Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

Posts

Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#1

Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

John Lucas

Well in short it doesn't work. Could be several problems. One is I don't know how good the seal is in baby food jars. I decanted the mini wax wipe on poly that was going bad by starting to Jel. A problem I've had with Watco as well. I end up throwing away about half a can all the time.

Anyway I thought I would decant it into smaller containers to reduce the amount of air. Then I tried thinning it (which it needed) using naptha, Lacquer thinner and Mineral spirits.

At first it looked like the mineral spirits was working. After a few weeks however it was as bad as the other two. A thick jel forms on the surface and the finish underneath is decidely thicker and needs to be thinned to work properly.

I thought it might be the air so I tried an experiment. I blew into the jar before closing the lid. That didn't seem to be any better than just closing the jar. So I went out and got my wine preservative spray and sprayed it in. If anything that was worse.

So I guess what it amounts to is I need to find another finish to use in the winter when I can't use lacquer.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#2

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

John Lucas

I meant to say that it appears that once the poly starts to jel it just seems to continue to go bad. You can thin it and get a little more life but not much. I do like that finish and may try finding some better small containers and see how the full jars with no thinner do to extend the life of the product.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#3

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

robo hippy

Yea, once it starts to go, you may be able to slow it down a little, but it is basically gone. Keeping the oxygen out of the can to start with helps extend life. There used to be a product called 'Bloxygen' that had some inert gas in it. I have heard of adding marbles to the can to bring it back to the top. Best solution, especially if you buy by the gallon or gallons, was to use one of the plastic collapsible wine/beverage storage things and fill it. As you pour out what you need, then no air is introduced. If you put finish back into the storage unit, since it is starting to cure, it will infect what is in the container and start it curing as well. It seems to do this even if there is no air in the can. I have found the gooey thick finish to be nice as kind of a friction polish that cures quickly, and builds fairly fast, but don't turn your back on it, or only lots of mineral spirits will take the lumps out, or at least let you wipe them off.

robo hippy

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

Mike Stafford

I only thin what I plan to use immediately. I have found that it gels in a few days after thinning. Since most of my projects are small I only have to thin an ounce or two to do the job. If I don't use it in a few days it will gel as you show in your picture.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#5

colapsing the can works.

bob davis

i squeeze the can in the vise as poly is used ..keeping liquid always to top. i can use the whole can. lasts indefinitely.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#6

John - Try using the LId on the jar!!   


Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#7

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

Galen Vetterick

Since the MSDS sheet says wipe on poly is 51 to 55% by weight of mineral spirits you would think you could thin it with the same. The can says thinning is not recomended so wonder if the is a chemical reaction that cuases a peripitate with a higher %. No chemist here. The MSDS sheet list that a hazardous decompostion product is carbon dioxide so maybe why your breath did not do any good to extend the life. Not sure what the wine perservative gas is.

The new can I have only list the batch number and I cannot see any expiration date or shelf life on the can.

I too throw out too much for letting it sit before the next use and it's not cheap or at least for this retired old man.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#8

Wow Jake what a great idea 


Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#9

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

mjonesrdg

You might try this: ( a tip from a friend ) decant to small jars so as to eliminate as much exposure to air as possible to the whole new can of finish. Place the small jars in zip-lock bags and seal, partially from the middle out, leaving an unsealed bit at both ends. Insert the nozzle of your Bernz-o-matic at one end and let a bit of propane into the bag. When you can smell it coming out the other unsealed end, zip it closed. And if your propane torch and finish is at room temperature, then place the bags in the fridge. The bag will collapse a bit, and this will tell you that there has been no air leaks during the ensuing months.

I've been doing this, but only for about four months...it'll take a year before I can say..."it works!"

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#10

Turn can upside down

Mike Brazeau

I have had the gelling problem with General Finishes Salad Bowl Finish and the past few months I am trying storing the can upside down so the air space is away from the lid seal. Seems to be working. I have a theory that temperature cycling in the shop, may induce movement of air in and out of the can. Even in small amounts it may introduce oxygen for the polymerization as well as evaporation of solvents in the finish. I have not tried storing Minwax Wipe on Poly this way.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#11

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

Paul Simon

Just be sure to wear a face mask and stand away from the fridge line of fire when you open the door. Or take the light out for a year.

