Having attended the TAW symposium, and watching Jimmy Clewes and Mike Mahoney's ability to grip a tennon with the Dovetail jaws, I'm wondering if I should move a little more aggressively towards these jaws? I'm normally one that subscribes to the; whatever it takes to get the job done which means hey, the jaws I have I can make work so why change things.
However, Mike Mahoney showed how well and his philosophy of why he uses the dovetail jaws, with incredible success on all but 1 piece. Then there was Jimmy Clewes discussing and making the point that he's only showing what works for him, when it came to the jaw selection (not chuck so much, but Jaw selection) he was very much for the Dovetail jaws. I'll also add that I know it depends on the application as well, just wondering what people here thought and used.
The Dove tail joint has been used in woodworking forever. Main reason is that, mechanically it offers better holding power than at finger joint. It is a locking wedge joint. Dove tail jaws make an 'adjustable' wedge, and as long as the joint is a fairly close fit as in angle matches, and diameter is similar, then holding power is better. Similar diameter means you get best grip on a recess where jaw diameter = 2 inches, and recess = 2 1/16 to 2 1/4. This gives the most steel to wood contact/surface areas meeting ratio.
Well darn. I didn't tell everyone why I like the Vicmarc Dovetail jaws. Well actually I did tell them why I like the chuck. The 10mm allen wrench chuck key. It's very easy to replace if you lose one. Can't say that about the keyed chucks, you have to order one from the company.
I can't say for sure that the dovetail jaws hold better in all situations. I can say that I like them far better for expanding into an opening and I think they are stronger on larger tenons. I worry sometimes that on small tenons they might create a weak point since the bottom of the tenon is narrower than the top.
I can say that I have 2 sets of straight jaws for my vicmarc and I have had pieces come out of them. I have almost never had a piece come out of my dovetail jaws.
Now I will say that the verdict is out on the Oneway odd shaped curved jaws for holding multiple sizes of tenons. On the Vicmarc dovetail jaws if you have the jaws extended very far you are only holding at 8 points. Granted they are dovetails so they are gripping inside a little. However it looks to me like the Oneway curved jaws will hold more sizes successfully. Can't say if they hold a size that is close to the closed position as well as the Vicmarc.
I use doevetail jaws almost exclusively and always try to match the size of the tenon to the jaw closely. I do have several different sizes to match the size of work.
First, a large-diameter tenon provides more holding power than a small one, assuming the shape of the tenon (diameter and profile) matches the jaws of the chuck. This holds true for both the ability of the chuck to supply torque to the workpiece, and to resist the levering action that results from the force the tool exerts on the workpiece.
The Oneway serrated jaws, with the funny curve on the inside, grips the piece at 8 points over the entire range of diameters the jaws can accommodate. Here, a larger tenon is better, without qualification.
With true dovetail jaws, the greatest power to resist the leverage component is achieved when the diameter of the tenon matches the curvature of the jaws. This gives the best seating of the jaws against the tenon. I don't think the torque component is affected significantly by using a larger tenon because the jaws dig in at 8 points, which gives a strong grip for the twisting force.
A disadvantage of dovetail jaws is that you must size the tenon carefully for the best fit to the natural curve of the jaws, and this forces you to use a rather small tenon with the standard jaws of a Supernova2, for example. Ideally, if a larger tenon is needed, you would use a larger set of dovetail jaws, but not everyone has a wide selection to choose from.
On a same size to same size comparison, I suspect the dovetails would win over the serrated jaws of a Oneway, but this is only speculation on my part.
For expanding into a recess, pure dovetails are best, assuming a good fit, etc. The Oneway jaws supplied on the Talon (and perhaps others) have a raised bead on the outside of the dovetail, and unless you cut a groove for this bead to fit into, the jaws don't hold as well as they would if the bead were not there ... in my opinion, anyway.
Routinely, I use the Oneway serrated jaws because of the greater range of diameters they can hold. I seldom actually measure a tenon and then only if I think it might be near the limit, either too large or too small.
Missed you at the last RMWT symposium. I hope you can make it this year. As you know I rough out a lot of bowls and large ones at that. I exclusively use the vicmarc dovetail jaws on a tenon for roughing and coring. I have tried other styles but have had issues with them holding. As others have said making the tenon or recess the proper size gives the best holding power. I have pushed those limits holding with the eight points and have had good success as well. Good luck with your decision.
....were better holding jaws, and even have same on my Oneway Stronghold chuck. They were originally made by some supplier than Oneway, but are now available labeled as the "smooth" jaws.
Doc I somewhat disagree about the dovetails having to be perfect. I've always cut them by eye and I never had a problem. Now I think maybe they shouldn't be real far off but the wood usually compresses enough to correct for minor imperfections.
What I said in the post above was that "you must size the tenon carefully ..." Now, as the lawyer asked the judge, what did I mean when I said that?
For me, the frame of reference is the Oneway Talon because I've used that chuck with the #2 (serrated) jaws far more than any other. Sizing a tenon for that combination is not an issue. Anything between 1.5 and 2.75 inches diameter will fit the jaws, but I tend toward the larger diameters for larger pieces. Seldom do I bother with measuring it.
On the other hand, to get the tenon diameter to within 1/8" or even to within 1/4" of the ideal diameter for a set of dovetail jaws, I have to use a ruler or caliper to mark the diameter on the workpiece. To me, this is sizing the tenon "carefully."
You have far more experience with the dovetails than I, so tell me, based on your experience, how close to the ideal diameter does the tenon need to be? Say for a 2" diameter ideal circle in your typical cherry or walnut, how far off can it be before it begins to make a difference?
