Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Carving stands

Posts

Carving stands

#1

Carving stands

John Lucas

I was finishing up this carving and barely touched one of my gouges. It's a really small cut but won't stop bleeding so I came in to find a bandaid. While I'm at it I thought I would start a discussion on carving stands.

I bought the Bestwoodtools carving stand when it first came out. I'm pretty happy with it with a few exceptions. the two knobs are both evil and good. I love being able to lock it at the angle you want to carve and then just adjust the rotating handle to access the area you want. But that is also bad in that the handle rotates and you have to look for it each time you use it. I don't know if the carving stands that have one adjustment knob that loosens everything would be any easier. Some functions would I'm sure and some would not.

On rare occasions I've had the tilting mechanism loosen up. It's usually whe doing heavier carving on heavy pieces and carving in the direction that would unscrew the backside of the locking mechanism. This has been pretty rare but does happen.

Over all I'd say I'm pretty happy with it and have certainly done a lot of carving off this thing.

I'm not familiar with the other carving stands. Anyone have one they like and would like to give a review of it.


Re: Carving stands

#2

Re: Carving stands

Mike Gibson

What we all want to really know is who is Barb......... ;)

Re: Carving stands

#3

Re: Carving stands

John Lucas

Mike Barbara was my wife. This piece is about about finding memories so I made the mirror similar to one that I gave her many years ago. How's your Current piece coming?

Re: Carving stands

#4

Jim Evans

Re: Carving stands *LINK*

Jim Evans

John, have you looked at Trent Bosch's carving stand? It's pneumatic, but a little (lot) pricey.


Pneumaic carving stand

Re: Carving stands

#5

Re: Carving stands

Mike Gibson

Darn, thought it may have been a new girlfriend. :) My latest is going slowly.

Re: Carving stands

#6

I just use my lap (ala John J)


Re: Carving stands

#7

Re: I just use my lap (ala John J)

John Lucas

Mike I stabbed my finger. Don't want to stab what's in my lap. :)

Re: Carving stands

#10

Rob Wallace

I was going to post Trent's pneumatic...

Rob Wallace

....but you beat me to it!

I've wanted one of these air actuated ball mount holders for a while, but was saving for the new lathe. Now that the new Robust has settled-in, I may be ready (?).... Having a look at Trent's web site, it looks like they are now "significantly" on sale, and I just might take the plunge for the new tool!

I currently have the Bestwood like John Lucas has, and I think it's a very good value and it certainly works well.

Rob Wallace

Re: Carving stands

#11

I have one like that Wilton

Keith Newton

Which I bought back in the 70ies. While it did a pretty good job, not much of the things I carve will fit on it.

Most of my turning work gets carved while still on the lathe, then followed by being held between my knees while I sit straddle a carpeted bench.

Otherwise, It would likely be larger panels which would be clamped down to the bench.

The Wilton serves as a quick platform for sharpening carbide blades on one of my grinders with a diamond wheel.

Re: Carving stands

#12

Kelton Carver's Jig *LINK*

Jeff Willaford

I've had this one for a while and really like it. I can put just about anything at just about any angle for hand or power carving. nothing moves unless I want it to.

Pricey but I can use it in the banjo of my lathe as I have no work bench or other horizontal surface in the shed that serves as my shop.




http://www.kelton.co.nz/Kelton%20Carvers%20Jig.html

Re: Carving stands

#13

Harry Robinette

Re: Carving stands

Harry Robinette

I have the Bosch manual stand and I love it, hold things very strong no movement at all. I find it easy to use with the one handle to do it all. The price isn't to bad ether.

Re: Carving stands

#14

Re: Carving stands

Jeff Smith

I've been using the WoodCut carving stand. The two handles on the same axis takes a little getting used to, but being able to use vacuum chucks on it is a real treat. I put a ball valve on the input and it allows me to reposition the piece pretty easily without disturbing the handles.

Re: Carving stands

#15

Woodcut carving stand *LINK*

John Lucas

Now that's a sweet machine. that's the way I think one should work. It looks like a good metal working project for this spring. I would love the capability to use a vacuum chuck because that would add to the easy of moving a piece around for those really unusual pieces.


http://www.philirons.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=66&Itemid=76

Re: Carving stands

#16

Jim Barbour

Re: Carving stands

Jim Barbour

I have Trent Bosch's earlier version (non-pneumatic) and like it very well. It holds whatever I put on it and has never slipped while in use. I have it bolted to the corner of a workbench, but occasionally put it on the banjo. It is not too pricey and seems to work precisely as intended.

Admittedly I am carving smaller objects (up to 12" or so) so I don't know from experience how it works with heavier pieces, but I wouldn't hesitate to load it up.

Having one that would work with a vacuum chuck would be nice though. If I were buying now, and price were no object, I might go that way.

Re: Carving stands

#17

Harry Robinette

Re: Carving stands

Harry Robinette

I seen a vac type stand somewhere and the write up said that they tend to slip unless the mount is just perfect. That's exactly what I was wondering about if the piece is warped a bit from drying is the vacuum going to hold it tight enough.

As for fast movement I can't see it being faster then the one handle Bosch that I just got.

Re: Carving stands

#18

Re: Carving stands

John Lucas

A vacuum holds tight enough for me to turn with the lathe at fairly high speeds. However and carving does apply some pretty good force. Slipping would be OK. If you break the seal the piece goes flying across the room. I'd probably save the vacuum for power carving or rotary carving for the most part. Light hand carving would probably also be OK. Of course like any vacuum it's the square inches of surface area that gives it a good hold. If you were carving on a platter with a 10" vacuum chuck you won't pull it off. If you have a 4" vacuum chuck you could run into problems.

Re: Carving stands

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: Carving stands

Alan Zenreich

John,

I thought you might be entertained by my repurposing of an old Bogen/Manfrotto model 108 ball head as a work holder (and light carving stand).

I've got it set up to accept the index plates from the eccentric turning jig that we use for pendant making.

The ball head is fastened through one of the square dog holes in this 100 year old Christensen work bench (you can see her brass brush in a nearby dog hole).

The ball head can be removed easily, and can mount onto pretty much any table if I add a one of my Manfrotto SuperClamps.

The boom arm of a microphone stand serves as a very comfortable wrist rest.

Lauren is quite pleased with this setup, because she can rotate the work easily, and the ball head is snug enough in its socket so it doesn't fall when it's unlocked. This makes it extremely easy to reposition the work and then lock it down.

We have about a dozen index plates, so she can keep the work on the plates, and return them to the lathe for further turning.

In the photo below, Lauren is working on some practice pieces, combining pyrography and Zentangling. Fun stuff.