I posted a response in the Hannes grind thread but it is getting kind of buried so I thought I would start a new thread. Has anyone come up with a good tool, formula or way to measure the bevel angle on the wings of a gouge. The angle tools that I have seen won't fit properly to get a accurate read on the bevel angle of the wing. The nose angle is easy. I hear so many say they are doing a 40*/40* bevel and wing angle but when you ask them how they measured it they say they set the platform at 40* so the angle is 40*. This would be true for the nose angle but not necessarily for the wing angle. Even though the platform may be set at the correct angle once you roll the tool to sharpen the wing the angle depends on how much you roll the tool over. I am wanting to accurately set wing angles but can't seem to find a means to measure them. Any help available? And yes I know it does not really matter that it is perfect and to use what is comfortable for your purposes but an inquiry mind wants to know.
In my opinion the side grind angle is not measurable. It is a moving target and changes as you get back on the wing vs up near the tip area. This is because of the internal flute configuration. There are many flute configurations and the outside bevel can not mirror the inside shape.
I agree with you that it does not matter. It is the outside bevel that is controlling your cuts. What the angle is, compared to the inside, is not going to change how it cuts much.
If you free hand sharpen, which is the only real way to get a proper 40/40 grind, the platform is set at 40 degrees. As you roll and sweep the tool onto the wings, the part that is getting sharpened should be flat on the tool rest (flutes roll from vertical to 90 degrees). since the platform is set at 40 degrees, when you are on the wings/swept back part of the gouge, the bevel angle should be pretty close to 40 degrees. I would guess that since you are going through 2 different angles (sweep and platform angles) you might have a compound miter, but still, it should be pretty close. If you don't roll the gouge as you sharpen, you will have very thin wings.
I do have a short clip up on You Tube showing platform sharpening. Type in robo hippy.
That is what I am discovering Lyle that it seems to be unmeasurable by tools. But I know that there has to be a way of measuring it through math. I also agree and think I mentioned in the original post (maybe not this one but the one under Hannes grind) that the bevel angle changes as you go up along the wing do to the thickness of the metal versus the flute and roundness of the steel.
Robo what you are doing in the video is exactly what everyone says. Since the platform is set at 40* then it is a 40* wing bevel which I maintain is wrong and misleading. The nose angle is 40* and the sweep back as you state is 40* from the nose but the sweep is different than the wing bevel angle. The wing bevel angle is determined by how far you roll the tool. In other words take your gouge and just keep the wings straight up and grind as you move it to your 40* you have on your platform. The sweep is still at 40* but you have drastically changed the bevel angle. So I maintain that you and others who claim they have a 40* wing bevel angle are just shooting in the dark to what it really is. The wing bevel angle in your video could easily be 60* and you think it is 40*. I want to learn how to measure it so that I can see visually what a 60* wing bevel angle looks like versus a 30* wing bevel angle.
I also believe once one can measure the wing bevel angle that one can set up his/her sharpening system to that parameter and repeat it. I don't believe that it has to be done free hand only. I may be wrong but I would like to prove this to myself. Any math whizzes who can help? Or any other ideas? Thanks in advance.
Youu don't need to be a math whiz and even if you were how would you calculate the varying flute grinds. I use a tool I purchased that has angles from 10 to about 45 degrees. It is a disc with these angles cut into it. It's not dead on because it's hard to get the tool in there and see the light at the gap to know your dead on but's close.
2 things affect this angle. How much you roll the tool when you sharpen the wing, and the shape of the flute. In Robo's description if you stop the grind with the flute parallel to the wheel then you have a repeatable angle but you still don't know what it is because the inside flute shape also changes the angle. simply because the nose is 40 degrees and you swing the tool 40 degrees for the wings does not mean the wings will be 40 degrees. I have sharpened my gouges this way for years before I got the wolverine jig the wing sharpness is different on my older off brand gouge vs my Thompson V and my Taylor U. Alll 3 have wings that vary in sharpness compared to the tip angle.
does it matter? Probably only a little. I use my old no name gouge for pull cuts beause the wing is a very sharp angle. It cuts extremely clean because of this on pull cuts. Dulls rapidly when used for roughing bowls. My Thompson V has a much blunter wing angle due to the shape of the flute and how I sharpnen it. This holds an edge much longer for roughing using push cuts. Still cuts pretty clean on pull cuts but not as good as the no name. I have my taylor gouge sharpened using the Stewart Batty grind. That style of sharpening and the shape of that flute gives me a 40 degree angle throught the edge.
It isn't quite shooting in the dark, but maybe kind of. You can't get the 40/40 grind with a gouge jig because they don't allow you to roll the tool all the way over the way it should be. If you try with a gouge jig, then you will have a sharper angle on your wings. After looking at Johannes's set up, I am thinking that his design idea is to allow you to do this with a jig, and hence the different mounting points. If you roll your gouge all the way over properly, you will have a fairly accurate angle. If you don't, then you will have wings that are too sharp.
