system testing

#4

Re: sharpening system testing

Starry Chan

John,

Where do you purchase your CBN wheel?

Starry

Re: sharpening system testing

#5

Re: sharpening system testing

robo hippy

The only sharpening tool I don't have that I really, really, really want is Stuart Batty's Omni Grinder. In Minneapolis he said it would be out in August. In San Jose, he said it would be out in August, and last week, he said it would be out in August. Sheer torture.........

I do not have a tool buying problem........

robo hippy

Re: sharpening system testing

#6

I feel your pain   


Re: sharpening system testing

#7

D-way tools  *LINK*


http://www.d-waytools.com/

Re: sharpening system testing

#8

Re: I feel your pain 

Peter Lamb

John you may wish to check out the new Johannes Michelson grinding system. I had a chance to test drive it in Florida last weeked and it solves a numnber of issues

Re: sharpening system testing

#9

To start with

Dale Bonertz

would you test the grinder with the CBN and regular wheels. I currently have two grinders with 120 grit AO wheels. Norton blue wheel from Craft Supplies in 80 grit and a 60 grit 3X wheel. So far it seems that the 60 Grit 3x and blue 80 grit sharpen very similar. My 3x wheel is nearing where I need to replace it and I am considering the CBN. My research has shown me that the CBN wheels are not supposed to be used for sharpening tools without a coolant. I know the people selling them say otherwise but I choose to believe a scientist/metallurgist (at least for now) rather than someone who is trying to make money on them. Even some of the people who sell them, outside the woodturning community, say they are to be used with coolant when sharpening tool steel. So if you don't mind I would appreciate your thoughts and comments on that once you have ran some tests. I figure you will but I hope you can stay unbiased between systems.

As a side note I know someone who blew through his CBN wheel in a year but he makes tools and is a very heavy user. He did not use a coolant.

Re: sharpening system testing

#10

Re: sharpening system testing

steve worcester

I had a bit of trouble with the CBN wheels on my Woodcraft slow speed, so I bought a Baldor. That solved the problem.

As far as jigs and such, I used the Oneway setup for a long time, then became a Sharpfast dealer (yes, I sell them)

http://sharpfast.com/sharpfast/SharpFast%20Flyer.pdf

and everyone who uses it loves it. Much simpler to use.

I have the Stuart Batty platform on one side (adapted to the Oneway slides), and it is fantastic. But if you have an existing Oneway setup and get it, you will have to realign everything as it needs the bases further back than the Oneway does.

Re: sharpening system testing

#11

Re: sharpening system testing

John Scheideman

Johannes Michelsen also has the CBN wheels at his website at Hannestools.com

Re: sharpening system testing

#12

Re: I feel your pain 

John Lucas

I looked at it but didn't have time to talk to him at the TAW symposium. I'm not sure what issues it does answer. He does have the CBN wheel I think. I did build a sort of wooden version of his sharpening guide but I don't think I got all the dimensions right. I was guessing.

Re: sharpening system testing

#13

Re: To start with

John Lucas

I've talked to 3 moderately long time users of CBN wheels. None of them use coolant and absolutely love the wheels. It does say not to sharpen mild steel or carbide on the CBN. HSS and Powdered metal tools are OK.

Re: sharpening system testing

#14

Don Leydens

Re: sharpening system testing

Don Leydens

I think you're going to love the CBN wheel, John. I've had one for months and I'm so glad I got it. Look forward to your results.

Re: sharpening system testing

#15

Re: To start with

Dale Bonertz

Everyone I talk to love the wheels including my long time mentor. I have seen many fad items over the years so I like to wait and see, as it were, to figure out if they are for real. Personally I hope the CBN wheels are for real because I think the dust thing or lack thereof is a huge advantage. I also like to research things beyond the sales pitch of a seller and then repeated by their customers. Here is one of the articles I found interesting on grinding wheels. Towards the end they get into diamond and CBN wheels. I found it very interesting.

http://www.georgiagrindingwheel.com/grindingwheels_basics.htm#faq1

Good luck on your research. I am anxiously awaiting your thoughts and what you have discovered.

Dale

Re: sharpening system testing

#16

Re: sharpening system testing

dick gerard

John, and all my WC friends!

I wish you all could see my face! My CBN wheel arrived Saturday, I wasn’t home so Post Office didn’t leave it. Picked it up this morning at 8:05 AM. Had it home and mounted by 9:00. Only problem was that the grinder I have has a 2 part guard held tegether with 5 screws. This releases a shallow metal outer guard. I don’t see how to remove the inner guard. Mounted the wheel per instructions. Wheel pressed against inner guard and would not rotate. So, I removed the wheel, placed washer on first, then the flange and wheel and finally the nut. The washer gave me exactly the clearance I needed. Now I just have to go the hardware store and purchase a washer for the nut side of the wheel.

Since I have been back in the shop with the grinder running non-stop, sharpening gouge after gouge after gouge ... I have lots of gouges! detail gouges, spindle gouges, bowl gouges, specially ground gouges, Sharpened all my skews, beading tools (yours), teardrop tool, scrapers and lots of other HSS tools.

Then came the real test. I started turning some really nasty osage orange, some contrary grained cherry, followed by some mesquite, some manzanita and some Australian ring gidgee. The new edges from the D-Way CBN tools is amazingly sharp! After nearly 3 hours of continual cutting with just one gouge, I gave the edge and the flute a quick hone with the CBN hone and .... voila! The edge was good as new.

I can honestly say that I wish I had purchased this wheel and hone when you first made them available. Even if that had meant using the evil dreaded credit card! Anyway, should anyone ask, please feel free to use my story. And, yes, I am as happy as I can remember in over 30 years of woodturning.

Throw away your old stone age stone wheels and join the 21st century! Count me as one of the converted.

dick gerard

aka bowlman