Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

Posts

Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#1

Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

Dick Coers

Anyone seen this in person or bought one? I see the pivoting plate has 5 locating holes in it, and he includes an adjustment block. Any ideas for how many steps it takes to duplicate his grind on this fixture? The little bit of instruction on the sales pitch has me confused as to which hole is use for what. My main question is how to duplicate the small cutting bevel. All the relief bevels seem easy. I'm just wondering if you use the two wing holes and the center hole to duplicate the cutting bevel. Thanks.


http://hannestool.com/products-page/hannestool-brands/vector-grind-fixture

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#2

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Mike Foster

Dick, I knew about his jig as he was developing it. I have been around when he had it at a couple of shows, but just did not have the time to look at it. I wonder if he uses it at all (though I would suspect that he SAYS he does) as he can get his grind in about 10 seconds at the wheel without the jig. I use his grind almost exclusively now, and just free had it myself. I do this on a belt grinder though. I can't say that I would be tempted to buy the jig as it is easy enough to do freehand. FYI, Hannes lives near me and I would consider him a friend and good guy, so this is no slight at all against him.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#3

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Dick Coers

I've watched Johannes for years, back when you could be a hat at a woodturners discount of $500. That was easily 15+ years ago at the regional symposiums in St. Louis. I'm sure he doesn't use the fixture, but has been hounded for so many years on how to do his grind, I'm sure he felt an opportunity knocking. I bought two of his gouges years ago, and what bothers me is the idea that I am laying them too far over to get the grind right at the last intersection before the straight. I've got some money to spend on tooling here at the end of the year so I don't send it all in on taxes. It's not a major investment, so thought it might be worth it. I can't see how to make email contact on his web site, so might call him tomorrow.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#4

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture (long)

Donna Banfield

Dick, Hannes really does use that Vector jig to sharpen his tools. Earlier this year he had a prototype at the New England Woodturning Symposium. It is now in full production. He was in my studio last month for my annual Open Turning event, and had these jigs with him.

Full disclosure here - I became a fan of his grind and his tools in 2007, and have been free-hand sharpening all my bowl gouges since. I'm also a big fan of his tools, as well, and own several. I teach private one-on-one woodturning sessions in my studio and my students have full access to use any of my tools. Many of my students end up buying Hannes' gouges.

I bought two of the Vector fixtures that day. Why? Because having several of my gouges with the grind that the Vector produces makes roughing out bowl blanks much faster. The grind is a bit more aggressive when compared to the free-hand grind. I loved the free-hand grind (as do many of my bowl-turning students) because it is nearly catch-free. I can roll a gouge with Hannes' free-hand grind completely on it's side, flute facing the wall, on the interior curve of a bowl, handle completely horizontal, and not get a catch. I could never do that with any other fingernail grind gouge, and not get a 3/4 inch divot alll the way around the inside wall. The trade-off to that is, it is not as aggressive at roughing out bowl blanks, which is what makes it catch-free. With the Vector grind, rolling the gouge on the side in the same manner will make it a little grabby, but I haven't gotten one of those 'fudge my huggies' catches I remember. So I have my larger gouges (3/4" and a few 1/2") sharpened with the Vector grind, and I keep a few of my bowl gouges with the free-hand grind. But, I've also just walked up to the grinder and did a quick touch-up free-hand on the Vector grinds, too. In that case, I'm just refreshing the edge to take a final cut.

To sharpen, you start with the two outside pivot points, (far left and far right on the plate) which give you your primary micro-bevel. The center pivot point on the same plane blends the tip of your gouge with the micro-bevel. The next two forward pivots allow you to remove the heel of the gouge. Once set up on the grinder, I leave the Vector in the slide arm; it works on all his gouges (or any gouge that you choose to put that grind on), regardless of size (3/4, 1/2 and 3/8) because the bevel is always a constant 40 degrees.