Something about flameable gas in enclosed spaces.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#12

Ted Calver

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

Ted Calver

John, Ya gotta brush your teeth before you blow in the jar :b (Sorry, couldn't resist) :D

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#13

Hang on to your marbles John!

Jorge

and put them in the jar until the air is gone.

You can aslo buy smaller cans t start with.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#14

Re: Hang on to your marbles John!

John Lucas

Jorge I always hear about the marbles and I guess in theory it works. What do you do with the marbles when the can is empty? I suppose you have to dump them out and clean them. That's why I haven't tried this yet.

I'm actually going to go to the camping store today and see if they still sell those clear plastic Toothpaste sort of tubes that roll up. If the plastic doesn't itself pass air then this might be a decent decanter that you could roll all the air out of after each use. I couldn't find these doing a quick search of some camp stores. Maybe my trip to town will be of some help.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#15

marbles also work if you dont want to crush

bob davis

dont worry about cleaning them. marbles are cheap.these are two simple solution i know that work .i used marbles before finding crushing can was usually easier..the marble idea was recommended by general finishes years ago when they introduced their three part finishing system...

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#16

Re: Hang on to your marbles John!

Don in Central Illinois

John, when I was still doing darkroom work I had some accordian plastic bottkes. I think I've lost them but that should work, if we can find any. As you use the solution you just push down and 'fold up' the botyle, not allowing any air to remain in the bottle.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#17

Rob Wallace

Let's understand the chemistry....

Rob Wallace

.....because some of what is being suggested is not relevant for this finish. Hopefully this might answer a few questions....

Polyurethane molecules do not cross-link with one another by using oxygen as oil-based finishes do (tung oil, linseed oil, etc. in products such as Watco or Formby's Tung-oil Finish). Keeping air out of these oil finishes IS important to prevent skin-over and all the other oxygen-based linking processes that come from air exposure. Use of Bloxygen, compressed CO2, "squeezing the can", marbles, and even adding water to displace the air all will help reduce unwanted curing in oil-based finishes.

THAT SAID - I would NEVER follow the suggestion of adding propane gas to a plastic bag and storing it in a refrigerator. Unless you have special, totally gas-impermeable plastic bags, the propane will likely diffuse through the plastic (it's a small molecule!) and could easily build up within the refrigerator to a concentration that could potentially be explosive - even a sparking thermostat contact or static discharge could be a sufficient ignition source. BAD ADVICE - don't do it!

OIL FINISHES - The reason why air exclusion works (by using marbles, crushing the can, using Bloxygen, or as some suggest, breathing into the container [which would not create enough CO2 to work effectively]) with oil-based finishes is that oxygen from the air is used as the link between adjacent fatty-acids of the oil, which forms a chemical bridge, making a network of chemical bonds (bridged with oxygen) that forms the "cured" finish. Sometimes these are referred to as "drying oil" finishes....as opposed to other oils (mineral, corn, peanut, etc.) which do not cross link (fewer double bonds in fatty acids) and go rancid instead of curing ("drying").

POLYMERIZED FINISHES - Finishes of this type (chemically reactive), which include polyurethane (as well as epoxies, etc.), do not necessarily incorporate oxygen in the same way as oil finishes do then whey cure. With polyurethane, the loss of solvent through evaporation once the finish is applied, allows the monomeric forms of the urethane in solution to become more concentrated and allows more rapid polymerization, in this case without the need for oxygen as part of the reaction. The monomer urethane (carbamate) units bond through chemical attack by bound nitrogen interaction with one another to form the polymerized version of the material. The chemically curious might want to look at these links to better understand the process: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyurethane and http://chem.chem.rochester.edu/~chem424/ureth.htm

Occasionally, if water is included in the reaction mix with these urethane reactants, one of the byproducts is carbon dioxide gas. (This is why polyurethane glues foam as they "cure" (polymerize) and swell out of the joints; polyurethane foams are created by careful addition of water to reactive urethane monomer mixes). That's possibly one of the reasons why the MSDS lists carbon dioxide as a potentially harmful byproduct. For our discussion, if the air in the wipe-on poly storage container is humid/moist or contains significant water vapor, this may add to the polymerization potential, and allow the finish to "go bad" or "gel" more quickly. As you use-up the wipe-on finish, there will be less finish in the container and room for more HUMID air (not oxygen exposure) in the container; thus, more water in contact with the finish can contribute to polymerization of the urethanes, and, well.... you know the rest of the story.

