I do mostly spindle turning. I build windsor chairs and repair chairs so I turn alot of legs. I'm actually starting to get fair at this. I need to improve my sharpening system so it's less of a chore.I use a 3/4" oval skew,a 3/4" roughing gouge and a small spindle gouge.I am looking for input on 1" belt sanders. Grizzly sells a simple and cheap model that looks as if I could mount it right near my lathe. As it is I grind with an 8" blue norton wheel on a slow speed grinder in another room. This has become such a chore that I end up not sharpening as often as I should.
Will this 1" belt help me as much as I hope? I'd like to just stop for a minute,do a quick touch-up then get back to turning.
Anybody use one of these? What are your experiences?---Jack
Jack I just purchase the Lee Valley 1" strip sander to learn how it will work for sharpening. I think for skews it will be excellent. The reason I want to try it is to be able to use finer belts for things like the skew. I think the skew needs to be very sharp. I have always used a grinder to hollow grind and then I hone the edge with diamond hones. This is not the fastest way to do it but I bet an extremely sharp edge. After I go through the 3 finer grits I touch it up on a leather wheel on my Sheppac wet wheel grinder.
I can usually just hit it frequently with the ultra fine diamond hone and strop and it stays pretty sharp.
The strip sander using a convex edge on the skew. So far the jury is still out for me on a convex edge. I seem to have to work a little harder to turn an accurate bead with a convex edge. For planing cuts it works great. I think it's just a matter of me using it more to get comfortable with the differences between it and my normal skew. The advantage of this edge coupled with a belt sander is it is extremely fast to restore the edge especially if you use a fine belt. Look up Eli Avisara's video on sharpening the radius edge skew and you will see. The downside is I seem to gradually round the edge more and more while trying to get the really sharp edge so it gets a more and more blunt angle and I eventually have to put a course belt on and touch up the shape. Again that all might go away if I used that skew exclusively. If you layed a flat leather strop on the bench next to it you could get a razor edge really fast however a 600 grit belt will put an awfully sharp edge on straight off the belt sander. It will also work for your spindle gouge.
I also grind my rough out gouge at a 35 degree bevel angle. I can almost completely shape a leg with that tool and then just barely have to touch it up with the skew and spindle gouge.
Here are a couple of videos that show how I do that.
I'm a strong advocate of belt sanders and flat bevels for sharpening turning tools (and convex for a few tools, too), but I'm not convinced the little strip sander from Grizzly will do quite what you want.
The two models I saw have a pretty short platen behind the belt, and a work table that looks like it can be angled.... It looks like you would have pretty limited access to that platen, which could limit the bevel angles you could get, even if the small platform was removed.
What would work slick as a trout (they must say that in Maine, too!) would be a setup like Jon Siegel used to sell, which Mike Foster uses a lot, too. I used to use one, but when I moved I created a reasonable knock-off from a 12" disc sander, which I still use a lot. These are not currently on the market, but can be built from readily-available parts without spending much money. Also, the belts are cheap, last a long time, and can be changed in a few seconds.
One of my local clubs (St. Johnsbury, VT and Littleton, NH) will be making a number of these at the February meeting from an inexpensive 4" x 36" belt sander and other stuff. Cost for all the parts with a few different grit belts came to $120 each, but that was with a discount coupon on the sander which I believe has now expired, so you could get the package for $140. Not sure where you are in Maine, but you'd be welcome to make the drive over to Littleton, NH for the meeting (Feb 16, 9:30 - noon-ish, usually 1-ish) if you're not way up in Holden or Caribou or Ft. Kent!
If you are registered on the AAW forum, you should be able to access some photos that Mike Foster (comment #12) and Jerry Hall (#13) posted in 2010 here: http://www.aawforum.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=8019&page=2 Mike's is the actual Jon Siegel machine from Big Tree Tools, while Jerry Hall's is a hand-made job. Mike may decide to chime in here, too.
At the bottom left is a tiny button to take you to page 2, which shows a few jigs he built, one of which would be good for a skew. His belt must be pretty coarse -- looks like 80 or 120 grit -- because with a used 180 belt you get a much more refined surface, and with a 320 or 400 grit, you get an almost polished bevel.
