David Pye in his book The Nature and Art of Workmanship defines The workmanship of risk vs the Workmanship of certainty. Have you ever taken on a project in which the outcome was risky, not certain. I have and usually patience and possibly testing before I start reduces the risk and increases the certainty.
Sometimes this is done with mock ups or test pieces. Sometimes it's more of an evolved skill.
The piece I'm working on now has all the risk in the final step. In other words there is a lot of work being done to get it to the final step but there isn't enough time to do enough testing to guarantee the final step will work. So this piece is a good example of The workmanship of Risk.
Fortunately nothing but time is lost if I don't succeed. I will learn something from the process for later on. Wish the deadline for the AAW Currents show was just a little further away. Then I would fee comfortable doing some more testing and decreasing the workmanship of risk and increasing the workmanship of certainty.
Why would you ever try to do something you knew you could do? How boring would that be? It's so much more interesting to try to do things that you hope you can do...or learn from failing.
We are only here for so long. We sleep away 1/3 of our life. We work away another 1/3. Somewhere in that remaining 1/3, we eat, we drink, we walk, we raise families, we play... leaving so little time to "get good at something that we have passion for"
Shakespeare knew how to write a sonnet. He knew that he could write one successfully. He wrote over 150 that we know of. Each is similar to the others in form. None involved great risks in the writing or broke new literary ground. Each of his sonnet's is a unique work of art, beautifully distinct from the others and from anyone else's. Each reflects the years he spent working within the same form honing and perfecting his craft. Millions are grateful that he didn't abandon the sonnet once he proved to himself he could write one.
None of this is meant to imply that your "life is too short to attempt something you already know how to do philosophy" is wrong. It is meant to demonstrate that such a philosophy is not the only valid way to approach art.
Just because you've made 100 or 1000 bowls, doesn't mean you have no risk. Risk comes in many forms. Can you make it thinner? Can you get a better cut? Can you get a better line? Can you make the interior a little bit more interesting.
My point was about pushing myself and not accepting my own limits as anything but temporary limits. When you give yourself permission to fail, you liberate yourself from fear.
I have no doubt in my mind that Shakespeare (or Bacon perhaps?) wrote some sonnets that were "B-side" efforts and they ended up in a ball in the fireplace...if you never try, you never fail. If you never fail, you never succeed.
I think in the turning world we have two parallel paths we take. We have the technical skills that evolve and we have the design or creative element that we refine. Each has a risk reward relationship. It is human nature to push the envelope and grow with each piece we do. Even when we do 100 stair rails we do the last one better then we did the first one.
Some wise woodworker said, "Half the art of being a Master woodworker is being able to cover your mistakes". So, some risk leads to 'design opportunities'. Some risk leads to the fire place.
Pye's definition of risk is a bit different from the way you understand it. He's talking about processes that are controlled by the maker's hand and eye, as opposed to having a controlled outcome as you would get with a machine fixture or other protocol that doesn't require skill. You seem to be talking about testing or practicing before actually performing the process to increase the odds of success. In your case, if it is a skilled operation you're doing, risk is intrinsic regardless of how much you practice. You could convert it to the workmanship of certainty by jigging it up to be done mindlessly by a machine or a controlled operation.
Attempting something new often involves both kinds of workmanship. You might use your thickness planer (certainty) to prepare your mirror blank, and your lathe to spin it in a controlled arc (certainty), but then use a hand-held gouge or bedan to actually form the shapes and features you want. That last, risky step is going to be less risky if you practice it a few times, but it will always entail some degree of risk. Similarly, a spray gun delivers a controlled amount and pattern of spray, but it is your skill that makes the gun produce a good finish, free of sags and orange peel.
When I was in the custom woodworking business, every single job originated with a design problem that some customer had brought to me. No two jobs were the same, so every job became an R&D project that had to succeed with the first attempt, or else I lost my shirt. It was a very high risk situation, and it required a lot of jigging up and tooling and machine process in order to guarantee as successful an outcome as possible. It was particularly important to eliminate risk since I had employees and apprentices who were being called upon to do much of the work. I couldn't afford to have them mess anything up either, although that didn't always work out as well as it might have.
For me, the feeling of taking chances and relying on my own hands and eyes and experience is probably my favorite things about being a designer-craftsman. I hesitate to use the term woodworker because what I do often requires a lot of other skills as well. But, regardless of how many controlled process I use to bring about a result (often time or cost constraints dictate the workmanship of certainty), it is the feeling of accomplishment when the piece is finished that drives me and carries me home. (Tip of the hat to Dan Fogelberg.
I continue to push my own envelope and try things that I've never done before with the knowledge that it will increase my skill set and give me more options in my next piece. I usually try to do practice on scrap for a new skill that has risk, but some are, as you said John, that last step where the risk comes into play. Those are harder to plunge into, especially if you have a lot of time invested. But you won't ever know if you can unless you just do it. Hopefully you have it thought out and by doing so, decrease the odds of failure. But you still have to take the plunge to find out.
