So, all of this talk about carbides in steel had me pondering...
Why haven't we seen a tool that is made the way samurai swords were made? The metalsmiths would forge together layers in an anvil weld and alternate edge holding capabilities with more flexible steels to create legendary performance in their blades.
Rather than making an entire bar out of 15V or whatever, what if only the flute section was the carbide heavy material and the regular shank was whatever standard steel it needed to be. Only the bit of an axe is "good steel."
Sounds similar to the older laminated plane blades where they would forge weld a piece of "good" steel to the softer iron to produce a better cutting edge.
a) The McNaughten coring knives are "regular" steel with a 1/8" layer of HSS steel bonded on the top surface of the point. This why they tell you to never grind the top surface of the knife as you'll just take off all the "good" metal.
b) You're doing the very same thing when you screw a carbide or high alloy cutter on the end of a tool shaft.
While it looks really cool on a long cutting edge, not sure the Damascus folded process would net us much for tools.
Stuart Batty's new tools, or at least a number of them, incorporate lamination of of A11/CPM 10V steel with another steel or sandwiched between layers of a lesser grade steel for support.
The concept is many instances is to make available a replaceable cutting section without having to buy a completely new tool.
I haven't seen any of these tools but the concept is interesting as is the taperlock system for mounting tools in his patented handles.
For our "out of the box thinkers" (you know who you are:)) take some time and read a couple of sites. Google up tatara steelmaking method and you will get some hits. Read the Hitachi Metals>Tale of Tatara>The Tatara Iron Manufacturing Method reference and the Japanesesword.com site reference. Hitachi Metals in Yasugi, Japan makes, as an accomodation to the samarai and damascus sword makers, quantities of Tatara steel a few times per year. They use the traditional method in a historic site with volunteers. The output of the Tatara process (which starts with heat, carbon, and iron ore) is a mixture of steels with very low to very high levels of carbon and hence varying hardening potentials. It is separated by breaking up the pile of reduced iron ore. The high carbon portions fracture easily, while the low carbon materials are too tough to break. There is a museum next to the Hitachi plant (Wako Museum) which is a monumement to tatara steelmaking. Hitachi began in Yasugi because of the iron-sand natural resources.
The low carbon materials are sandwiched between pieces of high carbon material and forge welded into a sword shape. Prior to heat treatment, various portions of the sword are painted with different thicknesses of clay. As a result, during cooling, some areas cooling faster than others resulting in softer tangs and blade backs and harder cuttting edges.
I expect Messrs. Antonuccii, Mandell and Lucas will lead the charge to set out and make a Woodcentral batch. Remember: Heat, carbon, iron ore are all you need ...... and maybe some beer!!!
I did observe an iron smelt at Peters Valley once... it is amazing to me to see the things that were produced hundreds of years ago without access to the processes and equipment we have today. I think my knowledge of metallurgy could fill a thimble... and my knowledge of blacksmithing would barely be enough to make it overflow.
I'm not quitting my day job to become a Damascus Turning Tool Maker....
Wasn't that stuff called "Tamahagane" or something similar, I have an old Japanese wood carving gouge made out of that stuff had it dated to the 16 century, expert said it would have belonged to a MASTER carver of very high note (found it in a junk shop too!!!)
.......austenitic or ferritic hops in the quenching beer???
I think the phase diagrams would change if you quenched in India Pale Ale versus something a bit heavier, such as an Imperial Stout or a Doppelbock....?? Would beer style effect carbide particle size?
Tamahagane is indeed what they call the iron-carbon alloy produced in the tatara furnace. If you are interested, Google Hitachi tatara. They have a number of references - as in sections in a brochure on the Hitachi Steel Co. Development around the tatara furnace.
I visited Hitachi in Yasugi about 10 times. Once they brought out a number of really old swords from their archives. They were really long and heavy. They had to be really difficult to swing!
Rob- Actually the early Sheffield steelmakers were the first to become acquainted with Gibbs and applied his phase rule to the brewing of beer. The first beers to result from this technology were Old Speckled Hen and Spitfire. As to the impact upon carbide size, the steelmakers found that steel quenched in a tank holding a minimum of 4 barrels produced the finest carbides. Also, they found that their waste recycling practices with especially Old Speckled Hen also produced the finest buzz.
Steve I was thinking about this last night and of course the reason we aren't seeing tools made like the Japanese swords is two fold. First of course is the labor, I've read that they can spend a month sharpening. Gosh and I thought spending a few minutes on a plane blade or carving tool was getting long.
Second is the materials. although they were state of the art back then and probably still might be from a pure sword weapon point of view. However they are severely lacking by todays standards of metallurgy.
My understanding of the powdered metal technology is that you can put more material in the metal with this method than you can by forging or smelting alone. Vanadium being the one we are most interested in for edge durability.
Carbide cutters have also taken a new direction with the smaller grain carbide that some call Nano carbide. Wouldn't make a good sword because it's more brittle but I'll bet it would cut right through some armour.
Oh and did you know the swords have a convex edge to more easily slice through flesh.