Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Finding center in a cylinder

Posts

Finding center in a cylinder

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Finding center in a cylinder

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm sure this has been asked but I don't don't hang out here often. I'm mostly into hand tools.

Are there any tricks to finding dead center on a cylinder? I use a small starrett center finder and a knife to make my marks but when I try to hit it I always stray.To chuck the cylinder in the lathe I need to predrill but the drill bit always strays,pulled off center by the wood fibers in end grain. If I drill very carefully I can stay pretty close to center but it's never right on. An awl just slides between the closest wood fibers. So what am I missing? How do you find center accurately?

What I'm talking about is spindle turning,as in chair legs.---Jack

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#2

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Jeff Rich

My answer would be to leave the cylinder a bit oversize, then if you are slightly off, you can true up the blank. I am sure there is a better answer, that is just my experience in fixing problems.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Jack Guzman from Maine

That's how I've been doing it right along. Sometimes,after cutting the ends off a chair leg,I need to tweak it abit. With that method it can't be done without introducing off center shaping to the leg. There has to a method for finding the exact center. ---Jack

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#4

Re: Finding center in a cylinder *LINK*

John Lucas

when I turn chair legs I use a cup center in the tailstock and live center in the headstock. I start with a rough blank of course so it will be centered when I'm done. I don't predrill or anything. I might use a wooden mallet to drive the live center home so the teeth bite but a better option is the steb center. It has a spring loaded point and as you advance the tailstock the spring will be compressed and the outer rim grabs the wood to drive it. Very accurate and easy to reposition the stock on the lathe if you have to remove it for some reason.

To accurately re install a piece I use a several methods. One is to make custom live center adaptors. I use the Nova live center which has replaceable points. They are short #2 morse tapers so they are very easy to make out of wood. If you have to cut off a tenon you can make an adaptor that is cone shaped or cup shaped. the tenon will self center in this jig. I believe Oneway sells a cone shaped aluminum adaptor for their live center. I turn a lot of mirror handles and every now and then have to re install a finished handle. I have a live center adaptor I made that has a very small cone shaped hole in the end. I can put the point of a finial in there to support and align that end if need be.

A chuck with small jaws will often grab a tenon to recenter it. You can also simply use a wasteblock on a faceplate or in your chuck. Turn an opening in the wasteblock to perfectly center the cutoff tenon.


http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020433/22893/Nova-Live-Center-System.aspx?keyword=nova_live_center_system&refcode=06INGOOG&gclid=CKjNm93RkrUCFQ4EnQodqjYA2w

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#5

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Don McLeod

"when I turn chair legs I use a cup center in the tailstock and live center in the headstock. I start with a rough blank of course so it will be centered when I'm done. I don't predrill or anything. I might use a wooden mallet to drive the live center home so the teeth bite but a better option is the steb center"

Shouldn't a drive center be used in the head stock, if not how does the live center turn the spindle?

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#6

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Dick Coers

Finding center isn't the issue, it's the material you are working with. Wood's cellular structure is like a bundle of drinking straws. This structure makes it nearly impossible to stay perfectly dead center when machining. You can start the hole with a starter drill, a metal working bit that is very short with a large body diameter. This will give you a place to start drilling with the larger bit. Then move to an expensive Forstner bit that doesn't rely on the center point to guide the drill. You may still lack the accuracy you desire, but it's the nature of the material.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#7

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

John Lucas

Ooops My boo boo. I use a live center in the tailstock with a cup center tip. I use a 4 prong or Steb center in the headstock. My fingers must be typing faster than my brain which isn't unusual.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#8

even a short center starter drill will wander

John Lucas

I've found the only way to truely keep a bit on center is to clamp the wood in a vise so it and the bit can't move out of alignment. Even then if you use a 60 degree point on your live center when you put pressure on the wood with the tailstock it can still force itself off if the hole is right on the edge of the summer/winter wood grain.

If you think this is bad try drilling a hole all the way through the blank. You never get it perfect from end to end. Wood is just that kind of beast.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#9

I'm Missing Something

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

What are you doing to the spindle (cylinder?) that needs a centered hole drilled? How deep is the hole?