If this is still about the fan pattern glue-up, I have concerns that it may self-destruct sometime in the future due to movement in the walnut, especially on the outside parts, where the grain is nearly perpendicular to its neighbor.
I have to wonder if it wouldn't work better, if you left the walnut as a solid ground, then rout the grooves only as deep as needed to stay visible on the face.
I'm sure you could easily bend in little 1/8"x 1/8" square strips, but even that holds some risk, if the MC changes. DAHIKT.
Keith I went through the wood movement thing many years ago. There isn't enough wood movement in these parts to affect the outcome. I kept one that broke many years ago. It broke because I made the opening for the glass to small and when it went to a gallery that had a very low humidity the wood shrunk against the glass and the wood lost. I glued it back together and kept it for demos to discuss wood movement. I'm had it stored in my, in unheated buildings and in my dry house and just about everywhere else in the last 10 years. It's still solid.
It is important to look at wood movement in your work and design accordingly. It is better to route grooves and fill them but it's just not as nice. If you route to the edges the depth of the route shows and it's OK and different but I don't like it as much. If you route not completely to the edges then you have the problem of cutting the pieces to absolutely perfect length.
In both case above you still have woodmovement problems similar to breadboard ends on a table. The ends of the veneer strips can stick out or receded seasonally and you'll feel lumps. You do get the same with the way I'm doing the mirrors. It is very sublte in that you can feel it barely but can't see it.
I personally enjoy pursuing Wild Hares - off the wall ideas - that I initially have no idea as to whether it can result in anything close to what I had in mind. As long as it stays interesting I'll spend the time, effort and money to pursue making the idea a reality. Of course, sometimes an even more interesting idea comes up . . .
Interesting subject often used to attribute a higher value to Workmanship of Risk over that of Workmanship of Certainty. In the case of hand crafted objects, as opposed to machine fabricated objects, the process of creating the object can be broken down into to two discrete processes - one primarily mental, the other primarily physicalm though requiring some mental use as well.
The process of conceiving the idea for an objects and then developing a means by which it can actually be made - either by the person who came up with the idea and worked out how it could be made - or by someone else with the knowledge and tools and techniques that can produce the object AND the eye / hand coordination to apply that knowledge and skills and those tools involves RISK - RISK implying "risk of failure". Though a mental process, it does involve the risk of failure. I would categorize Einstein's development of his Theory of Relativity as an example of "workmanship of risk"- that was successful. On the other hand, his efforts to develop a Unified Theory was also an example of "workmanship of risk" - and one that has not been proved to be "successful".
The process of using hand controlled tools to create an object similar to one the "maker" has successfully made before, or has seen successfully made before, is more an example of the hand crafted implied meaning of "workmanship of risk". The physical control of the tool being used to make an object and the knowledge, skills and abilities necessary to perform the physical operation involves a higher "risk of failure" than would be the case if the tool and the process of its use were controlled by something else - say a micro-computer/controller or some other "programmable" device (see The Jacquard Loom for an all mechanical example of the latter).
Wharton Esherick came up with some very interesting interpretations of functional furniture. Some he was actually able to make. But some he had to collaborate on with a person who had skills he, Esherick, lacked. His Corner Desk, the one that is all triangles and trapezoids, was WAY OUTSIDE THE BOX when it came to "desk". It was also beyond his ability to actually fabricate / construct. So to have his conceived idea become real, in the physical world, he collaborated with a very experienced German cabinetmaker. The resulting piece of furniture is known as a Wharton Esherick Corner Desk. The fact that Esherick credited the actual maker by putting is initial in the piece, and acknowledged his contribution, took nothing from Esherick nor diminished the fact that it was his piece, elevated my opinion of Esherick as an artist, designer and craftsman. Chihuly, on the other hand . . .
From your description of your dilemma, it would appear that most if not all the risk involved in making the object you've conceived of is in the physical skills required to perform the last operation in the making of the piece - specifically your manual dexterity using the tool or tools to be used - or the potential physical limitations of the materials you're working with - or both. Apparently, neither can be tested prior to your expending a significant amount of time, effort and perhaps materials cost.
Sometimes there is an "economy of scale". Could a smaller prototype be used to test the operation that involves the most risk - the LAST operation - or would that involve even more risk?
The other possible means of reducing the risk to an acceptable level would be to examine the processes required to get to the last step. Are ALL of them necessary to test the process you're concerned about? Is there ANOTHER way to get to where you want to go - that's less risky and perhaps less time consuming?
The more specific a problem is defined, the more likely a solution can be found, or a better solution can be found. While I understand the desire to work independently and the satisfaction that can come with "I did it all by myself", sometimes "keeping it a secret" can act as a barrier to "success".
There could be another interpretation of the "risk" factor...One can become very comfortable in their current work; it's become second nature, has your "signature"style, and sells well. The risk is trying something new, outside your comfort zone. Will customers welcome your new style or form, or will they reject (refuse to buy) it? Will you make a fool out of yourself? Will you be praised or ridiculed? Stick with the comfortable, or swing for the fences?