Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Line Of Fire?

Posts

Line Of Fire?

#1

Line Of Fire?

Stuart Johnson

Over on WoW there is a long thread about an Australian woodturner that was killed at his lathe. There aren't any details regarding the accident but a side thread talks about Lynne Yamaguchi's accident

http://www.lynneyamaguchi.com/wordpress/


and using a riot helmet. In that thread and many here the "line of fire" is constantly refereed to and staying out of it. I don't recall ever being told or shown in the many dvd's just where this line of fire is suppose to be. It's as if this is one of the things that is so common knowledge it's never shown.

The pieces I knock out of the chuck have all seemed to hit the ways and then bounce usually with some force. My usual steps are to turn down the speed, plug in the machine, turn it on then stand by the headstock with the Nova or tailstock with the Robust and adjust the speed. Once up to speed I move to wherever I need to make the cut but try to stay on one side or the other but don't see how a complete piece can be turned without it spinning toward you. Plus how do you protect against a shattered piece and the rebound off the ways?

Re: Line Of Fire?

#2

Re: Line Of Fire?

Robert Hayward

I am a relative newbie to turning and have knocked a few pieces out of the chuck so far. None have exploded, just came out of the jaws. The flying pieces have hit either the tool rest or the ways, not me. I am a very cautious turner and keep my RPM's rather slow.

None of the flying pieces went in what I would call the line of fire. Rather thericocheteded around. Most of them were ruined or at least damaged to the point I did not have the ambition to repair them.

A year or so ago I had a small piece of very hard wood with crotch feather literally explode in the thickness planer. Pieces of wood came out the infeed side of the planer like a fragmentation grenade had gone off. That incident sure has kept me out of the planer line of fire.

Bob

Re: Line Of Fire?

#3

A ban should be made on

Terry Scott

A ban should be made on lathes that have the switch on the head stock

Reaching across a piece of work that has suddenly gone out of balance or a piece has come off is daunting .

Reaching across a square piece of work were the outer shadow is the inner bowl not the outer proximity of the square also makes me grit my teeth when I see turners reaching over work.

All my lathes have a remote or lead with the controller on it so if anything happens I can step back and turn off .

A lathe should at least have a kill switch in reach of the turner at the tail stock.

Knee bars are also a good idea although sometimes a pain as you keep knocking them.

Trust me I have learnt all of the above by experience.

Cheers

Re: Line Of Fire?

#4

Re:  A ban should be made on

Karen F.

I have a Vic Marc 300 with the knee shut off and I love that part. I have had many other people use my lathe and they can't stand the knee shut off because they are not use to it and turn it off by mistake. I look at it like I can turn my lathe off without taking my hands off the work especially if it gets scary.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#5

Re:  A ban should be made on

Jeff Willaford

I added a stop switch with a long bar to my DVR for that reason. I'm much more comfortable hitting the stop bar with my hand or knee than trying to reach across a piece to push a postage stamp sized button.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#6

Re: Line Of Fire?

Dale Bonertz

I don't believe you can protect yourself from all incidences that occur at the lathe or any woodworking tool. You can only assess what you are about to do and use risk management. Problem with that is newer users and even some experienced users have not had bad things happen yet to know what to manage. Hearing these stories sadden me but I am glad they come up as a reminder for the rest of us to try and be safe.

I hope we don't come to the point of banning things because a start/stop switch on the head stock is needed in some emergency situations. I think and hope what Terry is actually wanting is all lathes to come with a stop bar or in my mind better yet a remote box that includes the start/stop, speed control and forward/reverse switches, in addition to the head stock switches, which can be located anywhere convenient to what your turning to shut down in the event of a problem.

I see so many stand pretty well in the line of fire when rough turning. This makes me cringe since this is probably the most vulnerable time things come flying off and can really hurt you. No helmet can help you if something smacks you in the chest or groin (I am a big proponent of face and head protection). Point is to teach yourself how to turn left handed when roughing since by the nature of holding the gouge automatically puts your body out of the line of fire. It is also a skill all turners should have since many cuts are easier left handed and you find yourself switching the gouge or any tool back and forth without even thinking about it. To tell you the truth it is so easy to learn this skill. I am a realist and know that things come apart after roughing and during finish turning as well. This is just one area (left handed turning) that can really help to keep you out of the line of fire in those more dangerous circumstances.

Have fun and safe turning,

Re: Line Of Fire?

#7

Steven Antonucci

99% of the time, pieces come out of the chuck...

steven antonucci

because your tenon was improperly formed.

In General, your tenon should be a few millimeters larger than your jaws are when fully closed so that you have wood to metal contact around the entire perimeter of the tenon. If you try to make a "big tenon", you only have 8 small contact points.

Secondarily, the tenon needs to be shallower than the jaws so that it does not bottom out in the chuck. Their needs to be air space below the tenon.

Lastly, the tenon has a very specific shape. Beginner turners often "generalize" the shape to be tenon-like, but this is the single most critical part of a tenon. If your jaws are straight or dovetailed, you need to make the tenon the same shape. When you look at how the tenon sits in the chuck, there should be NO VISIBLE space between the top of the jaws and the face of the tenon. Often, the corners of the tenon are a sloppy mess too, which will cause your chuck to seat funny and introduce runout to the work piece.

