Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Lathe switch

Posts

Lathe switch

#1

Lyle Jamieson

Lathe switch

Lyle Jamieson

There was a long thread a couple days ago so Ill start a new one. This is very important to understand the dangers lathe manufacturers put us in. Please...everyone move the on-off switch. See my YouTube clip on lathe set up. HYPERLINK "http://youtu.be/AWYEPfqRet8".

Re: Lathe switch

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Here's the link

Lyle Jamieson

Thanks John, Im computer challenged, I spent some time, more time then I should admit, but failed to find a way to get the link posted so I just cut and pasted it.

Re: Lathe switch

#4

Re: Here's the link / Kill Switch

Jim Breeden

Thanks to Lyle and John for the video info. I normally stand to left when I turn on my lathe but, as with Lyle's demo, I am now going to extend / install a switch on the right side of my DVR XP. Much cheaper than the Nova hand held device.

Re: Lathe switch

#5

Re: Lathe switch

John Veerkamp

I have my PM plugged into a doubly pole switched outlet at the right end of the lathe. Convenient and in easy reach. Maybe not quite as good as a paddle switch on the right, but a good safety feature that is less expensive than the purpose built switches.

Re: Lathe switch

#6

Re: Lathe switch

John Lucas

I purchased a new switch and some wire to replace the very poor one that Powermatic sells as a remote. My intention was to wire up the speed as well as on/off switch. That was 3 months ago and it's still sitting in the box. I guess I'll have to get around to it one of these days.

I think I've decided to move the whole switch assembly rather than go the more complicated dual switch arrangement. I'll just add an extension to the cords that exist and remove the faceplate with switch and speed control and mount it in a magnetic box.

The one downside to a remote is that you have to put it in the same spot all the time. If you don't you find yourself searching for the on/off button. Not a good thing in a panic. The first time I turned on a Oneway it drove me nuts looking for the remote that is on a moveable arm. What I did with my Powermatic remove was to always put it under the tailstock. If I had removed the tailstock then it goes on the end of the bed. that way I didn't have to think about where it was.

Re: Lathe switch

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: Lathe switch

Mike Stafford

Lyle, good advice. When I was looking for a lathe that is one of the features I considered; where was the switch? On the Nova 3000 I had at the time the switch always required you to move into the line of fire to turn the lathe off. Being inherently chicken I did not like reaching around a bowl or platter to turn off the machine.

I decided to buy my Stubby because it fit the space I had and also had the capability to do the type of turning I wanted to do. But the switch was mounted on a box attached to a cable and could be placed anywhere along the length of the lathe because of a magnet on the back of the switch box.

I highly recommend having your switch on a long cable so that it can be moved to where it is needed.

Re: Lathe switch

#8

Steven Antonucci

My lathe plugs into a repositionable switch box

steven antonucci

I bought it at Woodcraft for $30? If I am on the headstock end, I can use the one on the motor. If I am on the tailstock end, I can move it to the front side or rear side of the tailstock. Depending upon what I am doing, I sometimes use the front mounting to bump it with my leg (like hollowing, so I can keep 2 hands on the tool while the lathe spins down)

You can see it on the lower right. I used it to hollow the vessel 22" deep...which means a lot of off and on. I agree that all full sized lathes should have the switch mounted on a long leash, and it probably adds less than $15 in cost.


Re: Lathe switch

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lathe switch

Lyle Jamieson

Mike and John, I think it is a safety issue to have the switch at the end of the bed screwed and glued in a permanent place. As you suggest, in a panic situation a split second of fiddling looking for the switch can be huge. You turn your lathe on and off a million times in your lifetime. The first waring alarm you get for trouble is the sound. As soon as you hear something wrong....boom....the switch is off, you dont have to look for the switch or fumble around turning it off.

Once the switch is permanently installed you can reach it from any place you stand. Sometimes I stand behind the lathe to hollow big pieces and you can reach easily over the bed to use the switch.

Yes, I hate the Oneway switches too. The arm is always in the way and I dont think it is safe to be a moving target. I always take the revolving arm apart and move it behind the lathe head stock and use the variable speed there, but put the remote down on the end of the bed for on-off.

Re: Lathe switch

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Lathe switch

Dick Hines

I built a remote switch for my PM years ago and wish I had done it sooner. I have mine mounted on a old speaker magnet. When I am hollowing I have in on the bed right under the hollowing rig. That way it close to my hands. When I am turning bowls it mounted on the tail stock end leg. If something goes wrong I can hit it on the out the door.