The can of Minwax wipe-on poly that I just looked at in my shop has no indication at all of what the actual reactive components are. Even reading the MSDS ( http://www.rockler.com/tech/RTD20000221AA.pdf ), it provides ZERO help in understanding what the polymerization components are in the product being discussed (proprietary information). With the wipe-on poly situation, there may be some mix of both oil and polyurethane finishes (...or not?), but the short story is that once the polyurethane begins its polymerization by whatever means (loss of solvent, metallic accelerators, co-polymerization with oil finishes, etc.) no amount of dilution with mineral spirits or trying to keep air out of the mix will eliminate the process of polymerization (although it may effect the rate), which will continue and form a gel - and eventually a solid (?). In short - the liquid finish is toast. Discard it and use fresh finish.

If others know more specifically what is in the wipe-on poly finishes, I would love to know that information. My guess is that it's a fairly well-guarded trade secret.

To borrow from one of our own, "Life is too short to use crappy finishes"..... (thanks John!)

Rob Wallace

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#18

Thanks for the informed "heads-up"

mjonesrdg

........THAT SAID - I would NEVER follow the suggestion of adding propane gas to a plastic bag and storing it in a refrigerator. Unless you have special, totally gas-impermeable plastic bags, the propane will likely diffuse through the plastic (it's a small molecule!) and could easily build up within the refrigerator to a concentration that could potentially be explosive - even a sparking thermostat contact or static discharge could be a sufficient ignition source. BAD ADVICE - don't do it!.....

Thanks for the warning. (I'm gonna clean out my shop fridge in the morning!)

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#19

Re: Hang on to your marbles John!

John Lucas

Don I used the same things in the darkroom but as far as I know they are too large but I'll look for some of them.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#20

Thanks Rob


Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#21

Re: Let's understand the chemistry....

DickL in Tampa

Always good to have a scientific basis for understanding what is going to work and what will not. Beats guessing every time. Thanks Dr. Wallace for the info.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#22

Re: Let's understand the chemistry....

bill Crommett

Rob: A beautiful and informative discourse on finishes, but your parenthetical disclaimer of blowing into the can is in error to the extent that properly done it is a viable action. Consider the anatomy of the respiratory system with it's functional space and it's dead air space. With the alviolae composing the functional space and the bronchial branches composing the dead air apace, one must exhaust the dead air space which still has oxygen in it before getting to the oxygen deprived alveolar air which consists of mostly CO2 before blowing into the can. This "blue -in-the-face' hyper ventilation procedure takes a little practice and is good only for oil finishes, but when used correctly is quite effective and financially rewarding in saved varnish products.

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#23

Rob Wallace

Easier with CO2 from baking soda & vinegar?

Rob Wallace

Hi Bill -

I just got the reminder e-mail about your reply....

I agree with you that if "deep lung" air were used it might be of sufficient CO2 concentration to create a 'blanket' effect and displace any air left in the container. As you note, there is a learning curve about how to do this effectively. While I don't doubt that it can be done (and learned), it would still need to be confirmed (and I would need to be convinced) that it was done with non-turbulent gas flow into the container to be effective in laying in a sufficient layer of CO2 to work in preventing oxygen contact with the finish, and not actually bring-in air with turbulent flow.

In practical terms, I think it would be much simpler to just produce CO2 with vinegar and baking soda in a suitable container, just pour the heavier gas carefully into the can of finish, and seal the container with minimal disturbance. For those of us who are homebrewers and use a keg system, a gentle stream of CO2 from our dispensing tank is another easy substitute for "going blue in the face" (this is what I use when I'm out of Bloxygen).

Thanks for the comments! I'll have to experiment with some Watco, baby food jars, and "deep-lung air". We used to have a CO2 concentration meter in our department, but it no longer works....it would have been fun to throw some instrumentation at this question!).

Rob

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#24

Don-found these  *LINK*


http://www.2spi.com/catalog/photo/air-evac.shtml

Re: Diluting minwax wipe on poly update

#25

John, I used to have some of ......

JamieDonaldson

...those accordian bottles, and they didn't work very well for chemicals due to leaky lids that didn't seal very well.