An odd notion from the Gransfors Bruk Axe Book?
Steven Antonucci
"A convex bevel has more strength than a straight one"
Agree?
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
An odd notion from the Gransfors Bruk Axe Book?
Steven Antonucci
"A convex bevel has more strength than a straight one"
Agree?
Steve
Sure, I'll agree
David Walser
A convex bevel leaves more steel in the ax head. It's a tautology that more steel would be "stronger" than less steel. Performs better is another question.
For what it's worth, I was taught as a boy scout that a convex bevel was preferable to a straight or hollow ground bevel because the ax was less likely to get stuck when trying to split a log. I don't know if that's true. I've just always sharpened axes that way.
An Interesting Question
Dennis in Southern Oregon
Geometrical considerations would seem to suggest that the opposite is true, that a hollow grind would be less prone to stick. For a given width of split, the wood would pinch down onto a steeper slope in the case of a hollow grind and should tend to have less frictional force to prevent release. Maybe there are other factors at work. 
Dennis
Re: An odd notion from the Gransfors Bruk Axe Book
Jim Barbour
I think I agree about the strength. About sticking in the cut, it seems to me that a straight bevel comes in contact with the wood for the full width of the bevel, a concave bevel will touch at the tip and at the opposite side of the bevel, and a concave bevel will only touch in one spot. Is there enough difference to make a difference? I have no idea. I do, however, sharpen axes in either hollow ground for light work or convex for heavy work. I was taught by my dad to do it that way for the two sides of a double-bit ax, and have seen no reason to change. Of course the same principle applies to two separate axes used for different purposes.
it is a good question, worthy of a starter for the year
Re: An Interesting Question
Bob Bosworth
Professional wood-choppers grind an ax to have 2 "busts". The first "bust" is a flat-ground zone for 1/2, 3/4 or 1 inch back from the cutting edge, followed by a hollow ground zone for another 2, 3 or 4 inches, followed by the second "bust which is a zone that is higher than a line from the flat grind to the heel of the ax. The first bust lifts the wood so that the ax can penetrate the wood past the hollow and then the second bust blows the chip away from the cut. The depth of the zones is dependent on the hardness of the wood being cut and the strength of the ax-man using the tool. We use the same grinds for both chopping and splitting wood, and seldom if ever use a splitting maul whilst making 10-15 cords of firewood a year out of red-oak.
Part B ... how does it translate to woodturning?
Steven Antonucci
Same basic idea... does it apply to a gouge? a skew?
Hannes grind is pretty close on a gouge. Does the edge feel tougher? Is there a benefit in throwing the chip?
If the folks at Gransfors say it about an axe, I would probably believe it. Why would a turning tool edge be different?
Steve
I think a hatchet would be easier...
Leo Cuellar
to control than an axe, less likely to get tangled up with the handle. Would likely not whack you as hard if you got a catch!
Clowning aside, some people like a convex bevel on their skew. I've tried that, but found that my tool movements needed to be more exaggerated to bring the cutting edge into play. Would a convex grind work better for some types of cuts? Perhaps, on the inside of a bowl, but again for me, the drawback of having to move the tool that much further up or to the side and how much stress that puts on my joints isn't worth the effort. Your mileage may vary.
Re: I think a hatchet would be easier...
John Lucas
I would assume a convex edge has more meat behind it so for something that takes as much force as an ax might need it. for turning the problem we have is the actual edge itself. It gets dull and then we sharpen. I don't think the strength is an issue.
I'm still playing with convex grinds but so far don't see an advantage. At least for skews. The Jury is still out on the Johannes grind because I just don't have enough time with it. Can't tell whether it's my inability to get a repeatable grind by hand or something about the edge that I'm uncomfortable with.
I did quite a bit of experimenting with hand chisels, flat grind vs concave with hone flat edges. I could not tell a difference except it took far longer to sharpen a very dull edge with the flat grind because you had to remove so much metal. If you religiously maintain the edge then they are about the same although I still think the concave edge is faster. I did not have chipping on either edge when pounding through wood so strength wasn't a factor. I did not try a convex edge. As far as I know no one uses that on flat woodworking chisels. Possibly some do on carving tools because it helps with the scooping action of some cuts.
Re: Part B ... how does it translate to woodturnin
Dennis in Southern Oregon
Steve, it seems to me that this is a departure from the original issue. Splitting wood and slicing wood are two completely different things. The original issue was
the problem of the axe sticking when the wood does not split all the way. When slicing (as in woodturning) the objective is to have the fibers split apart as little as possible but to cut cleanly.
Dennis
Two questions in first post
Steven Antonucci
The first question was "Is a convex bevel somehow stronger than a hollow ground one?" The second question was "Did a convex bevel promote the release of a chip better because it doesn't get stuck in the wood?"
I didn't mean to support either side of the argument, simply because I don't know the answer, but it does seem to have a following in the "axe community" as a best practice. As I previously stated, if the folks at Gransfors think it is true for axes, I am likely going to believe them- but it got me wondering if these concepts could translate.
Steve
Does a side ax count as a convex bevel
John Lucas
I have 2 side hatchets (I know I typed side ax). I have sharpened them very keenly and they just peel away wood. I guess it's sort of a split somewhat like a sharp Fro but I can really smooth out a piece of wood taking off nice shavings. I have not tried the same thing with my hatchet that just has a wedge shaped sharpening so I can't compare the two.
Ax terminology?
Steven Antonucci
If by a Side Ax you mean an axe with a flat face and a single bevel (sharpened like a draw knife), I don't know?
As a point of reference, most of my interest in adzes and axes comes from this video:
Enjoy
Steve
Wow, just watching this video..........
JamieDonaldson
...inflamed my tendonitis, so I'll just keep making bowls on my lathe thank you!

that's exactly it Steve.
but his bowls aren't round?
Steven Antonucci
I suppose you could put the chopping block on your lathe and use the axe anyway... then you could say that they were "made on a lathe" and probably get an AAW grant 
Re: Sure, I'll agree
Jorge
David,
I live in the woods and split all my firewood with an axe, pictures tomorrow.
A hollow edge works well if you are an accurate ax person and hit in perfect alignment to the pith. But if you are not, most probably you will have a stuck axe.
The convex edge in the other hand it splits the wood sooner if you are accurate and if you are not it just bounces.
So they thought you well...