I hope that this helps.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#5

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture (long)

Dick Coers

That helps a lot. I had the idea that it worked like you say, but was concerned that you may have had to reset the distance from the vari-grind to the tip of the chisel when you were moving around the hole pattern. Since that is not the case, I'm ordering one now. Thanks for the help.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#6

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

robo hippy

Well, hopefully I will be in Tampa and can check it out there. I really don't understand why, when the primary bevel has been sharpened, why it makes any difference how you remove the heel on the bottom of the bevel. I guess it can be called a secondary bevel, but it isn't a bevel that you use or that ever comes into contact with the wood. Mostly I want at least half the heel removed, and I round it over rather than try for a smooth even bevel. Some times, I will remove 3/4 of it, and even saw a Christian Burshard gouge that was rounded over so that it had no bevel at all.

As for the not catching point, any gouge will do that if you roll it on its side between 45 and 90 degrees, especially if the handle is held level. Deeper V gouges don't work as well for this cut. Continental gouges, or Doug's fluteless gouges are great for this cut (cutting on the lower 1/3 of the blade).

Kind of like the jitter bug, it plumb evaded me......

robo hippy

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Bill Blasic

I have one and it works as advertised. A nice addition to your tool grinding arsenal.

Bill

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#8

Steven Antonucci

Why does the shape of the heel matter?

steven antonucci

I watched his video on his website, and he's doing it freehand. It's probably before he invented this jig, but it seems like one of those "huh?" moments? Why would I care if the heel was faceted, round, or pretty? It doesn't cut, and it's just in the way and has to be ground off.

I remove the heels on my gouges freehand, and by no means pretty. I simply place them against the wheel and roll the tool until I have "enough" of the heel removed to provide the clearance I need.

It seems like something that if you really needed one, you could make a block of wood to attach to your Wolverine arm in about 5 minutes... but I don't get this at all?

Sorry

Steve

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#9

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Don in Central Illinois

Great song, haven't heard it for awhile. I see we a have a parrot head.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#10

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Don in Central Illinois

Steve, I meant to reply to Robo's post.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#11

Re: Why does the shape of the heel matter?

Dick Coers

I'm pretty sure this fixture is not really about the heel, (well maybe some) but for me it's about being able to roll the gouge correctly to get a consistantly accurate main bevel all around the flute. The design has the pivot points way off the sides of the beam. I really thought about making a wood insert to get those holes, but I'm at the stage in life where I don't always like to do the trial and error. I'm at the buy the tool and start cutting. I mentioned earlier about seeing Johannes in St. Louis, around 1996. I picked up his gouge and remarked to the guy next to me, "That's the ugliest grind I have ever seen." After the demo, I knew exactly why it looked that way.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#12

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

robo hippy

I remembered the old song about Moonshine and Buddy Bear, didn't think it was a Buffet song though. Looked it up again, and there it was.... Always loved that song, lots of good lines in it.

I freehand/platform sharpen now, no jigs for me. Can't see why you would want to use the special jig. Just think of the amount of time saved if you never had to use a gouge jig. Setting platform angles is pretty simple, and you already have the basic skills, ABC/anchor the tool, rub the bevel, and cut. Exactly as you do when turning.

robo hippy

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#13

Re: Dick said it...

Donna Banfield

It's not the way that the heel is removed, nor how much, but rather the consistent manner in getting the same micro-bevel all the way around the entire cutting edge of the tool. That's the purpose of the jig.

For you, Reed and many others, it may escape why this seems to need a jig when it can be done free-hand. Pretty simple. Not everyone can do that, no matter how much they try, they can never get the hang of it. Several years ago I had conversations with Hannes about his grind. It took me at least 3 months back in 2007 to learn how to do it - that is be able to get a consistent, repeatable free-hand grind, and that was turning and sharpening nearly every day. I have students that I've taught how to do this, and a year later, they still can't get it.

