I wood like to get a new live center. My main concerns are versatility and being able to attach a scroll chuck and other threaded accessories such as jam chucks. Accuracy, no runout, is a definite plus as well. I would appreciate any input you have.
Re: Upgrading live center... recommendations? *LINK*
David Walser
I don't think you can do better than the Oneway live center. It's not inexpensive. It is extremely versatile and allows you to make your own tips. Oneway and other make a number of accessories for it, including a chuck adapter. If you do buy the live center, splurge and get the "pen point". The pen point's 60 degree angle is better for supporting a pen mandrel than the standard point that comes with the live center.
Re: Upgrading live center... recommendations? *LINK*
John Lucas
I'm a huge fan of the Technatool live center. The inserts are very short #2 morse tapers so it's very easy to make all sorts of accessories. The nice thing is once you turn the #2 morse taper (which is very easy) you can place it the headstock to turn whatever shape you need for the live center. when your done just cut the morse taper short enough to work in the live center.
The screw thread adaptor is tapped on the inside so you can just buy a screw and adapt all sorts of pieces to that center.
It's just a very versatile center. I have had it for about 10 or 12 years and still have not had to replace the bearings. I have a Powermatic copy of the Oneway live center and it's nice but it's just so much easier to make adaptors for my Nova center. If you buy a 3/4x10 tap you can make accesories for the Oneway/Powermatic live center. I put the live center in the headstock and then use a cotter pin through the hole that stops the live center from rotating. Then you can shape the wood to whatever accessory you need.
It's cost alone makes it attractive and it seems to last forever.
I also have the Precision multi-tip center from Craft Supplies. There are a large number of accessory tips for this center and I find it useful for a variety of jobs. They offer 9 different tips which can be bought separately including a faceplate tip. A very good tool!
Re: Upgrading live center... recommendations? *LINK*
Don Evans
You mentioned specific "chuck attachment", the other centers will not readily do that but I could be wrong. The Oneway is the only one that has all that worked out with threads on it and they also make adapters to adapt the live center to any popular chuck thread. The link I give you should take you to Oneways site and to the page with the center, so scroll down that page for adapters.
The pen point that Dave mentioned is on that page also but he didn't tell you the most important thing about it IMO, that is that it is made of steel, not aluminum so it will not wear out when mating it to other metal objects like the regular point that also comes with the center.
I've used this center for 12 or more years. Now a friend is using the first one I had as I upgraded to 2436 and had to get new center, Oneway of course as I then needed a morse taper 3.
When I was a kid like Lucas is now I would spent time making lots of things but now I don't feel like I have enough time left to get all the things done I want to do so I don't waste my time making something I can buy in the tool category. After all, we get this stuff to make art or whatever not tools but if you have the time more power to ya I loved doing it back then!
the Oneway and threaded adaptor as the Nova seemed to be unavailable for a few months. It looks like making specialty attachments for this will be relatively easy.
My old live center (Griz) wasn't bad, just not big enough. It has a small oddball taper where the interchangeable tips go. Wasn't comfortable with how flimsy it looked for larger projects.
Thanks John, I was looking at these also. If the bearings in the Griz ever go bad, I was giving these serious consideration as a replacement. Bruce & Jan are great folks to do business with.
Dick they are identical. I haven't tried swaping parts to really see but the thread sizes, length, etc are identical. Jet/Powermatic ships these with all the new lathes.
Now go get a 3/4-10 bolt, grind a couple of grooves lengthwise down the threads, (a 4" handheld grinder works great) taper the end and you have a tap for for the threads on the end of your new center.
Don't forget that you can also just purchase a 3/4" x 10 tpi nut, drill the appropriate sized hole with a Forstner bit, and glue it with epoxy into whatever attachment you intend to make. I probably have at least 10 different tailstock adapters that screw onto my Oneway live center, made out of both wood and UHMW plastic (drilled and tapped in this case; it turns very easily, but watch out for those long plastic "threads" generated while turning!).