hunter osprey tool
bob davis
your experience with tis tool?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
hunter osprey tool
bob davis
your experience with tis tool?
John Lucas Video *LINK*
Doc Green
I have no experience with this tool, but I did watch John's video:
Re: hunter osprey tool
Mike Stafford
I have both of the Osprey tools. They are very versatile tools and as I have learned to use them I find more and more uses for these clean cutting carbide tipped tools which I think of as gouges.
I like the Ospreys because of their ability to cleanly cut face grain and end grain. I like to turn miniature birdhouse ornaments and boxes. Both of these items require clean cuts on both face grain and end grain and the Ospreys will transition from one to the other flawlessly. I like to use exotics in both my boxes and birdhouses and exotics can be tricky to cut cleanly. If the cut requires a lot of sanding on the end grain exotics tend to respond poorly if the sanding gets the wood hot and heat checking will occur. The Ospreys will cleanly cut the end grain and greatly reduce any sanding. On really dense wood such as cocobolo, tulipwood, blackwood, etc. the Osprey will leave a surface that needs very little sanding if one's tool control is good.
The Ospreys also do a great job on spindle work and leave a terrific surface. Recently I have been turning some small plates/saucers with under cut rims. The Osprey did a fabulous job of cutting the undercuts below the rim and cleaning up end grain tear out left by bowl gouge.
As a disclaimer, I am friends with Mike Hunter but I have no financial interest in the company. I just like Hunter tools because they are problem solvers and make certain turning operations easier and provide results that make sanding and finishing easier.
P.S. I almost forgot to mention that the cutters stay sharp a long, long time and require no sharpening. When they get dull just replace them.
Re: hunter osprey tool
matt overton
I agree with Mike and John. These are great tools. They are the next generation of Hunter tools. The profile of the bottom of the tool adds a new dimension to its versatility.
Re: hunter osprey tool
Don Leydens
I love my Hunter tools as well. They have allowed me to make some cuts that regular tools just couldn't do. The Osprey is more of an overall bowl gouge as I like to use it, though it has many uses. You can ride the bevel on this one.
that is inf iwanted.thanks, all
Re: hunter osprey tool
steve worcester
(full disclosure - I sell Hunter tools)
I like the tools for times when you want a real clean finish cut, but for most turning, they won't replace a gouge. Here's why.
The Hunter Osprey is designed so the face of the cutter and the steel of the tool meet to give you a bevel to ride, like a gouge, big plus. A gouge has a deep flute for agressive and big stock removal, a carbide cutter doesn't. So you can't use an Osprey to take deep cuts like a gouge. But you can use an Osprey to take lighter cuts with the super sharp carbide and get a finish usually better that you can with a gouge (or better than I can). Especially on end grain where I get more tear out than I want to deal with.
Re: hunter osprey tool
Don Thur
**Disclosure-- I am part of Kilian Tools**
I just had to jump in to make the turning community aware that there are alternative high quality carbide cutter tools available. Check out my site www.knotsburls.com/kiliantools.
Other than word-of-mouth and forums, we do not advertise to keep the cost to a minimum.
You can take large cuts
John Lucas
I've been away at a symposium so I've missed all these posts. You can use the Osprey with the cutter flat and use it like a scraper. It will remove a lot of wood very fast this way. Once you get it roughed out using the scraper mode then you rotate to tool around and use it in bevel rubbing mode to clean everything up and leave a good finish.
The Hunter Hercules is better for hogging off wood because it's thicker and has a square body which helps keep it from rolling over on you if you use the 3 or 9 oclock area. All cuts should be with the 10 to 2 Oclock position of the tool. You can still rotate the Hercules around and do bevel rubbing cuts just like the Osprey. The geometry of the tools are the same just the shafts are different.
I do still agree with Steve. I can take more wood off faster with proper use of a bowl gouge.
Point of clarification.....