When used with a flat platen, you get a flat grind, which is definitely not as good as a hollow grind for hand honing. BUT: Jon's basic philosophy is that the edge you get from a fine grit belt does not need honing, even more so when you include a linen buffing wheel and a little Tripoli to remove burs and/or polish the ground bevel. He also contends that hand honing is not all that accurate after 3-4 times, and can be a waste of time (probably more so in spindle turning***). Honing is usually done to refine and maintain a keen edge, which helps us avoid a number of trips to the grinder, which makes our tools last longer, and saves $$$. Once you have the tool shaped the way you like with a coarse belt (or grinding wheel) you only need to touch up the edge with a very fine belt. With a light touch on a 220 belt, you get a very nice edge & bevel, and only remove about 0.0005" of valuable tool steel (using a pocket jig for the same grind each time), so you can sharpen the tool ~2,000 times before you shorten the tool by just 1". That's pretty darned good!
*** In my own universe, I think honing makes more difference where more end grain is involved than in spindle turning, so for the outside of bowls I still have some tools sharpened on an 8" wheel and hand honed, but then again, I contend that on the inside of of a bowl or vase would be best with a convex bevel, but I find that a flat bevel is easier to get just right every time, and thus a good compromise. Mike has convinced me to try the Hannes Tool grind (JoHannes Michelsen; = convex) on one of my 1/2" bowl gouges, but I have not tried that yet.
There ya go, Jack -- that's my 3 cents on the matter -- a lot more than you may have wanted, but worth every penny!
The belts are also less expensive. GRanted I think a 2 or 3" belt would be better and I have one but the 1" is quite a bit less expensive as well as the belts. You do have to be more careful when you grind so you don't run off the belt but then if your used to grinding on a 3/4" wheel that should not be a problem.
I'd agree that if grinder sharpening is the goal then mounting the grinder in a more convenient way -- like a rolling cart -- would be a good solution.
However, I contend that "sand & buff" sharpening is better, easier, and much faster, and uses up so little tool steel that it makes our tools last longer.
I don't think I follow about the dull belts... As long as the tool comes off the belt sharp, and we have a good feel for how a very sharp tool cuts and sounds, it's working fine. I had a 180-grit belt on one machine for ~4 years back when I was turning about 25 - 40 hours per week. I'd clean it with one of those big rubber erasers every now and then, but that's it.
One of these days, we gotta give up the addiction to grinders. I truly believe sanding belts work much better for many turning tools. Just one fella's opinion, and of course no one is required to agree, but these things really do work. For a beginner especially, they take the stress and difficulty out of sharpening, and can greatly assist a beginner in their learning curve by completely removing sharpening from the long list of skills to be mastered.
This is alot of helpful information. I appreciate all the help. I think I may look into LVs 1"x42". I learned more than I was looking for here but that's what Woodcentral is all about. thanks---Jack
I have used a belt system for a couple of years and really love it. I still have a couple of grinders, but use them only for rough shaping or changing the shape of tools and I have one dedicated to sharpening scrapers. All other tools I use the belt system that I bought from Jon. I would point you to the recent thread we had just a while ago regarding this subject.
I'm a convert from wheel grinders, and I think that ,slowlyyyyyy, this will become how turners sharpen. BTW this system works great for hand planes, bench chisels and many other tools. I have yet a different system for my carivng chisels that removes even less steel. That's on my website as well, but belongs in another forum.
Jack Got mine assembled today. A couple of things you should know. Of course the motor doesn't come with it. You need a motor. A switch also doesn't come with it. I simply drilled a hole in the chasis and added a switch. OK, I drilled two holes. When installing the motor it was too close to the switch so I had to move the switch. should have planned that one better.
The table is interesting. you have to reach under it to loosen a nut so you can move it. Not the best design I've seen. I'm probably going to modify the table. I am going to use the slot for mounting the table to make a system that has an adjustable V or pivot point for the Wolverine jig.
It runs great. I'm happy with it. It came with a 120 belt which I will only use for rough shaping metal. I'm going to order some finer belts of the Blue Zirconium grit.