Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Lesson Learned ?

Posts

Lesson Learned ?

#1

Lesson Learned ?

Jim Breeden

Not paying attention today - got smacked with one (?) of the wings on a red cedar winged bowl I was turning. Had it reversed in the cole jaws, 1800rpm, turning the bottom, supported by the tail stockwhen - BAM ! :b - the back of my left hand got in the way of the whirling propeller wings. Hurt like hell but, luckily no damage, except my ego, and a large bruise on the back of my hand. On the other hand, five of the eight extended pins were bent, five silicone bumpers shredded, large chunk of the bowl taken out by the carbide bit, bowl came off the lathe like a whirling rocket. Damn, now have to start over ! Lesson learned - KEEP MY STUPID HANDS OUT OF THE WAY OF THE PROPELLER ! :O

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#2

Re: Lesson Learned ?

Steve Kniffen

Experience is what teaches us we've made this mistake before. Deep cut on the end of my thumb when it hit the spinning wings on my tri-wing bowl last week. Got blood on my easy finisher but no damage to the bowl.

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#3

Re: Lesson Learned ?

Don in Central Illinois

Just got close enough to the wings once. And that was close enough for me. Glad you were not hurt any more than a bruise.

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#4

Glad you weren't hurt worse but...

Don Orr

...Cole jaws are not meant to be spinning at 1800 rpm. Please check the manufacturers recommendations and stay safe.

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: Lesson Learned ?

Ric Taylor

My cole jaws have a warning label on them not to exceed 600 rpm.

Ric

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#6

Re: Glad you weren't hurt worse but...

Jim Breeden

Don - Yeah, I know the recommended rpm for cole jaws is 600 but, I normally use the tail stock as a light pusher, then I run 1000-1800 to initially clean up the base, remove the tail stock, then slow down to 500 for the final adjustment. I have turned numerous winged bowls and objects this way with no problems, except for yesterday when my fat hand got in the way of the "propellers".

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#7

Re: Lesson Learned ?

Jim Breeden

Ric - Yep, see my response to Don.

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#8

Hope it will be "Lesson Remembered"


Re: Lesson Learned ?

#9

Re: What if a jaw comes off?

Doc Green

Have you considered that the RPM limitation might be concerned with the mechanical integrity of the jaw/chuck combination? Only two fairly small screws hold each jaw, and this does not represent a lot of metal keeping everything together.

The presence of the tailstock for support, which is a good idea, will have no effect on the centrifugal force exerted on the jaw.

At 1800 RPM, the centrifugal force is 9 times what it is at the recommended maximum of 600. Do you think there is a "factor of 9" safety factor built in? Is there a possibility of metal fatigue with the screws? Stress cracks at the bottom of the threads? Etc?

Just a thought. ~Doc

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: Lesson Learned ?

Brad Vietje

Been there, done that, Jim!

Glad you had a learning experience instead of something much worse!

Mine was a square-sided crotch bowl with bark attached...before it smacked my left elbow! Turned to my right to respond to a sound, and somehow, my left elbow strayed just a "touch" too far to the left. How this happened, I can't speculate, but I remember it very well! Had a hard, sore spot on my left elbow to remind me for months. Just missed the little knob of bone sticking out (lateral epicondyle?), which could have been a lot worse had I hit it. I damaged the tendons just below that, on the ulnar side. Couldn't turn for a few days, then removed the weapon from the chuck and set it aside to dry. Still right there on the floor to the left of the headstock, where I buried it in shavings over a year ago.

I may finish turn it someday soon, and will post a photo when I do.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#11

Re: What if a jaw comes off?

Jim Breeden

Doc - I hadn't thought of that ending, good to know. Only problem I have, even with shard tools, I can't get a smooth cut at 600rpm. Any idea what I'm doing wrong?

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#12

Re: What if a jaw comes off?

Doc Green

Jim, I have my own problems in getting a smooth cut when removing a tenon at low RPM (with Cole jaws). What I generally do is take very light cuts and advance the tool as slowly and smoothly as I can manage. As a result, I may spend 5 minutes removing a tenon that is 2.5" in diameter and 3/8" thick. Seems like forever, but if I rush it, I lose more time in sanding away the ripples.

Good Luck, and Merry Christmas! ~Doc

Re: Lesson Learned ?

#13

Re: Lesson Learned ?

bill Crommett

It has been observed that the only real absolute safety with any machine is to "DON'T PLUG IT IN ". Take it from there !