Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

roughing gouge

Posts

roughing gouge

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

roughing gouge

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have a very good 3/4" roughing gouge. As a matter of fact I use it more than any other tool on spindles.I only bring out the skew after the gouge has done most of the work. I have been looking at larger roughing gouges. Not that I need one,it's just that almost every picture or video on turning shows one being used for roughing out.

How important is this tool? Should I be using this instead of a smaller one?Is there a significant difference in function between the 3/4" gouge and the larger ones?

I'm guessing that it removes more material faster but is there any other difference that I should be aware of?---Jack

Re: roughing gouge

#2

Re: roughing gouge

Dale Miner

For one thing, there is more edge on a larger roughing gouge, so there is usually more time between trips to the grinder.

A larger rouging gouge can be (for me) harder to control when trying to round the ends of a cylinder. The tighter radius of the smaller gouge pulls the wing out of the danger zone a bit faster.

I would put a 3/4" roughing gouge in the 'smaller' category, with 1-1/2" and larger roughing gouges in the 'larger' category.

Re: roughing gouge

#3

Re: roughing gouge

John Lucas

Ditto what Dale says. I think I wasted my money on the big roughing gouge. I don't think it necessarily moves wood any faster. It's a little harder to control. You do have more edge to dull before a trip to the grinder but I think that's inconsequential. You tend to go to the grinder after every few legs anyway.

I think it might be a little better on large spindles. I had to do some 15" x 6" finials and I used that tool. I switched the 1" that I normally used and didn't really notice much difference other than the handle on the big one is longer which gave me more leverage for really hogging wood.

Re: roughing gouge

#4

Re: roughing gouge

Doug Turner

I have a 1/2" and a 1" roughing gouge which I use consistently. I did have a 2" roughing gouge and sold it because it didn't hold an edge as long as the smaller gouges (softer HSS?), it didn't remove wood faster, and the larger diameter obscured the cutting edge ( I couldn't see as well).

Re: roughing gouge

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

Dale,John and Doug, you have answered my question. I believe I will stick with my 3/4" gouge. It is after all a good tool for what I do. ---Jack

Re: roughing gouge

#6

Re: thanks

Dick Coers

If you would be doing large tapers on say porch posts, or baluster work. A large roughing gouge can be more versatile. You can rough off the corners, then rotate the gouge around and angle it. Exposing that large flat is almost like using a skew. More important for production work than one offs.

Re: roughing gouge

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

I will eventually get one. It's not a need now however. I make windsor chairs so the largest piece I turn is a 20" piece for a chair leg.So it appears that the 3/4" is actually the right tool for the application.---Jack

Re: roughing gouge

#8

Re: roughing gouge

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jack,

I "traded" my 3/4" stamp-formed rougher for a 1" P&N rougher that I put in an 18" Kelton handle. Great combination. The P&N is machined from a billet rather than bent from a piece of flat stock, and it's a full "U" shape. I ground the wings back at a 15° angle and use a 75° sharpening angle (very durable edge). With this configuration, not only will it hog off waste, but the long(er) wigs will leave a surface almost as polished as a skew when side cutting. A heavy tool, to be sure, but capable of fine cuts on a spindle.

Re: roughing gouge

#9

Thompson roughing gouge

John Lucas

I didn't see it listed on his site but Doug has a spindle roughing gouge that also has a large tang. Very heavy duty tool. I'm drooling over them but my old Sorby is just hanging in there and doesn't want a mate.

Re: roughing gouge

#12

Re: roughing gouge

John Lucas

Interesting Mark. I sharpen mine so the tip and the wings are at about a 35 degree sharpening angle. I can't really tell that the edge holds up any less. It lets me get an almost finished cut on the whole spindle. I just have to touch up the areas where the big U is too large to cut.

Re: roughing gouge

#13

Re: roughing gouge

robo hippy

I view roughing gouges the way I do scrapers. Any thing over about 1 inch is not necessary, maybe up to 1 1/4. Mostly, if you engage that much steel into the wood at once, you will most likely bog down your lathe. If you want the best, you want ones milled from solid stock rather than forged and bent. This is because you have a heavy duty shaft to mount into your handles. I have them from Craft supplies (old tang type), Thompson and D Way. The Thompson and D Way are my go to tools when I want a SRG. Yes, I do turn spindles on occasion.

robo hippy

Re: roughing gouge

#14

It's A Different Cut

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

from "normal" roughing.

You set the rest above center, hold the tool dead level, rotate the "U" to face away from the direction of cut so that you have a trailing wing. The cut starts behind the center point and leaves the wood from the trailing wing. Functionally, I think, it's similar to a skew's peeling cut, and you decide how wide a shaving you take by controlling how much angle, away for the cut direction, you shift the centerline of the tool (left or right). All the pressure is down onto the tool rest and you progress the cut with hip movement. If you try to "muscle" it, it will still cut, but not as smoothly.

Re: roughing gouge

#15

Caveate

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

This is for spindle orientation only where the cuts all run with the wood grain rather than across it as in bowl/end grain turning.

If you insist on trying to cut end grain, please make sure that all your insurance, life and health, is paid up and current, your body armor is intact, and you've notified your local EMT guys to stand by.

[That's a joke, but only marginally so. Let's have no more turners dying for their art. Deal?]