Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Banjo Upgrade

Posts

Banjo Upgrade

#1

Banjo Upgrade

Richard Jones

No, Béla Fleck has no worries here...........

I have been debating/perusing the Oneway banjo to upgrade my Jet 1642. I don't do a lot of larger bowls, as they don't sell well, but I do like the ability to do so. I also realize that the curved Robust rests (I do have both) do a lot to negate the need for a larger banjo, dependent upon the form of the piece.

Who has done this and what are your thoughts? Was it worth the not-so-inconsiderable cost?

Thanks.

Rich

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: Banjo Upgrade

Alan Zenreich

I forgot to mention that Bob recently added a OneWay lathe to his shop, so I guess he liked the tool rest.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#4

Re: Banjo Upgrade

John Lucas

The tool rest on the old Nova 3000 was not the best in the world. I had one. The Jet on the other hand is pretty decent. Certainly enough to handle a 16" bowl. At least that's my opinion. If your having excessive chatter then it's possibly more about tool control than the tool rest banjo. Especially if you already own a good curved tool rest to get the tool close to the work. I would think the differnce in stability between the two banjos would be marginal. Now you might like the locking mechanism better but that's a different story.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#5

Re: Banjo Upgrade

robo hippy

I would suggest looking at the Robust banjo. Unlike most, rather than a set screw to secure the post on your tool rest, Brent came up with a screw through 2 wedges, so that when you tighten, the post is locked by the wedges, which gives the best grip of any banjo I have used. I haven't played with the Oneway banjos much though. I do like the longer lever arm to lock the banjo onto the ways.

Interesting point Bob makes about the Oneway inside bowl rest. I found it always bounced a bit when working on the tip (PM 3520A banjo, and Robust Beauty). The Robust inside bowl rest does not bounce at all.

robo hippy

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Banjo Upgrade

Dick Hines

Since Jet and PM are made basicly the same lathe why not a PM 3520 banjo?

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#7

Re: Banjo Upgrade

Dale Miner

I've demoed on a 1642 several times, including metal spinning.

The banjo seemed OK to me with one detractor; it needs to be about two inches longer. When doing larger bowl blanks, it is a bit to short to make doing the OD and back side of the blank without more tool overhang than is comfortable.

I can't recall any issues with the clamp method of the tool rest not being secure. For metal spinning, I did use an auxiliary clamp to keep the banjo from moving. Keep in mind, metal spinning does put a substantial axial thrust on the banjo compared to turning.

I turn on a 3520B, and prefer that banjo over a 2436 banjo. Familiarity probably weighs heavily in that preference. Both clamp the bed suffciently well, with the 2436 clamping a little better. I like the offset tool rest style of the 3520B.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#8

Re: Banjo Upgrade

Richard Jones

Dale,

"needs to be 2 inches longer" = exactly why I'm considering it. As you know, when you place the banjo at its outer limit, you sacrifice some stability. I've been looking at the 3520 banjos, and according to one source, I would only have to change the retaining nut, so I guess the ways are different dimensions.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#9

Reed........

Richard Jones

Thanks, I've sent Brent an e-mail requesting some info.

Rich

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#10

Re: Banjo Upgrade

John Lucas

Be sure and check the height from the bed to the top of the banjo. You may not or may not be able to get the tool rest to the proper height when using the 3520 banjo on the 1642. Same might be true with the Oneway so I would get all the specs before you buy one.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#12

The reason I say that is ....

John Lucas

I was doing demos at the Craft Center and somehow they had put a 2442 banjo on a 3520. It worked but I could not get the tool rest lower than dead center which meant my tools were cutting above center by the thickness of the tool. I use some tools with the tool rest well below center so it was rather clutsy to turn that day. I've also noticed the same problem when working on mini lathes with my homemade tool rests. The top of the banjo is different heights for many of those.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#13

Re: The reason I say that is ....

Peter Hyde

I have constant problems with the Powermatic banjo in as much that it constantly loosens all by itself. Yes I've tried different adjustments on the locking nut and yes it will come undone without being in use. I think the reason is the extra length allows the cam rod to bend and flex. Also the actual locking pressure varies along the length of the banjo in as much as the handle will completely turn 360 at one extremity while locking satisfactorily at the other. The Oneway 2036 banjo has a higher post but will accommodate most bar type toolrests. The banjo is shorter but still allows maximum radius pieces to be turned inside or outside. Outboard it's too short. However the big big plus is the locking action. The rod is square and has a captured eccentric bearing with a square centre hole that slides very easily along the length of the bar and locks with very little pressure. Most new users tend to over tighten and it then needs a really big yank on the long handle to release the banjo. Not something you would want to do if the lathe was running. :)

But it also needs a coat of Mustard Yellow :)

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#14

Bill Blasic

Re: The reason I say that is ....

Bill Blasic

I have had my 3520b for a number of years and I have never had the banjo come loose and I do not crank it down to tighten it. I believe there is little or no radial force just vertical force on a banjo so I don't know why it would loosen. I have never had a problem with any of my lathes having the banjo loosen. Another turning mystery.

Bill

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#15

Re: The reason I say that is ....

John Lucas

I did turn on a jet mini once that the banjo would vibrate loose. Drove me nuts. I have never had a single problem with my Powermatic. I do like the way Oneway does their lock however. It's very solid looking.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#16

Re: The reason I say that is ....

Peter Hyde

I've had the same experience with the Delta Midi and also a big General, but both of those were solved by adjusting the nut. The Powermatic just doesn't respond to anything and I'm still trying to figure out why it happens. I can tighten the handle down and as soon as I let go it slowly releases. I have found a setting on the nut that will hold for a short time but as soon as there's a hint of vibration on the tool rest the banjo just lets go. It's been stripped down and cleaned and lubricated and dried and every other possible combination I can think of, but so far to no avail. I've been told by a machinist that a light spring between the banjo and the clamping plate is what's needed. So the search is on for a suitable spring.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#17

Re: The reason I say that is ....

John Lucas

I sounds to me like the brass piece that rotates around the long bar and pulls it down might be worn, loose, or some other thing.

Re: Banjo Upgrade

#18

Re: Banjo Upgrade

gary jarvis

I had lots of problems with my jet 1642 banjo and replaced it with the oneway about 4 months ago. I wish I had done it 4 years ago. Money well spent. If you go with the oneway make sure it's for their 16 lathe.