Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

My new sharpener

Posts

My new sharpener

#1

My new sharpener

John Lucas

I bought one of the Lee Valley strip sanders. I want to see how it will do for sharpening turning tools. I built some attachments to make it more user friendly. I built an attachment for the Wolverine jig. I built an attachment that functions like the V arm and it came with a tool rest which I modified.

The original tool rest had a bolt that was pretighted to lock the tool rest in place. It was stiff and hard to move and would probably get loose over time. I replaced it with a carriage bolt that was longer. Put a tightening knob on the end and added a spacer to take up some slack so the whole thing would lock down. Works great.

I am ordering new belts in finer grits to see how it does. It came with a 120 which is a little finer than my grinder stones. It put a nice edge on my spindle roughing gouge. I can't find the Blue Zirconia belts finer than 120. Anyone know where to get them. I can buy the aluminum oxide belts up to 320. I was hoping to find 600. Can't find those either. At least not yet.






Re: My new sharpener

#3

Re: My new sharpener

John Lucas

Thanks Alan. Not sure why it states Klingspor has 600, 800 and 1000 when Klingspor doesn't list them in their catalog. I guess I'll have to call and find out.

Re: My new sharpener

#5

Thanks  gonna give Klinspor a call this morning


Re: My new sharpener

#6

Re: My new sharpener

Mark ravensdale

I was using the sorby pro-edge belt sharpener for about 12-18 months but ended up putting it back in the box, it got the tools sharp but they just didn't cut as well as a tool sharpened on my bench grinder, to this day I don't know why but they didn't, I stuck with it thinking "you'll get used to it" but I didn't even after 18 months!!!

And the worst part is it cost me close to £500 (uk pounds) to find this out!!!

Good luck John hope you have better luck than me.

Re: My new sharpener

#7

Re: My new sharpener

Paul Vechart

Nice job John...what direction is the belt running?

Re: My new sharpener

#8

Re: My new sharpener

John Lucas

Mark What tools were you sharpening. I used mine today with a 120 grit Zirconia belt and it sharpened it as good as my 100 grit white wheel. that was on a Thompson bowl gouge.

Re: My new sharpener

#9

Re: My new sharpener

John Lucas

It's running up. I decided to go with the wood carvers direction since I might use it for wood carving tools as well as turning.

Re: My new sharpener

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: My new sharpener

Brad Vietje

Looks great, John!

I'll be interested to read the results of your side-by-side testing -- which is really the way to do it.

In my experience, all these systems can get the tools equally sharp, but a well-designed sand & buff system is just faster and easier, and especially for the beginner, less to learn and much less stressful. With easily indexed positions for the V-block, easy to get the same results consistently.

The 1" belt is wider than many wheels, but still not as care-free as a wider belt, at least as far as speed and ease of use go. Should be a real good comparison of the different methods.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: My new sharpener

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: My new sharpener

Brad Vietje

Sorry to read this, Mark!

While I'm a strong advocate for sand and buff sharpening systems, and while the Sorby machine looks rugged and well-built, I have not tried their machine.

Were you finding the tools not sharp enough, or did you find it difficult to use? What grit was used? I find that after initial shaping with a lower grit belt (and/or a wheel), the edge can be maintained with a much finer grit than we are used to in grinding wheel terms -- typically 180-, 220-, and even 320-grit belts. This also results in a keener edge and a more polished bevel, with less of a bur. Does the Pro Edge have a provision for increasing the belt tension, or bringing the platen toward you just a tiny bit? Here's why I ask...

Sorby made two important mistakes in this design, IMHO:

1) The belt goes the wrong way***, which would not be much of a problem with a tight enough belt if they also kept the speed down (I don't know the belt travel in FPS for this unit). If the speed is high, and/or the belt just a little bit too loose, the belt will ride up on a tiny cushion of air, and thus where the tool pushes the belt against the platen (right at the cutting edge) there could be a tiny bit of round-over in exactly the worst possible place. If this is causing a not-quite-sharp cutting edge, you may be able to get rid of it by a little more belt tension, or by moving and/or shimming the platen toward you a little bit, though the speed may be harder to tweak. In models with the belt running the other way, any round-over happens at the heel of the bevel, which is usually very desirable for reducing any wood fiber bruising or tearing inside bowls. I have even loosened the belt a bit on such a machine (home-made knock-off of Jon Siegel's design) to get even more round-over of the heel.