Once you master this, you should at least keep the work in the chuck. As for the line of fire, it is generally more of a concern in faceplate work than spindle work, as it is impossible to turn spindles without standing in the line of fire.

Steve

Re: Line Of Fire?

#8

Rob Wallace

Getting back to Stuart's first question...

Rob Wallace

.... about the "Line of Fire".

This is the so-called "danger zone" of the spinning blank when mounted on the headstock, typically for faceplate ("bowl") turning. That is not to say that there is no danger involved with spindle turning, but that given the nature of what and how the piece is being turned, the effects of problems resulting from bowl blank fragmentation are far more "spectacular" than if a spindle blank fails.

You can hopefully imagine the "Line of Fire" as the space created from the rotating piece mounted to the spindle of the lathe if you were to draw radius lines from the spindle outward in all directions for the entire width of the rotating piece. This would be a doughnut-shaped space behind, above, in front of, and below the spinning blank which is the space that you would most likely encounter flying pieces if the blank fragmented while it was being spun. (BY THE WAY - bowls and other hollowed vessels being turned on a lathe DON'T BLOW UP - they FRAGMENT. Unless you are using very rapidly expanding gasses as part of your turning technique, they will not blow up!! After nearly 20 years of turning I can say that I have never blown-up a bowl or hollow vessel on the lathe, but I have fragmented quite a few over those years!).

The "Line of Fire" results from the centrifugal forces of rotation acting on the blank. If the rotating wood blank fragments into smaller pieces, the rotational forces will cause them to spray outward in a somewhat straight line (like spokes on a wheel) from the moment they are "released" from being part of a solid blank. This is the only predictable path for wood fragments flying outward from the rotating blank. All other paths of wood fragments resulting from the flying pieces encountering lathe beds, tool rests, walls, face shields, or other body parts are far less predictable, and due to the 'ricochet-factor', subsequent directions of flying pieces really can't be determined with any confidence. Some lathe manufacturers provide screens or shields which are placed within the "Line of Fire" zone to minimize catastrophic effects of flying chunks of wood. Very few turners actually use these shields; they accept the risk and turn without them (e.g. the shield from my Jet 1642 is some where in my attic). I always wear a full face shield when turning and deliberately avoid being in the Line of Fire at any time the work is spinning. Experience is a good teacher, and can reduce BUT NOT ELIMINATE the risk. This is a personal decision.

By understanding that the Line of Fire exists, and by avoiding standing in it or having body parts within it while starting-up lathe rotation or while turning, you greatly minimize, BUT DO NOT ELIMINATE, chances of being hit by flying wood fragments if the piece "decides" to come apart. This is why many turners prefer to have lathe control positions what do not require entering or reaching into the Line of Fire to shut down the machine (which I fully agree with!).

The comments about proper tenon sizing and shaping are all correct, but you still should understand that regardless of how good the tenon is to fit your chuck, etc. the possibility always exists that pieces will fragment, or blanks can pop-out of chucks, tenons can shear-off, etc., and pieces are most likely to fly outward within the Line of Fire until they encounter some other object. If this is not a good enough reason to wear full-face protection, use good turning technique, and follow proper safety practices by keeping out of the Line of Fire, then you should not be woodturning!

If you need more information about the Line of Fire, etc. please feel free to contact me. This is a major part of any woodturning instruction I provide, and I am very happy to share it with all who will listen.

Turn SAFELY!

Rob Wallace

(recently appointed as Chair of the AAW Safety Committee)

Re: Line Of Fire?

#9

Alan Zenreich

Re: Getting back to Stuart's first question...

Alan Zenreich

"The comments about proper tenon sizing and shaping are all correct, but you still should understand that regardless of how good the tenon is to fit your chuck, etc. the possibility always exists that pieces will fragment, or blanks can pop-out of chucks, tenons can shear-off, etc., and pieces are most likely to fly outward within the Line of Fire until they encounter some other object. If this is not a good enough reason to wear full-face protection, use good turning technique, and follow proper safety practices by keeping out of the Line of Fire, then you should not be woodturning! "

Well said.

One can guess about the final trajectory of launched objects (and the ricochet path), but it's only a guess.

Wearing protective gear may not help much during certain castatrophic incidents, but it can minimize the injuries, and often turn an unexpected launch into a non-event (perhaps a good story), instead of a trip to the hospital... or worse, the need to send flowers.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Line Of Fire?

