sharpening system testing
John Lucas
As of yesterday I now have the 4 most popular sharpening systems and I will be testing them against each other. I don't expect to have a winner because they are so many other factors such as cost, sharpening other tools besides turning, life of the stones, belts, etc but I think it will be a great learning experience for me and of course I'll share it.
I can say that I am really impressed with the CBN wheel so far. There is apparently a break in period for the wheel and I'm told I'll like it even more once the grit settles in. Right out of the box it runs absolutely true. The bushing that came with it fits perfectly (god I love sliding metal parts together that have no slop). It cuts almost aggressively. It's a 180 grit wheel but cuts faster than my 100 grit white wheels. I'm told that will change slightly when it gets broken in. It will supposedly cut a little less aggresive and give a smoother edge, both good things.
I did have to move my Oneway jig slightly to better align with the wheel. I also had to grind some screw stampings on my wheel guards to put them back on. You don't need them now because this thing can't explode like a grinding wheel. However I have kids over occasionally and this thing is heavy enough that the grinder takes a long time to run down and don't want someone touching the wheel accidentally.
What I would like is some help evaluating the various system. I have A Tormek wet wheel grinder, a Lee Valley 1" strip sander, a Slow speed grinder with white wheels, and the CBN wheel. What would you test? give me your pros and cons of the various systems, and how do I evaluate the actual cutting results? This is not going to be a scientific, engineering full blown write up. Based on the nature of my skills it's going to be seat of the pants, and probably subjective but I'll do my best. Feel free to write me personanly rather than clog up all of this space. If you own one of these systems or even another system let me know the pros and cons so I have a better understanding of what to look for.