2) There's no buffing wheel.
If they had incorporated a linen wheel, this can be loaded with Tripoli or another buffing compound, which can remove the wire bur from the cutting edge, and can also replace hand honing by polishing the bevel and the inside the flute. Seems a small detail, but really makes a difference. Might be easy to add onto the end of the shaft somehow, though you would use the bottom of the buffing wheel in your case. No reason a hard strop wheel could not also go on there, but again, these are easier to use and see what you're doing with reversed belt travel.



*** End Note on Direction of Travel:
I spent about 4 hours with Jon Siegel a few weeks ago (along with our own Mike Foster), and he says the direction of the belt travel doesn't matter all that much on his machines. However, I believe he moves the platen out just a bit to make sure there is no air space, and probably uses machines with higher belt tension than the Sorby. I've seen the round-over when the belt is loose, and have tried to increase it with a looser belt to polish the heel of bowl gouges (above) so it must be dulling edges on some machines, though perhaps not the ProEdge.

I hope you can tweak the Sorby Pro Edge to get better results -- that machine costs some real money!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: My new sharpener

#12

Re: My new sharpener

John Lucas

Brad I adjusted the motor on my LV sander so the belt touches the platen. I tried both directions and it seems to work well but I'm also going to use this for carving tools and they are sharpened sometimes at very acute angles. I just feel safer having the belt run away from the tip instead of into it. It produces a different burr but if your sharpening to a very fine grit the burr is gone with the first cut so I don't think that matters.

Re: My new sharpener

#13

Re: My new sharpener

Mark ravensdale

John, I used it to sharpen all my turning tools (spindle roughing gouges/spindle gouges/bowl gouges/scrapers/parting tools) I found it worked well on scrapers and my parting tools but on bowl gouges/spindle gouges and spindle roughing gouges it put a good edge on them but found them VERY grabby almost to the point of being nervous to start the cut, they seemed "all or nothing" if that makes sense?

At first I thought "stick with it" but after almost 18 month I gave up on it,

I do still use it to sharpen carbide cutters from time to time (with ceramic belt) but other than that it doesn't see the light of day

Again, I hope you have more luck (maybe it is just me!!!)

Re: My new sharpener

#14

Re: My new sharpener

Mark ravensdale

Sorry John, I forgot to mention that my woodturning tools are mostly Sorby with a smattering of Henry Taylor, all M2 as far as I know, though I doubt this had any affect on why I couldn't get them to work when sharpened on the pro-edge (belt sharpener) when I gave up on the pro-edge and went back to the wheel/bench grinder it was like putting on an old pair of slippers again, cuts just flowed/worked with little effort (like night and day)

Re: My new sharpener

#15

Re: My new sharpener

Mark ravensdale

Brad, the problem wasn't that it didn't get the tools sharp enough, they where just as sharp as when sharpened on my CBN wheel (I was using a 120grit zirconium belt by the way) they (the tools) just seemed too grabby (like playing Russian roulette with a gouge) it did sharpen scrapers and parting tools fine and these worked great, but spindle gouges/bowl gouges and spindle roughing gouges were just so snatchy to the point that you were waiting for the snatch to happen (not conducive to happy woodturning!),

I gave it around 18 months and went back to my wheel/bench grinder, and as soon as I did the cuts started to flow again and turning became fun again!

Maybe it's just me, set in my ways, I don't honestly know, I would have loved it to work as I hade sunk a chunk of money into it, but for me the wheel worked better

By the way brad, Sorby did make provision for a buffing wheel, you just bolt a pigtail adapter onto the bottom drive wheel and the small buffing wheel (4inch???) threads it's way onto that

Re: My new sharpener

#16

Re: My new sharpener


Re: My new sharpener

#17

Re: My new sharpener

Ron Bauer

OOOps on that last non-post.

I am not an expert here but one distinct difference you are going to see between the belt and a wheel is the belt has a flat bevel while the wheel is hollow. This may be contributing to the differant feel when presenting the tool to the timber.