Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

Posts

Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#1

Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

Dick Coers

So I'm sitting here, wasting a half hour, watching over the wife who was diagnosed with case of pneumonia this morning. I'm watching Scott Phillips hacking his way through a little wine table. He's offset turning pads on the feet of the legs, and trying to transition up the leg. He stops turning, and shows us how to really do it easily. He pulls out a 4" angle grinder with a 40 grit pad on it!!!!!!! 40 grit? Must have had it left over from derusting angle iron before welding. How long do you think it will take to get those scratches out of the white oak? Oh man, this kind of instruction ain't helping' anyone!!!!!!! Now he's building the rest of the table with no glue and lots of Kreg screws in the apron to leg connection. In my opinion, he might as well show us how to shop at IKEA for a wine table. It will last about as long. I've met Scott several times, nice enough guy, but this kind of instruction is just a tick off of the DIY Channel. Horrible!

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#2

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

John Lucas

I use 24 grit paper on an angle grinder for rough carving. It works great. Just about as fast as the Arbortec or Lancelot but a lot safer. You do have some heavy scratches to get out but a wood rasp or course sandpaper glued to a stick does that.

I used to fuss about Norm Abrams having every tool in the book to do work and Scott Phillips is about the same. The good thing is, they got people hooked on woodworking.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#3

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

Terry Quiram

Sorry to hear about Shirley. Hope she has a speedy recovery. Missed you today.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#4

So bad technique is okay?....

Dick Coers

as long as people get hooked on woodturning? A right angle grinder with 40 grit used to transition a long taper to round is not teaching woodturning, and I fail to see how that will get people hooked. Having crazy, poor technique videos on youtube are bad enough. But people have to search those out. Crappy technique (40 grit super gouge on a right angle grinder) on TV, with many reruns, can only damage a craft.

I will agree that Norm single handedly built an air nailer industry. Before him, a pinner was over $150 at Duofast. Now they are $20 at Harbor Freight. So he did some good.

The cheap right angle grinder industry is already in place, again less than $20 at Harbor Freight, so I don't know where Scott has to go with this. Maybe Scott Philips signature right angle grinders?

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#5

Harry Robinette

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

Harry Robinette

I'm with you, his show is a complete waste and dangerous to the people trying to learn woodworking.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#6

Re: So bad technique is okay?....

John Lucas

I don't see what's wrong with showing alternate ways to shape wood. Since I didn't see the actual leg he was turning I can't say how I would do it. I normally use a wood rasp to smooth out the area between 2 offcenter areas but if I thought It needed it I would grab the angle grinder without a moments hesitation.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#7

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

Barry

Where's Norm Abram and his pneumatic nailers when we need him?

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#8

Steven Antonucci

Are there any good woodworking shows?

Steven Antonucci

I mean since David Marks show went off the air? He always had safe, and useful techniques that he displayed. On HGTV, there is a spot running for one of their finishing experts showing how to make a door look instantly antique... by blackening it with a torch. In the end, he smothers it in stain and proudly proclaims that the "man cave looks like it's been there for years"... even though the doors look like crap.

All I can say is that we're not the target audience...

Steve

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#9

Mike Stafford

The John Lucas channel on YouTube!!!


Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#10

Re: Are there any good woodworking shows?

Peter Hyde

The Roy Underhill shows are still on PBS and there certainly will be no angle grinders to be seen :)

On the other hand most who watch these shows don't want to learn how to do woodworking, they want to know the easiest way from A to B and be able to show off the collection of low cost junk tools they accumulated along the way.

Trouble is they then persuade others they know enough to actually charge for their services.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#11

Re: The John Lucas channel on YouTube!!!

Galen Vetterick

I go along with John's YouTube as a good learning channel to watch. I also enjoy what I'll call his commic counterpart from Cap'n Eddie Castelin's YouTube videos. I learn a lot from the people that post construction photo series right here on WoodCentral. So I will never make a concrete countertop or gun case lamp but they are still interesting and I can learn things that aply to other projects.

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#12

Clint Searl

What a bunch of snobs

Clint Searl

Woodworking ain't a spiritual competition.

Clint

Re: Scott Phillips woodturner? Rant warning!

#13

Spiritual competition?