Rob Wallace
The Kilian Tools that Don has mentioned are not directly comparable to the Hunter Tools (e.g. Osprey, Hercules, Hunter) being discussed in this thread. Kilian tools are analogous to the scraping-style carbide insert tools similar to Easy Wood Tools, and are NOT related to the Hunter Tools (other than the replaceability of the cutters) as to the types of inserts used or cuts able to be made between the different styles of tools.
Newcomers to "carbide insert tools" should become aware of the fundamental differences between these two types of replaceable insert tools.
Rob Wallace
Thank you...
Lyle Jamieson
Thanks for mentioning that all carbide is not created equil. The Nanograin Carbide that Mike Hunter uses will be sharper then the old carbide inserts some folks are using.
I agree, Lyle, but....
Rob Wallace
.....although the particle size of the carbides in the different steel alloys are important in determining sharpness and durability of the edge, however from a teaching standpoint, I think emphasizing the differences of the presentation of each tool type against the work is more important than differences in carbide type.
The Hunter Tools primary mode of action is through actual cutting or shearing opposed to the Easy Wood & Kilian tools which use "flat" inserts that are used only as 'long-lived' scrapers. The techniques that are used to allow these tools to perform are quite different, as are the quality of the finishes surfaces that are left following use of the tools.
Newcomers are more likely to need to know the differences in the techniques involved with using these different kinds of "carbide insert" tools, and what qualities of surfaces can be expected from them, more than they will be able to discern differences in carbide particle size and edge-holding properties. You are absolutely correct that they are different, but the most significant practical difference is how the tool is applied to the work.
I really like using my Hunter and Hercules tools (haven't gotten the Osprey yet), as well as the Hunter mini-cutter used in my Jamieson hollower, since these cutters perform extremely well. I also agree that a well-sharpened gouge likely performs more efficiently in removing stock quickly, and occasionally leaves a less-than-perfect surface that can be cleaned-up with a Hunter tool in bevel-rubbing shear mode (which often is a "spectacular" finish).
As long as the expectations and limits of the tools we use are known and understood, their utility in woodturning can be used to maximum advantage.
Rob Wallace
Re: I agree, Lyle, but....
Lyle Jamieson
Totally agree, Rob, great discussion. I would add that even a beginner needs to know what to expect from the tools. The old carbide will not get as sharp as the Hunter tools AND they are using them in scraping mode...you can not expect to get a good finish surface and will have to do a bit more sanding. A dull tool will not work in either a scraping or slicing mode. I believe that marketing some of these tools as finishing tools is misleading.
Even some expert turners often use the Hunter carbide in a scraping mode. Some systems are set up so they will only scrape. I think everybody needs to understand the difference between scraping and bevel supported slicing cuts as well as what to expect from dull or sharp tools either hogging off or trying to get a finish cut. When doing roughing out cuts, any tool will get the job done, some easier then others. I prefer a bowl gouge for bowls. But when finish cuts are needed we need all the help we can get. Its all part of the learning curve...do we teach it now or teach it later??
Re: I agree, Lyle, but....
Mike Stafford
When I first received my Hunter Hercules I followed Mike's instructions and did all the cutting with the tool flat on the tool rest. I was rounding up a walnut bowl blank and to tell you the truth I was not happy with the amount of tearout that I was seeing on the end grain. So I dropped the handle and went into a bevel riding cut. The tearout was removed and the surface was so smooth that it needed little or no sanding. I took pictures and sent them to Mike. Since then I have been an advocate of riding the bevel on all Hunter tools.
The Osprey tools make riding the bevel easy. The presentation of the cutter should be done exactly as one would present the cutting edge of a gouge. This will result in the smoothest cut surface in both end grain and face grain particularly if the cutter is rolled over a bit so that it is shearing.
I don't find that the Ospreys will remove a lot of wood effectively without significant tearout but when you ride the bevel you get a surface that greatly reduces your sanding time. For that reason I almost always make my finish cuts with the Osprey now.