Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

Posts

Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#1

Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

Roger Chandler

Iffy combination- Ambrosia Maple/curly redwood

First off, let me apologize for the less than stellar pics! My photo setup is put away at the present, so I just put this on top of the wood stove and took some pics!

I am also trying to utilize some of the many small pieces of wood that I seem to be a magnet for, as they just keep on finding me.......not a problem however! The redwood lid is from a small piece that Scott Trumbo sent along in the flat rate box when I got my Ultimate Gouge and handle from Serious Toolworks.

I did not have a suitable piece of ambrosia maple or even walnut [which I would have preferred] to make the lid, but that piece of redwood was the right size to do what I needed, so I went for it! I did not know I was going to uncover such figure on this piece of Northwestern redwood...............I might have held on to it for something else, but once started it is too late!

The lidded dish with pedestal is 5 inches in diameter and 4.75" tall at the knob...........will be great for M&M's or such!

I think it is okay, but not an ideal combination of woods.........but the redwood did provide some contrast.

Comments always welcome!




Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#2

Steven Antonucci

Like Steak and Ice cream

Steven Antonucci

Two good things that just don't go together?

If it was mine, I'd probably rechuck the lid and turn the inset for the lid into a bead, and then turn off the knob to make a shallow bowl.

You could leave the base alone for another day until you had something that went with it better. These two pieces of wood don't belong together.

It's my 2 cents, but your call

Steve

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Like Steak and Ice cream

Brad Vietje

I think I agree with Steve; looks like good technique and two well turned pieces, but they don't go together really well. With better mates, these two parts could really come into their own, and could really look great!

The other issue besides contrast between the two pieces is the competition between them, as each is a pretty piece on its own, and seems to be vying for the spotlight -- like having two Michael Jordan's on the same team (I know that's an old fart's out-of-date example, but at least I didn't refer to Wilt Chamberlain or Oscar Robertson ;) )

Is that an end-grain base and a side-grain lid? If so, that could cause a poor fit between parts as humidity levels change. I think a dark wood like Black Walnut might compliment the Ambrosia Maple piece, and help show off the spalting pattern (?). What woods are available to you?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Like Steak and Ice cream

Brad Vietje

Roger -- another option would be to turn a contrasting ring that would sit between these two pieces... probably glued to the base, so the lid would be framed in dark-colored wood to create a sharper distinction between the two.

That adds contrast (and might just look awful), but you'd have to watch the effect on the shape/profile, and you'd still have two lovely pieces of wood competing for attention.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#5

Re: Like Steak and Ice cream

Roger Chandler

Thanks Brad.......and Steve......there is probably a re-do in the future for both pieces.......I was limited on available wood, and was trying to utilize the smaller pieces that are cluttering up my work space...........

I agree with the steak and ice cream analogy......both good, but not necessarily together! ;)

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#6

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwoo

Craig Daymon

I think you have 2 fantastic pieces of wood fighting for attention. For this reason, the piece fails to highlight either.

That being said, I think there is a possibility that reversing the usage of the woods in this piece might have worked better. Though the same issue of competing attention would probably still exist.

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwood

#7

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Iffy Combination - Ambrosia Maple/Curly redwoo

Dennis in Southern Oregon

This clearly is a forced marriage and needs something to distract the eye from the conflict. Brad's suggestion of a contrasting ring is one solution; another might be two or three beads at the top of the base and a slight reshaping of the base at the top so that there is a more abrupt transition at the join.

Dennis