ONe of the problems I have with the assembly of my bent wood fan mirrors is bending the wood. It acts like a spring and so I'm trying to put 10 wedge shaped pieces of wood together with 8 springy pieces of wood all made slippery with glue. It gets interesting.
Over the years I have played with heat bending wood to get it close to shape before being glued together. This helps a lot. The problem is I don't have one of the heat bending rigs and they are very expensive. I just aim a propane torch into a piece of pipe and then use that. Well it's really hit or miss because the pipe gets too hot. Anyone have any suggestions for a more controlled way of heating the pipe. I don't have a heat gun although I am definitly in the market for one. Not sure that's the solution but would solve some other problems I have.
I have made bent laminiations and they look great but then I have a hand mirror with 4 or 5 hours invested and can't sell them for anywhere near what they are worth.
It is easy and fast to use the microwave. Wrap a paper towel soaked with water around the strip and nuke it. Get it steaming hot. Depends on how much water volume you use but I'd guess it would be boiling in about a minute. Place it immediately in a form with a little more bend then you want, cause there will be a ltttle spring back after it cools. Use gloves of course, it should be very hot. You might be able to do two at once if the bends are simular arcs.
Or a cheap HF heat gun in the metal pipe luthier style might be more controllable than a torch as you said.
For what it's worth, when we built the Onrust (a 17th century Dutch ship replica) we bent huge planks and wales into some serious compound curves just by heating fresh-cut wood with a few of the large weed-burning type torches and twisting and bending them to shape and letting them cool in position. The planks are 1 1/8" thick x 8" wide and as long as 20 feet white oak. The wales are 2 1/4" thick x 8" wide and up to 20' long also white oak. Some of them have severe twist, bend and bow. They are held in place with wooden pegs (trunnels) which are wedged on each end to create a rivet-type of effect. That is supposed to be how they did it back then.
The guy who calls himself the "Crazy Canadian" was demoing at the wood working show. He uses a ladies curling iron sitting in a cradle. He just dips the wood in water and bends it on the hot curling iron. He let the audience participate and I was able to make a nice bend the first time.
A nice heavy duty curling irons will set you back $15 at Ollies or Big Lots.
Thanks guys. I had forgotten about the microwave. I took a one day class with Hosaluk and we did that. I've done it a few times at home. Estimating the spring back will take a few trials but then they don't have to be perfect just close enough to take the spring affect out of them.
The curling iron sounds like a good solution. when you bend with just heat you don't really get spring back so you can get it really close to the correct curve.
I looked it up and you need about 350 to 400 degrees.
My grandfather built boats. He would wrap the chines in grass sacks and pore boiling water on them. Worked every time.
I saw a guy bend wood by holding it over a 3" pipe with a torch stuck in the end. He would soak the wood and work it over the pipe until he got the bend he wanted. I think there was a article about this he did for Woodturning Design some years ago.
Steve I've tried all those methods over the years. They all work. The only one I don't have much experience with is the heat method which is why I was asking. Got some interesting replies.
I'll buy a curling iron tomorrow and tell the people I'm buying it for my dog to see what they say.
John, when I use to make dulcimers I had to bend the wood on the sides. I have a 4 or 5 inch piece of steel pipe that I heat with a propane torch. When I'm set hot and ready, I lay a soaking wet towel on the pipe then follow with the wood. Depending on the thickness, I sometime flip the wood from front to back then put some pressure on the ends, it seems to hesitate or resist a few seconds, then it will just give and bend easily. I've easily take a 3/4" x 1" piece and made a circle with it.
Thanks Josh. I"ll give it a try. I'm thinking if I use a larger piece of pipe it will spread the heat better. The wet rag will of course add moisture and help. I'll probably set the rag on fire and burn my shop down. Can I sue you if I do.
I hope you don’t mind if a throw a bunch of information as you- I have been using the hot-pipe method for a long time, and here are a few tips that may help you get better results:
It helps if the radius of the pipe is only slightly smaller that the radius of the desired bend- this way you get a better proportion of hot curved metal surface that will activate the lignin in the wood. Lignin is what holds the cellulose in the cells in place, and because it is thermoplastic, the heat allows the lignin to soften and thus the cells can distort and slip into a new position that should set as they cool.
The tight diameter of most curling irons may not give you enough surface area, unless you need a very tight radius bend, and the wood is very thin. I have bent some wood strips to a 3/16" radius on a hot soldering iron, but they were only 1/32” thick.
Using a propane torch will work just fine, but there are a few tips that make it easier:
A pipe with a thicker wall usually helps, because it has more thermal mass and will hold the heat longer- thin wall pipes cool down to fast, and don’t help regulate the heat either. my best bending pipes are aluminum with about a 1/4” thick wall. Black pipe will work OK, but be careful heating up galvanized plumbing pipe- (the fumes are terrible, and they say breathing it causes dain bramage, but I don’t know for sure about that). Don’t use a pipe that it too long (can’t be heated evenly with a torch, and chokes the flame), or too short (won’t hold enough heat to work). Most of my bending pipes are about 5 to 8 inches long, and range in diameter from 7/8” up to about 5” diameter.