I have bored end grain quite accurately by using a series of twist drills that increase in size to the final diameter. That way the bore's walls act to guide the bit while limiting the flex. This is done, however, on a drill press with the workpiece precisely plumbed to the press quill, will not work for a bore much longer/deeper than 3" or so.

To "find" and mark the center I use that same center marker to strike 3 or 4 diameter lines. Any inaccuracy in the tool results in a small gap rather than a point.

Are you doing restoration work on the legs such that you can't just start with a square blank? I've made any number of tool handles by boring the hole first, then using either a small cone or a plug in the live center. The finished handle, turned using the bore as the reference, always has the hole dead centered.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Leo Cuellar

If it is round at both ends, another possible way is to use a cup center at each end and jamb chuck it. You won't be able to take a heavy cut, but it might get you where you want to be.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: I'm Missing Something

jack Guzman from Maine

I'm just trying to find a more accurate way to find center in a cylinder for those instances where it is needed.I have no problem cutting chair legs from blanks. In that case I created the center.What I'm learning from these responses is that I'm not missing anything. It is just a situation that has to be dealt with.---Jack

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#12

Okay.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As long as you got your answer. ;)

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#13

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: I'm Missing Something

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I'm with Mark in that I don't quite understand what your mean by "finding center". If you mean "remounting the piece on the lathe exactly centered", then this is the method that I use for difficult situations like this. Get a small scrap of 1/4" plywood or other non-splitting wood a bit smaller than the diameter of the piece you are trying to mount. Place the scrap between the end of the spindle and the tail center and drive the tail center into the scrap. Now loosen the pressure just enough to allow you to tap the end of the work piece until it is centered to your satisfaction. You can run the lathe SLOWLY to verify this. Then, tighten the tailstock and apply a bead of medium CA glue to the joint between the scrap and the end of the work piece. If you need to center both ends of the work piece repeat this process with the other end.

Dennis

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: I'm Missing Something

jack Guzman from Maine

I'm going to try that .Thanks---Jack

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#15

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Jorge

Jack,

The most accurate drill bits are Forstner bits, the real Forstners are made by Convalco

pricey but they last and last. second to that are the brad point drill bits, mine were made by Fuller, go very slowly until the spurs on both sides are buried, then you can increase pressure.

The metal bits just wander.

The choice of wood also helps.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#16

Pssst, Jorge . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

He's not drilling holes; just trying to get the piece centered on each end. I'm still wondering how we got "off" on boring centered holes. ;) ;)

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Keith Tompkins

Hey Jack, if the spindle isn't too large in diameter, mount a small faceplate with a wood block attached, and form a cone in the block. Use the oneway cone reversed in the tailstock, the cones will automatically center the piece assuming they are truly round. Would work for a small job.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#18

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

Lan Brady

Lots of good answers, sounds like they all work. Let me add another.

I clamp a small scrap of 1" lumber on the drill press. I drill a hole(same size as tenon) about 3/4 of the way through the board. Without moving the board I replace the drill bit with one about the size of a pencil. Finsh drilling through the wood. Now place the board on the tenon just like a mortise. The pencil hole will be dead center.

Good Luck, Lan

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#19

Jack Guzman from Maine

I like that one

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#20

OOoops!!

Jorge

Hi Mark,

Senior moment, and a projection of my own predicament, I was trying to make a recorder, I made a few in 2006, and drilled them with a 5/16" looong dril bit, one commercially made and another made by myself.

Back then I had a Delta midi and it worked just fine. Now I have the PM 3520b and the drills cannot go thru the tailstock.

I was drilling 16" and drilled from both ends, so starting with a centered hole was important.

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#21

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

H. Phillip Medghalchi

What???????????????????????????? cup cenet at each end?

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#22

Leo Cuellar

Re: Finding center in a cylinder *LINK*

Leo Cuellar

A cup allows you to capture the piece based on friction from the outside edge instead of trying to find the center of the piece again. You can turn them to very specific shapes to fit your needs. Doc Green wrote an excellent book that covers it beautifully!


http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/

Re: Finding center in a cylinder

#23

Thanks, Leo! A pleasant surprise.