Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Match the blank or match the blade?

Posts

Match the blank or match the blade?

#1

Match the blank or match the blade?

Jeff Willaford

The recent posts about McNaughton coring makes me wonder. How many turn the outside of the blank and try to select the blade that matches best … and how many select the blade and then turn the shape to conform?

My best success at coring comes from turning the outside shape of the bowl to match the curve of the blades I want to use. I understand that getting the most out of a great piece of wood might dictate a different approach but I am, for the most part, just coring bowls to be re-turned at some later date. I can refine the shape then. This seems intuitive to me but most of the videos and posts seem to talk about selecting a blade to match the curve of the blank you’ve previously shaped.

Just curious what approach others may take.

Re: Match the blank or match the blade?

#2

Re: Match the blank or match the blade?

robo hippy

I think the proper answer is 'yes'. I probably do a little of both. Some times, the shape is determined by the piece of wood. Over the years, I have a preferred shape that fits nicely with the medium curved blade. I do wish Kel made a blade with a curve inbetween that of the medium curve, and the small curve. It would fit well into the set.

robo hippy

Re: Match the blank or match the blade?

#3

Steven Antonucci

I don't make samll medium large matches

steven antonucci

I just want to get three bowls out of the deal. Like you, I core them thick and return to a final shape. If the three relate, it's kind of a surprise to me because I am not trying to make a nested set.

Steve

Re: Match the blank or match the blade?

#4

Re: Match the blank or match the blade?

Dale Bonertz

Either would work fine so as Robo said yes. I turn the form that I like and then use the best blade to core it. Remember, the form you turned to match a blade will change once you move that blade in to core. The interior radius/arc will be slightly off since you have changed the location of the blade in both width and height of the original blank. Not always very much but some. Having said that I am all for what gives the individual the confidence to be successful with their tools. Have fun - Be safe.