Re: Lathe switch

#11

Re: Lathe switch

Bill Howatt

Did something similar for my General 26020 but mounted box containing on/off buttons and speed control on a wood base with piece that fits between opening in bed to keep it in place. I always keep it close to where my right hand is which means I do swap it in front or in back of tailstock depending on what I'm doing. I deliberately included the speed control beside the on/off so I reduce the risk of switching the lathe on with the speed turned up too high.

The General had the on/off buttons in the worst possible place - low on the pedestal so when you reached down to operate them you actually lowered your head closer to the line-of-fire. A word of caution for anybody considering relocating the switches on a General; the buttons have 240V on them, not a low control voltage.

IMO, the big safety improvement is being able to turn the lathe off from a location away from the line-of-fire. Whether the button is always in the same place is a minor consideration compared to that.

Bill

Re: Lathe switch

#12

Re: Lathe switch

Hal Taylor

While we are on the subject of switches, I have the extra on-off switch on my PM, but I cannot find a switch which will last worth a toot in the dusty atmosphere. The last one I got was from Grizzly. Any suggestions for a good one?

Re: Lathe switch

#13

Re: Lathe switch

John Lucas

Get one from industrial electronic suppliers. I bought mine from my local motor repair business. The switches are much heavier with better seals. The Grizzly, Woodcraft, and Powermatic remote switches are just cheap alternatives and don't last long.

Re: Lathe switch

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Lathe switch

Dick Hines

Go to the drawer you keep you sandwitch bags. Pick a really good one. Go to the shop and wrap the PM switch in the bag and wrap some tape around it.

I did about 6 months ago and have had not trouble with my switch since.

Blowing out the dust once in a while will help too.

Re: Lathe switch

#15

Re: Lathe switch

Philip Duffy

Dick, you could make up a few of those switch boxes and I would be happy to pay you handsomely for the first one! Phil

Re: Lathe switch

#16

Re: Lathe switch

Guy Bratt

Here's a suggestion for E Stop situations. Have you seen the teather switches they have on personal water craft? Maybe even on snow machines? The teather clips or loops to your body. In an emergency you step away. The magnet pulls off the switch and the machine stops and you are safe away.

This doesn't cure the control issue of starting and crossing the line of fire. Sounds like every body has some cure for that. Adding the teather to the remote box would be simple and there is no need to locate it in an emergency.

Re: Lathe switch

#17

Dick Hines

Re: Lathe switch

Dick Hines

Phil I wouldn't sell you one but I can help you make one. The supplies you will need is a switch, a short piece of #10 cord, a plastic box and lid. It helps to have a magnet to attach to the back of the box. The switch is the most pricey piece.

I have a copy of the PM manual.

Contact me after the new year and we can get her done.

Re: Lathe switch

#18

Nobody has mentioned foot switches,

Keith Newton

What is the general feeling about those?

Re: Lathe switch

#19

Re: Nobody has mentioned foot switches,

Bill Howatt

I know there a people who use them on a variety of power tools but I consider them a hazard for things like any type of saw. I do have one on my drill press because I consider it a lower risk tool if I accidently press on the switch and having an extra hand is a real plus sometimes.

I'm assuming you don't want to be standing on the switch to keep the lathe running so it is click on, click off or ...? After a bit of roughing I don't think I'd be able to find it on the floor!

Bill

Re: Lathe switch

#20

Re: Nobody has mentioned foot switches,

Stuart Johnson

I bought one to use with my router table and quickly decided it was dangerous when I stepped on it accidentally. That could have been a very costly trip to the emergency room. I now use with my miter saw and vac. I still have to start the saw normally but if I'm not stepping on the switch neither the vac nor saw has power.

Re: Lathe switch

#21

Re: Nobody has mentioned foot switches,

charlie_belden

I've used a foot switch - but the set up required that the switch on the lathe was ON before the footswitch would work as a remote secondary on off switch. This way, when mounting a blank, setting the tool rest and checking for clearance by manually turing the piece - the lathe's switch is ALWAYS OFF. Only when the lathe's swtich is turned back ON does the foot switch control power to the lathe's motor.

For spindle work and smaller turnings, the foot switch worked great. Could get the tool in position in tight places and then turng the lathe on without getting the tool out of position. Also worked well when a cut into a tight space was done and I want the lathe off before I extracted the tool.

But for bowl work and hollow forms, where you may have to move your feet - or try and keep one foot on the switch and still get the range of movement required - it was like Indian Wrestling - where one foot has to stay planted while the rest of you is moving all over the place trying not to fall over. Foot switch then was more hassle than benefit.

Since I don't turn green - or large stuff - piles of shavings weren't a problem. But the foot switch I had wasn't sealed, so chips and crap would get into it and would have to be cleared in order for the switch to work. Tried it in a ZipLok bag, but stuff still got into the switch