Just in case you actually wanted to measure a tool -- let's say, for example, that you have a grind that really works great, and you want to see just what you DO have...
I suspect you could use some sort of stiff casting rubber, or a harder wax compound to make a negative casting of the flute from tip to wings, and then carefully slice it open at different points along the cutting edge and measure the angle that way (?)
It seems the ideal would be an included angle that does not vary, and that would be pretty hard to achieve. As others have stated, the flute shape would have to be the same for each tool sharpened on any given jig to get the same result. Thus, the true Hannes tool, or Ellsworth signature gouge, would be expected to produce the same result when used with recommended fixture, but when I take my off-brand 1/2" bowl gouge and attempt the same grind with that jig, the actual cutting edge geometry will only be the same if the flute design is exactly the same as the name-brand tool.
I think that I have it figured out how to measure the angle. It required modifying a tool but that is no big deal. My initial findings are pretty fascinating in that if the nose angle is 60* then the wing angle is 60*. The same held true with a 45* nose and wing. They are within a few degrees. I am sure this is a coincidence but I won't have time until after Christmas to play around on my grinder to change angles. I have measured four gouges and all held true except a detail gouge which has a 30* nose angle and 60* wing angles. I also believe, at least for now, that I can change that nose angle to wing angle by moving the jig in and out and moving the multi grind tool angle (Kelton Tools sharpening system). You'll have to wait, if you're curious, on how I managed to measure the wing angle until I can verify through an engineer friend of mine if I am on the right track. I agree with what some have said that it is going to be difficult to get an absolute true measurement but I think that I can get it to within +- 2*. Again, this is to satisfy my curiosity and I don't think this will change the wood turning community and the way it does thing by one bit.
Again its the outside wing angle that is the important measurement. That is what you are grinding. The angle of the bevel compared to the flute is not necessary or needed.
One way to measure the outside wing angle would be to lay the gouge on a table with the flute edges parallel to the table, pointing straight up and measure the wing bevel angle compared to the table. This would give you an obtuse angle. And it still would be a graded, changing angle, different on the front part of the wing than the rear part of the wing. If you measure at the center location of the wing you could compare it to other gouges/grinds.
Always keep in mind the rules for setting any jig. The jig arm adjustment changes the tip angle, and the basket pivot position changes the side grind angle. It is confusing because they influence each other but those are the rules.
I like my grind the way it is.....but if I wanted to take off the heel of the bevel I would put a block of wood shim in the Wolverine basket pivot point (moving it closer to the grinding wheel) and the heel would go away and never touch the edge shape or angle. That is what Hannes is doing with his multi-hole jig, he has three pivot points. One for the edge and two to take the heel off the bevel off, by moving the jig pivot position up closer to the wheel.
Ok I understand what you're saying but I disagree - maybe because that is my point in the first place that when talking the wing angle there is so much misinformation. First when you measure the nose (tip angle) you use the inside of the flute and the bevel cut by the grinder or the parallel line from the flute on the outside edge of the gouge and the bevel to determine if you have a 60*, 40*, 30* or whatever (I just put my angle gauge in the flute and measure the angle - easiest for me). So why on earth would people say I have a 40* 40* angle on my tool using two different reference points. The only reference point is the inside flute and not some other non constant like a table top. The sharpness angle of the edge or bevel angle is determined by two planes and those planes are the inside flute surface and the bevel that has been ground. I do agree that it changes along the cutting edge depending on the gouge manufacturer and the profile of the flute. However this difference along the edge bevel angle is not going to change by very many degrees thus in my mind not going to be a big enough factor for discussion.
When using a jig as you mention you are correct in the relationship between the carrier arm and the multi/vari grind tool holder. But I go back to the platform (this becomes the carrier arm) and the free hand of the tool grinding which now becomes the multi/vari grind jig. No one can say they are achieving a 40* bevel angle (I guess they can but they can't prove it) because it depends on how much they roll the tool over. Just because one marks and angle on their platform at 40* from the center of the wheel does not ensure they are getting a 40* bevel angle on the wing of their tool. Sorry got to go to church for Christmas - we can continue this discussion later.
Great discussion, and so appropriate for this angelic season.
This thread matters in part because the included angle at the cutting edge is a measure of the tradeoff between sharpness and durability. Smaller included angle more "sharp" and less "durable." But I believe a consistent included angle all the way around is not necessarily goodness for turners. And doesn't exist in practice.
For turners the included angle matters in part so that the tool bevel profile can allow the bevel to follow the intended surface shape (eg. turning the corner at the bottom of a bowl.) Thus we have multiple grinds on different tools, or variable included angles on the same tool (eg. Elsworth grind.)