Keith Tompkins

A few random thoughts....I now use a hockey helmet with a heavy wire shield, with my safety glasses inside. No fog-up, and I feel there is far better protection than a face shield alone. Some throat protection too. Never, if possible, have your lathe in a confined space....a blank can fly off the lathe, hit the wall, and then bounce back at you. I know of two accidents where the wood bounced off the wall BEHIND the turner, resulting in serious injuries. Why are we using a chuck to rough turn? A faceplate takes seconds to secure, and is far safer. Get into the habit of turning the lathe speed to "0" each and every time you turn. Don't get distracted....recently, my son called me in the shop "Hey Dad, is everything OK?" He heard an unusual noise. I reached down to shut the lathe off, and stuck my left thumb right into the chuck. The jaws were positioned nearly closed thankfully; still I didn't want to look at my thumb...when I did...the thumbnail was gone. My first real lathe accident, and I consider myself lucky. I'm still wondering...How and why did I do that? Can you imagine if the toolrest was positioned in front of the chuck?

Re: Line Of Fire?

#11

Re: Getting back to Stuart's first question...

Dale Bonertz

Good points Rob but lets not get caught up on terminology. People say it blew up or blown up more because it makes the point easier than saying it fragmented on me or it fragmented up. The other thing is watch yourself turn. It is impossible to not have some part of your body in the line of fire at some point while turning. It may only be your hands or shoulder or edge of your body or while sanding or head when taking a quick look at the form or etc. There is an inherent risk involved in woodworking/woodturning that we can minimize but not eliminate. We need to teach safe practices but we cannot for see every possible scenario of an accident. Congratulations and good luck in your new position in the AAW.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#12

Re: Line Of Fire?

Dale Bonertz

Keith, I use a chuck for roughing because I production turn rough out bowls. It is much faster than face plates and very safe when done correctly. I cannot see why one would use 2 and 4 prong drive, as a norm, to rough unless you need to adjust a piece for aligning grain or natural edges and even then there are safer ways to do this than the prong drives. Using a screw in your chuck or using a pin chuck combined with the tail stock will keep anything from exiting the lathe. Bets are off, even using a face plate, if the wood is punky or not solid do to bark inclusions and etc.

I think this is why safety can be so difficult sets standards because we all turn differently and different projects for different reasons and different levels (hobbyist through professional). Not saying there can't be some standards set but what is safe for one may not be safe for another thus we need flexibility. Example: I cannot wear safety glasses because for whatever reason they always fog up on me. I am a contractor and get frustrated because I can't wear them for work either for the same reason. I have tried countless styles, brands and etc. with the same results. I think it is because they all have side shields and there is not adequate air flow for my eyes. I am not sure if this is some type of eye condition but what is more safe wearing safety glasses and not being able to see what I am doing or not wearing safety glasses and being able to see what I am doing. I always wear a face shield while turning and carry one with me for work when needed under certain circumstances. When at work I always wear sunglasses which are better than nothing but not by much. My point is that it is tough to fit everything into one box - there are to many variables at play.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#13

Kill Switch ?

Jim Breeden

I have a DVR XP. How would a kill switch be attached, since the stop switch is part of the touch screen?

Re: Line Of Fire?

#14

Alan Zenreich

Re: Kill Switch ?

Alan Zenreich

Jim,

Nova now makes a wireless remote control for the DVR XP.

It lets you mount the remote pretty much anywhere, or wear it like a wristwatch.

You can start, stop, and change speeds with the remote.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#15

Re: Kill Switch ?

Jim Breeden

Thanks Alan, I'll look into it.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#16

Alan Zenreich

Re: Kill Switch ?

Alan Zenreich

Jim,

I've got one on my XP. Depending on your lathe vintage, you might need an upgrade kit in addition to the remote. Mine did, but I like the remote, so it was worth it for me.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#17

Re: Kill Switch ?

Jeff Willaford

Mine is a simple limit switch wired in parallel with the button on the touch pad. That and an easy to reach red bar to actuate the switch. Take a look in the files (?) on WOW or I can send some info once I return from our Christmas travels if you might want to build one.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#18

Ellis Walentine

I like the hockey mask idea, but...

Ellis Walentine

... what do you wear for sanding and general dust protection? And, does the wire mesh obstruct your view of what you're doing?

Ellis

Re: Line Of Fire?

#19

Keith Tompkins

Re: I like the hockey mask idea, but...

Keith Tompkins

Hi Ellis, The hockey mask does not really interfere with my view. Honestly, it's a pain in the a$$ to take on and off, but otherwise, not bad. I run my dust collector while turning, as well as my Jet 1000B. I wear a dust mask at all times, but don't have a forced-air system.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: Line Of Fire?

Keith Tompkins

Dale, I agree that a chuck can be used safely, but the faceplate provides the additional security when needed....Personally, I won't turn punky wood (why would anybody?) nor wood with bark inclusions. Many production turners use faceplates, including the big guy himself...flatten the blank, six screws...reverse turn..done. I do use several chucks, but when I'm turning a big or off balance piece...faceplate.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#21

Re: Line Of Fire?

Dale Bonertz

Without a doubt there are good uses for the face plate.

Who is the big guy?

Re: Line Of Fire?

#22

Keith Tompkins

Re: Line Of Fire?

Keith Tompkins

Who is the "big guy"? THE big guy.....why David Ellsworth, of course! :D

Re: Line Of Fire?

#23

Re: Line Of Fire?

Dale Bonertz

Oh that big guy. David is a good man.

Re: Line Of Fire?

#24

i have  similar stop on all power tools