Steve, you teach. Don't you sometimes want to just take the tool out of the student's hand and 'do it yourself'? :) Especially when a student keeps repeating the same mistake over and over (admit it, you know you've wanted to). As much as you'd like to do that, you don't, because some concepts are harder to grasp. Enough times repeated the right way, and most of the times they get it. However, some don't, especially when you only get a chance to turn a few times month. That's why Hannes finally came up with the jig. In his words, "I had to bring the grind to the turners, not the other way around."

And sure, you could probably come up with a jig of your own. A lot of woodturners will do that/have already done that. But like Dick Coers, some are at a point in their life that they don't want to tinker, they just want to turn. Even if I could tinker (I can't) I wouldn't. I just want to turn. :)

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#14

Re: Dick said it...

robo hippy

Donna,

I will have to think about this one for a bit. For sure, there are some skills that are more difficult for people to learn, but never really considered free hand removal of the heel of the bevel to be one. I do know that some people will never be able to learn how to core with the McNaughton. I don't work with too many beginners. I did do one small 'Saw Dust Session' that was stations on different sharpening methods, and I was showing free hand. Some times the most difficult idea to get across is that this really isn't that difficult, you have the skills, you just need to learn how to apply them.

robo hippy

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#15

Re: Dick said it...

David Walser

Robo,

I don't think the purpose of the jig is to remove the heel from the bevel. Instead, the purpose of the jig is to allow turners to get a consistent bevel angle (40 degrees) along the entire cutting edge. [Most jigs produce a blunter bevel angle at the nose (say, 60 degrees) and a far sharper bevel angle on the wings (say, 35 degrees).]

Once the jig has accomplished this purpose, the turner will still need to remove the heel of the bevel. The turner could remove the gouge from jig and remove the heel freehand. Or, since the jig maker thoughtfully included a set of pivot holes closer to the grinding wheel, the turner can use those pivot holes to quickly remove the heel -- without any risk of inadvertently touching wheel with the cutting edge. I think this extra set of pivot holes is a nice touch. It makes removing the heel easier than removing the gouge from the jig and removing the heel freehand. Plus, some turners just like the aesthetics of having a smooth, single facet, on the removed heel. Personally, I don’t get that. The secondary bevel – smooth or not, single or multi-faceted, does not affect the way the tool cuts. But, then, I don’t get why some turners use fancy wood for their tool handles. A cocobolo handled tool doesn’t cut any better than does a tool handled in some more ordinary wood. Yet, some turners like their tools to look the part.

While I think the jig’s extra set of pivot holes are a nice touch, I don't think they're the reason to buy the jig. I'd be surprised if it's maker thought they extra pivot holes were a reason for buying the jig, either. They're just a nice touch.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#16

Re: Robo, what David said!


Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#17

Re: Dick said it...

robo hippy

Now, that makes some sense. The Stuart Batty 40/40 grind (40 degree bevel, and 40 degree sweep can not be done on any grinding jig. I think that may because when you use a jig, the amount of roll you can do as you grind is pretty limited, and some times the wings are too pointy/not thick enough/too sharp of a bevel. His grind is on the platform. Nose bevel angle with a jig is determined by how far out it extends. Using the same pivot point, more extension makes it more sharp, and less makes it more blunt. I need to perfect my teaching methods on free hand sharpening. Main point I make is that the part that is cutting/being sharpened has to be directly on the tool rest, and you have to roll as you sweep. Scraper, no roll, continental gouge minimal roll, SRG, smooth steady roll, V gouge little roll on the nose then quick roll over to the wings.

robo hippy

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#18

Bill Blasic

Re: Dick said it...

Bill Blasic

Micro bevel repeatability without grinding a lot of tool away for me is the name of the game.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#19

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

joHannes Michelsen

The original impetus to create/invent the Vector Grind Fixture was to make this high functioning grind available to all turners and we did accomplish that. Now that I have it on my grinder and know the real advantages of "controlled" grinding I use it exclusively---" I never freehand any more" not even for a touch up, its just not worth messing with the perfectly repeatable angle and then having to "get it back" the next time you use the fixture!