This excellent thread asks how we can get a consistent included angle at the cutting edge. Why? I think it only matters that the "included angle" is consistent if all you are concerned about is consistent "sharpness" and "durability." Most side ground bowl gouges go from a blunt nose to an acute side grind, more or less depending on flute profile. But don't we mostly cut wood just off the nose at about 1:30? And very little on the side except when sheer cutting or scraping? And generally when shear cutting we would want the side to be more sharp and it is ok to sacrifice durability?
Measuring the tangent line of the concave flute at the cutting edge is a problem. As John said you can get a rough idea (if it matters) of this included angle with a circular angle jig such as this:
There are several factors apart from the jigging and sharpening body mechanics discussed here that affect the angle of the side grind. I have struggled with this for years as I try to help new turners learn sharpening. They always seem to show up with a tool that is different than I expect:
- Flute profile eg. Round to U to V)
- Flute depth eg. spindle gouge v detail gouge
- Length of side grind eg. Irish v traditional
All 3 (and in combination) I believe affect the included angle between the side bevel and the tangent of the flute at the cutting edge. Again, the included angle is a measure of the tradeoff between sharpness and durability (and also no doubt "catch-ability.")
- A round flute shape tends to lead to a more consistent included angle as you sweep to the side bevel
- A U shape does the same, but less so.
- A V shape can lead to a dramatic change to a more acute side angle.
- A long side grind tends to lead to a more acute side angle (and a pointy nose)
- A deeper flute likely has an effect but I am not just sure how right now....Maybe it follows along with flute shape.
That is why I think many turners seem to intuitively prefer U shapes.
A straight grind on a round flute is the only reliable way to get a consistent included angle. Think roughing gouge out of bar stock. When you deviate from straight with a round flute to a fingernail grind and/or V flute the included side angle will unavoidably vary methinks, unless you are a contortionist who hand grinds differently for each tool. A straight grind on a V flute would be odd.
So because of all the observations above I think it is impossible to provide a general purpose jig based solution to get a consistent angle all the way around the fingernail grind, even if that was desirable. And I don't see why that is desirable in general.
But I do agree that hand grinding with consistent personal feedback by some measuring method for a particular tool and flute design is the only way to get there. You might come up with a jig based solution but it would be very tool and flute specific.
I would much rather learn to repeatably and quickly sharpen to a consistent multi-use profile with little loss of steel, adapt to my tool, and spend my time turning.
Re: How many angles can dance on the end of a goug
Dale Bonertz
Jerry,
Quite a bit of the same thinking I have. I really am not interested in getting a consistent bevel angle along the edge but rather, out of curiosity, learning what the angle is other than just saying 40* when in reality it may be 60*. I also,as said earlier, don't believe this information will rock the wood turning world but it may lead to a better understanding of cutting edge and how they relate to wood turning. It has always baffled me when someone says they have a nose angle of 40* or 60* (always measurable) and then make up a wing angle based on what. I hear you loud and clear that we use the edge near the tip so if you have a 40* nose or 60* nose and both gouges have a 60* wing angle then we essentially are cutting with the same tool (provided the tools are equal otherwise - ie: flute shape, metal type and etc.). The nose angle then only becomes important when starting a cut and its ability to get into the area you want to get to (such as the transition area and across the bottom of a bowl). So for me then why even use a 40* nose angle on bowls (as some do). So that is why I started this thread so turners can get a better understanding of the wing angle which can be as important as the nose angle.
BTW: I have measured 5 gouges 1- 3/4" thompson V 1- 5/8" oneway double ended (different grind on each end) 1 - 1/2" unknown brand (more parabolic) 1- 1/2 serious tool (again double ended different grinds) and 1- 3/8" serious tool spindle gouge. As we have all agreed so far that the flute shape dictates the wing angle isn't panning out to be correct in my preliminary measurements. I have measured all of these gouges as so (tip, near the tip on wing, 1/2 way up the wing and the top edge of the wing). In every case so far the wing angle has measured the same all along the edge of the wing. Now this may be getting lucky/unlucky with my sharpening techniques so I have a lot of testing and playing around before I can make any firm conclusions. I have a friend (John Giem) who is an engineer and is also interested in this topic. We are collaborating findings which is giving both of us eye/mind opening thoughts.
I know many people are probably saying who cares as long as it works. True statement but some inquiry minds want to know. What started this for me was standing at my lathe roughing another batch of bowls. I rough bowls much the same way Glenn Lucas does (left handed push slicing cut) except I am not nearly as talented and way to chicken to sharpen the wing back as far as he does. However, it occurred to me one day that if I grind the wing at a different angle I can then position the tool in a more comfortable position for me so I can stand in a better position to alleviate back and hip pain. I am kind of slow because it has only reached the thought stage and not the take action stage but it really got me thinking about the importance of wing angles. That coupled with the comments that I hear so many (not just forum people) say they use this 40* 40* grind but really don't no what the wing angle is or even understand it - rather just repeating what the person who taught them a grind is saying. At least that is my perception and I may be proven totally wrong which I won't know until I go through the exercise to understand/test it.