Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

Posts

First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#1

First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

charlie belden

Turning multi-axes pieces can be a lot of fun. But the results are usually a Hit Or Miss thing - sometimes really interesting - and often "not so interesting". While working with Peter Rand and Barbara Dill, two turners who have really gotten into multi-axes turning, on the variables of TWISTED two and three ARCs, two or three AXES pieces, I developed a method of DESIGNING multi-axes pieces using Google's FREE SketchUp 3-D modeling program. With it, I can work out where the centers of each axis should be, where my arcs should intersect, and visualize what the results will look like.

I'd had this idea for a four axes piece for a while and had worked out the centers locations. I had an old broom handle, a piece of which would be prefect for turning the design. The piece is called Kaitlin after my 7 year old grand daughter - little wisp of a girl, with a pixie cut. She's an interesing combination of Fashionista and Tom Boy - just cute as hell.


The piece, actually more like a sketch, is about 6 1/2" tall and about 3/4" in diameter.

Comments and questions welcomed.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

Brad Vietje

Very cool, Charlie.... Have you turned it yet?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#3

Don Leydens

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

Don Leydens

Very nicely done, Charlie. The transition points are quite clean. Very cool.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#4

You're too much Charlie,

Mike Foster

Figuring out a way to pre-turn a multi-axis (or multi-axes, wonder which is really correct) piece on the computer, then taking it to the lathe. I thought I was a little out there, but you win. Cool stuff.

Mike

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#5

Re: You're too much Charlie,

charlie belden

Mike:

For a guy who takes mathematical equations for minimal surface area shapes - and then creates actual 3-D versions of them . . . that are absoulutely beautiful - and mind bending . . . !

If I can't visualize what I want to make, I can't work out how to make it. I can make SketchUp models of between centers multi-axes ideas and work out where the centers for the axes need to be. I've tried to create virtual 3-D models of of a few of your pieces - and gave up. How you can visualize your ideas, then make them - amazes me.

A former Significant Other is a math whiz. She could look at an equation and visualize it in 3-D - and then do 2-D drawings of various views. You seem to have that gift as well.

What I'm hoping to be able to do is put together a primer on between centers multi-axes turning fundamental concepts - with accompanying virtual 3-D models - that can be used to "tinker toy" together basic components to make virtual 3-D multi-axes pieces. And when 3-D printers get more affordable, and work in multiple colors, actual 3-D, color coded by axis models can be "printed" and held in hand for study. That's coming, and probably in the near future.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#6

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

charlie belden

Brad:

With this "sketch" of the idea, I've got the means to change the orientation of the components -legs, torso, neck and head - relative to each other so I can "lean the hips and torso" one way relative to the legs, the "neck" in another directions and turn and tilt the "head" - without having to do a virtual 3-D model first.

When, and whether, I do more with that info is up in the air. I've got a lot of "irons in the fire" I'd like to pursue and I jump around a lot. But I hope to put together some HOW info and illustrations on this piece so others interested in trying one don't have to start from scratch.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Multi-axis

Lyle Jamieson

Axis is singular, Axes is plural. When we say multi-axis it means more then one axis. They are also pronounced differently. Using axes would be a double-double. We dont say mulit-nationals or multi-linguals or mulit-millions or multi-skilleds.

Axis | Define Axis at Dictionary.com

dictionary.reference.com/browse/axis

An imaginary line around which an object rotates

Plural axes (āk'sēz').

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#8

Steven Antonucci

Grammar Nazi

Steven Antonucci

I was trying to visualize Charlie turning with a single bit Axe in one hand and double bit axe in the other, and you had to ruin it for me :b

S

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Grammar Nazi

Lyle Jamieson

Yes, I visualized turning with both hands and two hatchets, one concave bevel and one convex bevel. :D

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#10

Lyle is correct, that if you have ............

JamieDonaldson

...more than 1 ax or axe, then you have axes! :D ;)

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle is correct, that if you have ............

Lyle Jamieson

When refering to axis plural, I thought it interesting that axes is not pronounced axes it is pronounced axeeees. But how do you pronounce the word for more then one ax??

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#12

Steven Antonucci

Referring has 2 R's and three ... for ellipsis

Steven Antonucci

Axes...:)

S

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#13

I have a Plethora of ax's ( or is it a gaggle) 


Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#14

Re: Lyle is correct, that if you have ............

Doc Green

More than one ax, pronounced "axis." Unless you're from East Tennessee in which case it is "aaackk sizzzz." ~Doc

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#15

Re: Multi-axis

charlie belden

When you refer to one corporation that has offices or other facilities in more than one country/nation it could be referred to a multinational corporation - or a multinational (the "corporation" being implied).