Big advantage of this fixture is that the steel is oriented "flute up" by the projection jig not internally in the tool hold device as in all other jigs--doing it that way makes it impossible to grind the whole flute, only about half the flute length can be done because it is used to bear on internally to orient steel flute up. The vector flute up is done out at the tip of the steel and the entire flute length can be done.

Vector tool hold device has knob on the bottom to facilitate total roll over while grinding which is what makes the tool catch free, its that curving side that give a bevel to rub no matter how far you roll over in the cut to a point---if the whole edge sees wood there will be a catch but the tool will be so far over at that point that it will be very mild almost a non-catch if there is such a thing. There are only abotu 3 degrees of rotation where there could be one of those non catches, once the tool is rolled so far that the inside of the flute is a ramp out the what you have is a negative rake shear scraper and that don't catch.

When turning hats I use the tool that way as much as I use it cutting.

It is my intention to make a video of instruction for the "Vector" just hasn't got there yet--maybe between the holidays!;-)

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#20

Brad Vietje

Re: Hannestool Grind Video (the OLD way) *LINK*

Brad Vietje

Excellent news that Hannes is planning a video of his Vector Grind fixture in use. I have been fooling around with thin lampshades and such, and want to grind a few gouges his way, so I will save up for the fixture if it doesn't come for Christmas or by B-day. I like the idea of a repeatable grind that gives the same result every time without frustration and loss of tool steel when the ideal shape is lost.

For anyone still grinding these free-hand, here's the free-hand method from the Hannes Tool web site. (Maybe someone already posted this ???) Let's remember that Hannes himself no longer recommends the free-hand method, but for those who can't have the Vector Grind fixture just yet, this link may help until you DO get the Vector upgrade.

Happy Holidays and Safe spinning to all,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Hannes Grind Free-Hand

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Dick said it...

Keith Tompkins

HI Donna, I think the biggest problem many new turners face is sharpening...especially if they come from a bacground where they've never sharpened anything. We've all seen the butchered grinds, and tools a week old with no flute left. Consistancy is the key, and the jig is the key to consistantcy. To the average turner, far less time grinding using a jig, longer tool life, and a tool that behaves the same way after sharpening. Freehand sharpening is too much to ask of a new turner, I think.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#22

Re: I agree, Keith

Donna Banfield

Which is why I think that Hannes' Vector jig is a really good idea. It gives the beginning woodturner the ability to achieve a consistent grind on their gouge that will not make them need to 'white knuckle' the handle in fear of getting a catch.

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#23

Re: Hannestool Grind Video (the OLD way)

Dale Bonertz

How are any of you measuring the wing angle? I often read the 40/40 grind. It is easy to measure the nose angle with an angle gauge but the wing angle is very difficult to get a good angle measurement. I can't say for sure ,because I can't get a true measurement on the wing angle, but I don't think you can maintain a 40 degree wing angle all along the wing. The flutes are not true V's or U's. Most flutes are more oval in shape. One can sharpen the nose at 40* but once you start going up the flute it will change all along the edge. It may be 40* starting around and up the wing but by the time you hit the center of the wing it changes to maybe 35* or less. I would really like to test my theories but I cannot find a tool that will accurately measure the wing angle since it is in such a tight area.

Disclaimer: Not sure it really matters, when it comes to using a tool, if the angle is consistent going up the wing or not. I am just a curious mind and my math side of my brain nags me to find out. Any help with a tool to measure this tight area angle would be helpful (Or math formula to calculate it).

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture *LINK*

#24

Re: Hannes vector grind fixture

Mike Kratky

I was at Hannes' shop for 3 days back in April when he was perfecting the Vector Grind Fixture and had the opportunity to put the prototypes through their paces and was one of the 1st to receive the new finalized jig. Having been an advocate and a big user of the grind for years and sharpening it by hand the jig really does give you simple consistant repeatability with the added benefit that the lower center dimple that he added not for the Hannes grind but replicates the wolverine jig grind should you desire so you actually get 2 jigs in one.