Would you say that a diameter of 2 1/8 is OK? 2 1/4? 2 3/8? Give me a number so I'll have an idea of the tolerances you are thinking of.
Doc I see what your saying and misread it. Not a first time for me.
I honestly don't worry about the tenon size unless the wood is weak. I just cut whatever I want and grip it with the jaws. I really haven't had a problem doing this.
The 8 jaw corners do leave a nasty dent in the wood but then I either remove the tenon or reshape the foot on all my pieces so that isn't a problem.
I also do a lot of work with 3" square waste blocks glued to them. It is only gripped by the 8 points on these. I can't remember the last time I lost one of these other than once when the square block had some grain run out across a corner.
Inside rebates is a little different. If I want the rebate to be part of the finished turning without marks from the jaws then I make it as close as I can to the size that is just larger than the jaws fully closed. If it's not important I don't worry about the size. The Dovetail holds really well in expansion mode.
I agree with all the comments I've read so far, but want to throw 2 - 3 other variables in the ring:
1. Green Wood & Rough Turning: I generally use the OneWay Stronghold with the regular "profile" jaws to rough turn work -- especially larger pieces. That's partly just out of habit, and partly because I keep my #3 Profile profile jaws in one chuck (#4 ready, if needed), and smaller dovetail jaws for finish work on another chuck. I shape and size a dovetail tenon when re-mounting between centers before finish turning if I need any sort of precision. Like John, I do this by eye w/out problems.
2. For finish turning I believe the added grip of the dovetail helps avoid uneven crushing of the wood fibers, and thus better accuracy in keeping a piece running true, and on-axis. For thin-walled pieces there may even be a little less vibration when a dovetail fit is just right, but that's just speculation at the moment. Knowing that Mike Foster used dovetail jaws for his paper-thin Fractal Trees piece certainly lends supporting evidence, though .
3. For any piece that needs to be turned end-for-end, and re-chucked even once, dovetail jaws with a well-matched tenon are infinitely superior, IMHO! The serrations in other jaw designs tend to crush and maim the wood fibers in some fashion that makes it all but impossible to have a piece run true after removing it and re-chucking it -- even when a tail center can be used for alignment. This is especially true if there is any sapwood or spalting in the tenon, as this wood compresses unevenly.
4. For any designs that incorporate a dovetail shaped base or foot into the final design, these can be finished and polished first and then chucked in dovetail jaws without marring if protected with a piece of cloth (shown in many books, especially by English turners and a certain English ex-pat living in Australia). In practice I rarely do this, since I generally don't like these forms as much, though it does work.
Hi Randy. Thanks again for the beautiful oak bowl. Being a relatively new woodturner, 5 years, I have been led in different directions at different times. I would mostly consider myself a student of Mike Mahoney. I love to work on big stuff, turning and coring, roughing and finishing. I wish that about 5 years ago someone had strongly suggested to me to buy nothing but Vicmarc chucks with dovetail jaws. I would have a lot fewer never used or seldom used chucks and jaws around my shop. As far as having to be more careful or more accurate cutting tenons and recesses, with a little practice it comes pretty easy and naturally. Much easier, in my opinion, than cutting a perfectly vertical tenon for OneWay or Nova. As far as holding power on large pieces, both coring and roughing, I have never lost one off a dovetail but have had some disasters with OneWay. I would love to be able to sell most of my other chucks and jaws and use the money for more Vicmarcs and dovetail jaws.
I greatly appreciate all the replies and feedback, I have learned a lot I thought I somewhat understood. Guess I'm going to be appealing to my financial adviser to make some upgrades in the near future.
I just completed an 8" tall vase(?) about 3" in diameter on my JET mini using an Axminster chuck wiith O'Donnell jaws and a very small dovetail tenon. It held rock solid. And, most importantly, I could take it out of the chuck, put it back in and have it turn perfectly true. Taking a piece in and out of the jaws using my Talon and the gripper jaws almost never gave me a true turning.
I saw a Richard Raffan video where he made this very argument. He always uses dovetail jaws, or will comment on the fact if he's demoing and doesn't have them.
Now I only wish I hadn't bought as many Oneway jaws with the serrated jaws.
Good luck in your negotiations with your financial adviser! In the meantime, I suggest you get a copy of Lyle Jameision's Bowl Basics the Easy Way DVD. In it he spends a lot of time showing you how to use a faceplate instead of a chuck to turn a bowl. It's good information to have. Even after you're adviser has approved the purchase of a boat load of new chucks and jaws, knowing how to use a faceplate will add a lot of flexibility to your arsenal of turning skills.
Here's a link to the DVD at CSUSA's website. Just so you'll know which video I'm recommending. It's available elsewhere.
I agree with robbo and the other posters, dovetails have been used for hundreds (maybe thousands) of years because they work, they offer a larger area of contact,
However I do think the toothed type jaws (oneway and others) do offer a better grip on big wet logs (parallel to the bed of lathe)
When installing the wood in the chuck if you will orient the wood so each jaw has an equal amount of end grain and side grain it will compress more evenly. This makes it align better when you are reinstalling it in the jaws after removal. Not as critical on an end grain piece but on side grain pieces it can make a huge difference.
Also not mentioned is making the tenon shorter than the jaws are tall. The tenon should also have a square shoulder that will sit on top of the jaws. This square shoulder keeps the wood from racking back and forth. If you have a straight tenon with no shoulder the vibrations and racking caused by turning can cause the bowl to loosen and fly out of the chuck. The shoulder helps prevent this.
If your turning green wood stop the lathe every so often and re-tighten the jaws. They have a tendency to compress the wood and get loose.