Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Long term chuck test

Posts

Long term chuck test

#1

Long term chuck test

John Lucas

I decided it was time to clean a couple of my chucks today so I cleaned cleaned one Vicmarc and my one Grizzly copy. I've had both of these chucks about 5 years and used them extensively. Here's what I learned.

The grizzly is a good chuck. I'm happy with it, especially for the price. I noticed it's now gone up to $119 which includes the insert.

I pulled the back off. The Grizzly isn't sealed as tight and had dust inside but very little. The Vicmarc was spotless. The Vicmarc has some grease from the factory on the gears, the Grizzly was either dry o rwhatever they used would not show up.

There is a roll pin to keep the jaws from coming out. It was hard to remove on the Vicmarc but I got it out with some needle nose vice grips and a twisting action. I thought the Grizzly didn't have one but it turns out somewhere along the line I somehow mashed it over and flat. I guess from cranking the jaws out too far. That's a pretty crappy pin they used.

The Grizzly rust easier than the Vicmarc. Each slide is stamped just like the Vicmarc but Grizzly also stamped the body to match the jaws. I didn't try putting them in the wrong slots to see if it made a difference.

The GRizzly has more slop than the Vicmarc. It doesn't seem to make much difference when in actual use. The rear cover has sharp edges which I long ago filed down. The same is true with their jaws which have sharper edges than the Vicmarcs.

Over the years I have swapped inserts and jaws amount the GRiz and Vicmarc and have not noticed a problem.

All in all I'm pretty happy with the Grizzly. I'll still probably buy the Vicmarc's if I can but they are almost double in price.

Re: Long term chuck test

#2

Re: Long term chuck test

Bernie Weishapl

John I have found the same as you have when cleaning mine. I bought the Vic VM 100 and then found that grizzly was the same chuck. I bought mine when they were $89.95 each. I bought 5 of them and put Vic jaws on them basically because I am lazy and don't like changing jaws. lol I am happy with all of mine and haven't had a dimes worth of problems with any of them. Yes the Vic is a better chuck but the Griz chucks do the job.

Re: Long term chuck test

#3

Harry Robinette

Re: Long term chuck test

Harry Robinette

John

Thanks that's a good thing to know.I use all Nova Chucks but you never no when a good deals going to change things.

Re: Long term chuck test

#4

Re: Long term chuck test

John Lucas

Bernie I was having trouble with them getting snug at one point in the travel of the jaws. As it turned out there was gunk built up on the inner jaw slides but it gave me a good chance to look over the chucks more closely.

Re: Long term chuck test

#5

Rewarding Quality and Innovation

don stephan

No doubt there is a significant difference in price. And they may offer somewhat similar performance. But even though money is very dear in this ongoing recession, I'm not comfortable rewarding a copy cat. Without Vicmarc's willingness to invest in product testing and development there wouldn't be a Grizzly clone. Doubtful any of us would be happy if we invested significant time and materials in developing an innovating product only to see import copies sold for a fraction of our price. Just my opinion, but I'll swap jaws on my VM120 until I can afford a second one rather than buy a clone.

Re: Long term chuck test

#6

Re: Long term chuck test

Bernie Weishapl

John again that is my experience. I found the same thing. I just make it a point to disassemble them once every 1 1/2 yrs or so. Since I do clock work I run them thru my ultra sonic cleaner which cleans them extremely well then rinse with Denatured alcohol. Blow off with a air hose and they are good to go.

Re: Long term chuck test

#7

Seems that the Grizzly quality is slipping

Dick Coers

I've had one of the Griz for a couple years, no trouble, so ordered another just after Christmas this year. It gets very stiff and notchy as it gets past half way to max open. Burrs inside? Two of the jaws will not tighten to chuck. Looks like the screws are either too long, or tapped not deep enough. It's going back for a replacement.

Re: Long term chuck test

#8

Re: Long term chuck test *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

Is this the one you are referring to?

The Grizzly equivalent in Canada is Busy Bee Tools and the chuck is B2618, if I remember correctly. I have two of these, with an assortment of jaws. You're right about being careful not to crank them too far open, though.

BOB


http://cdn0.grizzly.com/manuals/h6265_m.pdf

Re: Long term chuck test

#9

That's it


Re: Long term chuck test

#10

Re: Long term chuck test

walta

“Then rinse with Denatured alcohol. Blow off with a air hose”

Be very careful you are vaporizing about ½ a cup of fuel into the air.

Denatured alcohol has a very low flash point.

Once I was cleaning with a paper towel wet with alcohol a small spark from a picture tube and in instant there was a ball of fire. I barley felt the shock.

Walt