Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Posts

What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#1

Allan W

What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Allan W

I would like to try turning a segmented bowl but found that when I glued the segments together I had a small gap at the last two segments. I am using a 12 inch miter saw with 60 tooth blade. Would I be better using a 80 tooth blade? Or for starters should I start with 6 segments instead of 12 like I did? I used a stop block with a clamp to hold the pieces during cutting. Would I be better off finding a 8 or 10 miter saw?

Thank you.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#2

Steven Antonucci

I am not a segmented guy, but I don't think it's..

Steven Antonucci

your blade?

I suspect that the propagation of small errors is to blame. I have seen this corrected by a working sequence in half rings that are flattened together on a sander before final glue up. By sanding the half rings to flat, you make two flat surfaces and you get rid of any small gaps.

Steve

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#3

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Ralph Lindberg

Allan, I haven't done a lot, but my rule is more teeth are better, I use an 80 tooth on a 10 inch, my guess would be that 60 on a 12 is better suited to rough the finish work.

I know lots of people use table-saws (which is what I think you are talking about). But I find by miter saw easier to setup

I also think that 6 is too few segments.

Last, the half-ring is your friend.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#4

better description of gap is needed

Dick Coers

The only gap that would be changed with a different blade, is one that is tight on one face, but gapped on the other face. That would indicate blade wander in the cut. But if it is an equal gap from face to face, it's an angular problem and is a result of the accumulated error mentioned. I'm a fan of using the table saw for accurate angle work. I feel that with the proper jig, it's much more accurate than a miter saw.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#5

thin kerf blades can be a factor

Jimmy Edwards

Had same problem with a thin kerf blade. I had deflection of the blade in the vertical cut. Got a Forrest blade. 0 deflection. Thin kerf was .08 Forrest kerf was .10

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#6

Re: better description of gap is needed

John Lucas

It is most likely accumulated error. A 60 tooth or 100 tooth should give you the same angle. The difference would be in the quality of the glue surface left by the blade. I lean toward higher blade counts myself but it's for the glue surface not accuracy of the cut.

I've found that you can even introduce errors when doing the rub joint where you glue 2 pieces together, then glue pairs together etc. I've had the 2 halves come out unequal even though I could put the whole ring together with a band clamp and not have a gap. This only happens on rigs with with a high number of segments. My only conclusion is the glue must change the angle very slightly and even .001" adds up when you have anywhere form 16 to 32 segments.

I've found that the everything from the feed rate of the blade to how much pressure you put on the saw can affect the accuracy of the cut and add up to create a gap. Even on my table saw but seems more so on my miter saw.

The most accurate method I've tried so far is the sanding disc method that Malcolm Tibbet teaches. You basically cut the miters close to size and then finalize them on the disc sander with a jig.

I have decent saws but neither one of them is a state of that art saw. I can get very accurate rings using my table saw and sled that rides in both miter slots. Even then I will sometimes get a ring that doesn't close up. I'm still learning to use my new miter saw. When it's on it's on but I have to use it for other things and haven't found a reliable way to set it up and get it dead on first try yet. I have an idea for a vernier scale for the saw but haven't had time to pursue that yet.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#7

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Fred Holder

I use a pretty much regular blade, but I use a segment cutting jig on the saw. Here is a photo of the rig:


I've had this for several years, so don't remember where I got the hardware to build the rig. I hope this helps.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#8

Allan W

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Allan W

;) Thanks for the picture. I am always open to new ways of doing things. From the picture it doesn't like it to hard jig to make.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#9

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

jim 9 miles

Alan- very unlikely the blade is a factor. As others mentioned your angle is off just a fraction and it shows up on the final joint. Half rings and saw the last 2 joints is a workable solution. In the longer term suggest you build a sled for table saw. If you ( anyone else ) will send me your email I will send a picture of my sled. ( I can't figure out how to post a pic here ) Suggest also that your pick a standard # of segments- I use 12 on 98% 0f all my segmented work. Tweak your sled until you get it as accurate as possible and lock it down so the adjustments can't move.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#10

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

Dick Coers

If you make a jig like that, have it run on both side of the blade. Pieces dropping off after the cut may not make that cut the safest. Do more research on Tibbets work.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#11

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

John Lucas

The two things I did that really increased my accuracy were to make the jig so it runs in both miter slots. This reduces the slight racking since there has to be some minor slop in the miter slots to be able to slide freely. I also make my runners out of plastic or something that does not change with humidity.

The second was to buy a Forest blade. I put it off for a long time because they are expensive. It's the best investment I've made. The cuts are super clean and dead on. I use that on the table saw.

That being said I am pretty darn happy with my Freud blade that I purchased for the miter saw. I'm still getting used to the differences in my miter saw and the table saw but the Freud blade cuts really clean. One of the best segmented turners I have met was Gary Johnson. http://www.craftalliance.org/store/CategorySubDetail2.asp?CategoryID=191&CategorySubID=454&CategorySub2ID=26

What was amazing about his set up was he used a cheap miter saw with a good blade. Once he got it set through testing everything was clamped or glued into position so it could not move. His cuts were dead on. This tells me it's as much operator as the tool.

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#12

Another of Gary's pieces *LINK*

John Lucas

Scan down this page and you'll see one of his pieces. To get that many joints to be that accurate is incredible. Anyone can do an 8, 12 or 16 sided piece. I don't know how many Gary has, probably something like 32. That is really tough to be dead on with that many.


http://www.woodturner.org/gallery/growshar/

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

#13

jim miles

Re: What Blade for Segmented Bowls?

jim miles