Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Salad finish over oil?

Posts

Salad finish over oil?

#1

Dick Hines

Salad finish over oil?

Dick Hines

I did a hollow for for a guy and now he wants a shinny finish. Can I put salad bowl finish over Watco that has been drying for a month? I don't do shinny finished very often so not really sure.

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#2

Quick and dirty

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Rattle-can lacquer. Mixwax builds better and has a better spray nozzle than Deft. Rub it down with 4-0 wool, vac off well, apply 4 light coats about an hour and a half apart. Let sit for 3 days. If the guy wants "Duh Shiney", apply 4 more coats, wait a week and hand buff with Meguire's No. 5 and No. 9 [auto parts store]

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#3

Re: Salad finish over oil?

Cindy Drozda

The professional finishers say that lacquer will go over Watco after 72 hrs.

My favorite water look shiny is minwax wipe on poly. wipe on & turn the lathe on really slow until it sets up. A couple or 3 coats will do.

My favorite rattle can is Krylon. It's acrylic lacquer, I believe.

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#4

depends how shiny...

GaryG in MD

You could do it without any more added product is your client would be happy with a nice satiny shine. Just Abralon it by hand from 500 up to 4000 and wax. (I use carnauba for the depth of shine and then Renaissance wax to help deter fingerprinting.) It'll be shiny enough to show all the sanding scratches! DAMHIK. It'll still look like wood, not plastic, which, for most people, is the goal. ...GG

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#5

Re: depends how shiny...

Jim Breeden

GaryG: So all those sanding scratches that show through the wax, even down to Abralon 5000, are ok as long as it doesn't look like plastic ? Am I sweating over an irritated nothing ? :b

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: depends how shiny...

Harry Robinette

Some time try Staples Crystal Clear wax no silicone or bees wax leaves very nice finish. Also cost about 1/4 of the Renaissance wax and no finger prints after it sets.

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#7

Thanks for the tip, Harry.


Re: Salad finish over oil?

#8

no, no, no!

GaryG in MD

Jim,

When I said: "It'll be shiny enough to show all the sanding scratches! DAMHIK. *** It'll still look like wood, not plastic, which, for most people, is the goal.", those are two independent thoughts. There's meant to be a big pause between those sentences. That pause is the time it takes to go back and sand out the scratches before returning to 1000 and then doing 2000 and 4000. When you get to 4000, with all the scratches removed, then it looks like satiny wood and not plastic. No, scratches are NOT ACCEPTIBLE!!!

I HATE scratches! I'm very near sighted, and I can see them as if I'm using a magnifying glass. But, no matter how hard I try, I usually end up with a few subtle ones (that many people wouldn't even see). It's very difficult to see them before the remainder of the surface gets to about 1000. Then they glare out at you with a sneer. This is a great reason for only going to 400 or 600 and calling it a day. But, IMO, the grain doesn't really pop at that level. It's fine for everyday, utility bowls, but I like to make pieces for "show". When I get to 1000 and find the inevitable scratch or two, I go back as far as I think I need to to remove it/them. Often, I can do this with the 500 Abralon (my first choice), but sometimes, if they're bad enough, I may have to go back all the way to 320 sandpaper, and then back up the ladder to 400 and 600 sandpaper and 500 Abralon before returning to 1000 and up from there. That may sound strange, but I find that Abralon 500 is "effectively" finer than 600 sandpaper. (And yes, I know the different scales.) Sanding sponges (like Abralon) just don't leave scratches like sandpaper does. That's one reason I love the stuff. ...GG

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#9

Re: no, no, no!

Jim Breeden

Thanks for the info Gary. I am also near sighted and, for some reason, see all those scratches - which drives me crazy. I want to see the subtle differences in the grain, not a plastic coating, even to the point of feelin the grain. Then I know it's made by hand, not poured into a mold.

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#10

I totally agree!


Re: Salad finish over oil?

#11

Re: depends how shiny...

Jim Breeden

Harry: Where do I find the Staples Crystal Clear ?

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#12

Harry Robinette

Re: depends how shiny...

Harry Robinette

I mine at Woodcraft.

Re: Salad finish over oil?

#13

Re: depends how shiny...

Jim Breeden

Thanks Harry.....It's a looooooong way to a Woodcraft from here, Denver I think.

:b Got to find something on-line from Woodcraft to justify...heh, heh, heh.