Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Production vs. one off

Posts

Production vs. one off

#1

Steven Antonucci

Production vs. one off

Steven Antonucci

The question about making peppermills has me thinking about "the best way" to do something and how that might relate to how many times you were going to do it?

If you plan on making a single peppermill, the best way to do it is probably not the same way as someone who is producing 100 per year. Process becomes more important if you are making one, because it is likely that you are thinking about every step with the goal of producing a single object. Making multiples is more about efficiency and the process is somewhat "automated".

Going further down that path... the question of the day is: which is more interesting to you - figuring out something for the first time or figuring out the best way to do something given your shop and a desire to make many?

Steve

(I like both)

Re: Production vs. one off

#2

Re: Production vs. one off

Stuart Johnson

I enjoy turning but most posting here probably turn more in a week than I do in a year. As a result I spend a lot of my time re-inventing wheel. One time I did turn large batches of pens and rug hooks. I found it was faster to do them in batch steps when possible.

FWIW, I did not care for the process, did not enjoy the turning and quickly decided not to waste my time with any type of production work.

Re: Production vs. one off

#3

Re: Production vs. one off

John Lucas

Oh without a doubt it's inventing or designing a new piece and figuring out how to build it.

Of course I do a little of both. When I make Christmas ornaments I make 5 or 10 at once. (One time 50 for special event). It's fun trying to figure out how to make it go a little faster. Just doing the same shapes over and over speeds it up. You don't waste time slipping up on the cuts. You hog off the areas that don't need wood and then finish the cuts.

My hand mirrors used to take 4 hours. Now I make them in about 45 minutes for the plane ones.

Re: Production vs. one off

#4

Jim Barbour

Re: Production vs. one off

Jim Barbour

I'm with Steve on this one; I enjoy both. I am currently making sixteen five-foot heraldic staves, each different, but with a sense of rhyme. The length is important and each must contain an acorn somewhere in the work. This is a form of production turning -- not exact matching, but the same idea over and over. I enjoyed working out how to get grain matches (I have to turn them in two pieces and then join in the center), how to be most efficient with a center steady, comparing a skew to an European spindle gouge for long, slow tapers, designing a full-bed tool rest so I don't have to work around the steady rest to get the banjo from one end of the lathe to the other, etc.

I am also designing a one-off box to hold two pieces of glass art. It will likely be a sphere rising through a plane with a threaded top, a carved lens in the top and a threaded lid at the center line of the sphere. The top will be pierced and the bottom of the sphere will be fashioned to hold the second piece of glass art. Working out all the technical issues is really quite fun.

About six months past I got a commission to turn nearly 200 matching acorn paperweights. That was production turning of the first order. At the start it took me 30 minutes or so to turn an acorn (from rough blank to finished and buffed). Before I was finished I got the time down to about 8 minutes. How to do each step most efficiently was an enjoyable exercise, and I believe my turning improved, even for one off pieces, from the repetition. It is sort of like working through multiplication tables as a kid -- a pain and seemingly useless, but really handy to have done.

Both have their place in my world, but my friend Nim, for example, has no interest at all in making two of anything at one time. He will make lots of pepper grinders, and lots of boxes, but each is turned from rough blank to finished piece before the next is begun. I suppose this is just another example of productive differences and is, of course, a good thing.

Re: Production vs. one off

#5

Re: Production vs. one off

Dale Miner

For me, figuring out how to do something the first time. But, in doing repepative production type items, the process is never etched in stone, and is constantly getting 'tweaked' to improve speed, costs, etc.

Re: Production vs. one off

#6

Re: Production vs. one off

robo hippy

If I ever made two things exactly alike, it was an accident, well, except for my flat work. The thing with production work, is that you learn technique better than you do if you do one of a kinds. Once you learn technique, then it is simple to adapt technique for one of a kinds. Some of both. In the furniture world, the design was the challenge, the making was the easy part, well, and being able to figure out how to cover/hide/blend in mistakes.

robo hippy

Re: Production vs. one off

#7

Mike Peace

Re: Production vs. one off

Mike Peace

I attended a discussion for new turners at an AAW symposium a few years ago. An idea repeated several times was to find something you enjoyed turning and make 50 of them if you want to improve your technique. Makes a lot sense.

Re: Production vs. one off

#8

Steven Antonucci

my longer answer

Steven Antonucci

I mentioned that I like both, but after all of these years at the lathe, it is rare that I start a project and get to a point that I am stumped and forced to solve a problem for the first time anymore. I've made a lot, of pretty much anything you can make on a lathe.

Working in "production mode" is a different set of issues, in that you may have to reproduce something (like a baluster) in multiples and they have to be the same, or you are looking to get through a process more efficiently, because there is a lot of monkey work to be done and you just want to get through it.

I have a series of projects in my head that require me to make potentially 100's of the same thing that all need to be pretty close. I know how to make one or even a few, but not at the scale that I will eventually require. I have one technical issue that I still need to resolve, as my first attempt worked, but not to my standards. I am sort of OK with the project living in my head, but I also think it would be cool to do it on a much larger scale too.

It is this kind of stuff that keeps it interesting in my mind. "The life so short, the craft so long to learn" (Hippocrates/Chaucer/and Gustav Stickley (I first saw this at Craftsman Farms))

Steve

Re: Production vs. one off

#9

Re: Production vs. one off

Jorge

I enjoy more figuring out ways to make many in less time, now and the I enjoy making a one of a kind...