Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

60 degree Cone for Live Center

Posts

60 degree Cone for Live Center

#1

60 degree Cone for Live Center

jake Niedling

I see alot of youtube videos using a cone point on their live center rather than the cup & point. I would think the cone center would have act like a wedge tending to split your wood. So other than using it to support the end of a turning that has a hole in it with a cone shape, why do people use it for normal turning. I use the cup and point just about all the time. I am probably missing something, but not sure what it is?

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#2

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

darrin hill

i use a cone cause my nova came with it... didnt have any other option till recently..

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#3

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

Doc Green

Jake, you are correct in concluding that the point of a cone center tends to split the wood, but in most cases, this is not a problem. It becomes an issue only with pieces an inch or less in diameter where the wood is a type that tends to split easily.

The force that must be applied to the cone center (or cup center, for that matter) can be reduced considerably if, early on, you cut a tenon on the headstock end of the piece and insert this tenon into a scroll chuck instead of using a spur drive or a Stebcenter at the headstock end. Then, only sufficient force is required of the cone center to stabilize the piece.

In most cases, it doesn't make a lot of difference which you use. However, a tail center like the Oneway or a very similar one that is shipped with a Powermatic lathe offers several advantages over the cup center that is shipped with a Jet mini, where the cup is about 3/4" in diameter.

In a jam-chucking situation, such as reverse turning a bowl to remove the tenon, you can work much closer to the center and turn the nubbin down to 1/4" or less, which makes for less work to be done off the lathe in removing the nubbin. The same applies when using the tail center for support when the piece is held by a chuck or a faceplate.

The cone center of the Oneway and PM live centers can be removed to expose a small, 5/8" cup center AND a 3/4 x 10 thread. This feature greatly increases the versatility of the device. A bull nose cone 3" in diameter is available that screws onto the thread, and this can be used to re-center and support a vessel that is being re-installed in the chuck, as well as other applications.

Another fixture that screws onto the thread is a spindle reversing adapter which allows a chuck or faceplate to be installed on the live center. I find this feature to be less useful because other more-direct methods of achieving the same result can be used.

Several shop-made fixtures can be made fairly quickly that either fit over the thread or screw onto it. One example is a cup center for holding a sphere, if you're into making "balls." Another is the tailstock side of a compression chuck for turning thin disks (of acrylic, perhaps) to a specified diameter. And etc.

After having used the PM version of the Oneway live center for many years, I find the more traditional live centers to be very limiting as far as these "other uses" are concerned.

Hope this helps. ~Doc

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#4

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

John Lucas

That's why I love the Nova live center. I almost never use the cone center. Only when making pens.

However I do use the stepped cone center that has a point with a 1/4" and 3/8" step. I use these when I need to drill a hole first for centering. I can drill a 1/4" hole and then put the point with the 1/4" step in that hole and it's perfectly centered on the hole.

Like Jake I use the cup center most often. Sometimes I'll use it without the center point when reverse turning bowls because it doesn't leave that little dimple in the center. The little ring it leaves is easier to remove.

I do agree with Doc. You have to apply a fair amount of force to split anything larger than an inch or so. I will use the cone center when I have the bark side toward the tailstock. It will bury itself pretty far in the bark and hold really well.

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#5

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

Joe Herrmann

I hardly ever use the cone center, preferring instead the cup and point. However, you can reduce the likelihood of splitting by putting a small washer over the end of the cone. It reduces the amount of penetration and distributes the force over a larger area.

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

Lyle Jamieson

I use the cone only for the final reverse turning process. It is not a safe tool for hogging off or aggressive cuts, and a catch can pop it out of its location and sling the piece off the lathe at you. Never use a live or drive center of any kind on bark. I always carve the bark away to make sure I am holding in solid strong wood. The cup and pin has much more strength.

One of the people in my club had a cone slip when hogging off and got a nasty catch and the piece came off and hit him on the side of the head. Got a black eye out of the deal. Could have been nasty if he was not wearing his faceshield.

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#7

Thanks for  replies - some great Safety tips

jake Niedling

I have a oneway live center now for about 10 years, so I understand many of the likes about this type of well made live center. My hope was that a number of very good comments would follow for everyone's benefit. And as always, you have come through. A number of very good safety concerns were listed as well. Thanks for contributing.

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Thanks for  replies - some great Safety tips

Dick Hines

I use the cup center that came with my lathe. Don't ask me where the point is. I took it out because I never used it. I found that if I wanted to adjust the piece just a scosh the point would go right back in the hole.

I like the cup because it lets me move the piece and it will stay where I put it.

I start all my bowls between center because I am looking of the side grain to flow right down the center of the bowl. It does not make the bowl work any better but it sure looks better..to my eye.

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

#9

Re: 60 degree Cone for Live Center

Paul Vechart

I have the Nova live center and like it a lot except for the length of the point in the cup. It protrudes .300" before the cup is in contact with the wood. It takes excess force to penetrate the wood if it's anything hard. Do any of you drill a pilot hole first for the point to go in? I wish the length of the point was adjustable.