When you're referring to several corporations, each that has offices or other facilities in more than one country they could be referred to as multinational corporationS or multinationalS (that S implying corporationS).

You wouldn't say "one wolf" - a "pack of wolf", pack implying more than one wolf. It's a pack of wolves.

But this grammar thing is just a sidetrack.

If multi-axes turning is to grow, it needs a vocabulary - a set of terms with agreed upon definitions - that will enable written and spoken communication needed to share information on the subject. This became very obvious when Barbara Dill, Peter Rand and I tried to figure out how Peter seemed to be able to turn a 3 arcs twisted piece with an apparent 180 degree twist. Initially we were exchanging text only e-mail messages. But lacking a common vocabulary, conveying concepts was difficult. Once we had some diagrams with some labeled terms for things we worked out how Peter had gotten ALMOST a 180 degree twist. In the process we developed a common set of terms that may be useful to describe other multi-axes methods.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#16

Alan Zenreich

Re: Multi-axis

Alan Zenreich

It's fine to make up terms for one's own artform... for example "Zentangling"

However, I cringe every time I see multi-axes written.

It should be multi-axis.

I cringe every time I see someone write about a lathe's Morris taper.

It should be Morse taper.

I appreciate folks helping to define the vocabulary for their art, but it's fine to use the existing lexicon... and use it properly. So, don't be surprised if interested parties point you to previous uses of the correct word.

For example:

http://www.barbaradill.com/images/xx_MultiAxis_LR1018-1.pdf

http://collectorsofwoodart.org/artist/bio/42

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiaxis_machining

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#17

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Multi-axis

Lyle Jamieson

I think your national or corperation example confirms my position. There are not many positions to one axis. There is one axis first and then a second axis, then, in my torsos, a third axis or a fourth. Each axis is a single location. There is not A multi position axis. You can only do one axis at a time. I guess this one of those times we have to agree to disagree.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#18

Re: Multi-axis

charlie belden

Alan:

Multi and Multiple are interchangable, denoting more than one.

More than one means plural.

The plural of axis is axes.

To me multi (more than one) and axis (singular) are incongruous.

From the Wiki link you provided:

"multiaxis machines also support rotation around one or multiple axes."

Bottom line - it doesn't matter if the terms for this area of turning are grammatically correct. What will matter is that there ARE terms for concepts - and that the terms for concepts - and their definitions - are agreed upon within the group using them, and anyone else who wants to get into this area, without having to start from scratch. The more specific the terms, the less ambiguity, the faster ideas can spread and be used, the faster this area of turning will expand.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#19

Alan Zenreich

Re: Multi-axis

Alan Zenreich

Charlie, you are welcome to make up any variation on English that you like.

However, it does not negate the proper use of the word. When you attach multi to a word, you attach it to the singluar.

A multi-person vehicle, not multi-people vehicle

A mutli-dog leash, not multi-dogs leash

My only concern about misusing the language is that it diminished the credibility of the writer.

Of course, you might be absolutely correct, and the rest of us might be wrong. If you have the inclinaton, check with a high school English teacher and report back < vbg >

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: Multi-axis

Alan Zenreich

You correctly noticed that the use of the adjective "multiple" and the prefix 'multi' are different.

Multiple vehicles are parked in the garage.

The garage is step up for multi-vehicle parking.

So "Multiple axes" is correct, as is "multi-axis".

Here's a little page about the prefix, note that all the examples have singlular suffixes.

http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/multi-#Prefix

I think I'm done with this. Thanks for your consideration.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#21

Re: Multi-axis

Coyne

The only multi-axis piece I ever turned was turned on multiple axes.

It is difficult to know how serious a writer is, because you cannot hear the inflections or see the facial expressions or gestures. i hope some of these comments have been at least a little tongue-in-cheek.

I learn much by reading this forum regularly and have learned to admire and respect many of the contributors whom I will never have the privilege to meet. Keep up the good work and please keep all difference of opinion or corrections of errors congenial and pleasant. :)

Coyne (a fellow- nit-picker)

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#22

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Multi-axis

Lyle Jamieson

I'm Smilin!! except when I try, but fail, to drag one of those smiley faces over into the text. Frown!!

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#23

Multiple Axes Turning?

charlie belden

I believe Multiple Axes Turning should be acceptable to english teachers and grammarians.

Re: First DESIGNED Multi-Axes Piece

#24

Re: Multi-axis

Steve Mushinski

Just type them in Lyle:

:) is colon and a forward bracket

:( is a colon and a backwards bracket

:b is a colon and the letter b