Also, don’t stuff the torch deep into the pipe- it may make it hard to keep it lit because it deprives the flame of adequate oxygen. Once the pipe comes up to the right heat, the flame can be turned to a little above a whisper. A smaller flame also helps create an evenly heated pipe- hot spots can scorch the wood before the wood is evenly heated and ready to bend.
Don’t heat the pipe so hot that the wood scorches- a drop of water should just sizzle on the pipe, and not instantly vaporize. the best heat range is about the same as you would use on a pancake griddle (proving once again that a good breakfast is essential for good woodworking).
The moisture content present in the wood will make a difference as to how it bends, but keep in mind that too much moisture will contribute to spring back. this means that surface moisture will act as a vehicle for moving the heat into the wood- up to a depth of about 3/16” max. Soaking the wood for more than a few minutes may raise the interior moisture content too high, therefore preventing the bend from setting. I usually just spray the surface with water from a spray bottle, rub it in a bit to break the surface tension, maybe wait a few minutes for it to penetrate, then slowly heat it up on the pipe by rolling it over the hot surface to heat a larger area, then when I feel the wood relax, tighten the bend to the pipe.
Holding the wood on the hot iron until you hear the sizzle stop will “bake” the bend- drying out the interior moisture and thereby helping set the curve. Avoid doing this before you have reached the desired curve: baking out the moisture can make it impossible to modify the bend, since very dried wood will not respond to re-bending, even if you re-soak it. Some luthiers say it ‘looses its memory” and tends to crack if you force it.
You have probably already discovered that the wood needs to be straight grained, with minimal run out, and not too much figure. Flat sawn tends to bend a bit easier than quarter sawn, but doesn’t hold the curve as easily. Thinner pieces bend easier- try to keep it under 3/16" thick if you can.
I realize this may be way too much information, but you are welcome to call me if you have any questions. I can also recommend some specific articles if you need more info, but I suspect practice will give you most of what you need.
Mike I know steaming will work. I've done steam bending. I just don't want to go to that much trouble for 6 small pieces of wood. I like the simplicity of the curling iron if it will work. I may go to Goodwill tomorrow and see if they have one. I'm also going by the office and may ask the secretaries if they have a spare. I'll tell them I'm going back to the Afro look I had in the 70's.
John: If you are going to tell the people you will be using the curling iron on your dog, be sure not to suggest the two of you are going on a Kibbles diet. Maybe some of them haven't heard the joke.
Your description of hot-pipe bending is exactly the way I used to do it. The spritz of wood from the spray bottle is a key to the process, as the steam penetrates and makes the bend easier.
I am not sure how long the pieces you are looking to bend are, but assuming they are relatively small you should be able to boil them, then bend them around a form. Leave them on the form overnight and they should stay relatively in the shape of the form. I have made a number of Shaker boxes and that is the bending process for those. The bends around the corners are pretty severe and I have had very few failures. I also have a cobbled up steam box I have used to bend Windsor chair arms but I agree that setting that up is a chore.
These pieces are less than 6" long. I have done the boiling method and it works great. In this case I want more or less instant gratification and don't want to make the cauls and wait overnight for my glue ups.
I can glue the pieces in small groups quite well without all the fuss but want to figure out a way to make it go faster and easier to keep the cost down on these. I've tried selling these mirrors for $75 which is what I would need to get at the current rate of production and they just don't sell at that price. Not in my market. I like making them but have to find a faster less labor intensive way of doing it.
Thanks Micheal. It's not too much information since I've played with this and other bending process's over the years. It just helps round out my book for the next round of experiments.
Beautiful piece of furniture. My mirrors are going to take some different directions now but may not go to that extreme. Thanks for posting both the info and photo
I don't think it can. When bending copper pipe you have to inserts something inside to keep the walls from collapsing. I've bent copper by filling it with sand and it didn't collapse. I would think to do it successfully you would probably have to fill the inside with something and then probably put a strap around the outside of the bend which works on a flat surface but not sure how it would work on a radius surface. Shouldn't take much work to find out. Turn one and try one the heating methods mentioned above.
I would soak it, fill it with sand, microwave it and then try to bend it. turn the walls fairly thin. for a T pot spout your not taking about a large bend so who knows.
John, I seem to remember that wood strips can be bent after exposure to ammonia, either fumes or solution. Dont recall the details, but it can be looked up. Would appear to be a simple method.
In shipmodel building, liquid ammonia is sometimes recommended for making wood easier to bend. Some people swear by it, others swear at it. It may depend on the specific wood. But most would concede that hot water, or damp wood and heat, or steam work as well (or better). Without the stink.
I recently bent a strip of ash 1/4" thick, 3" wide and 34" long by simmering it in my Shaker box tray. Bent it around the 10" radius frame easily. After it dried in 24 hours there was no springback whatever.
Ammonia works great however it will discolor some woods because it reacts with the tannin. We used to soak wooden yardsticks and tie them into a knot as a gimmick. It has limits like any wood bending technique and will split on the outside of the corner when you get too tight. You can put a band around the outside and it will let you bend tighter.
I use a piece of PVC pipe with caps on both ends. That way I don't have to smell it that much.