Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

earring stand comparison

Posts

earring stand comparison

#1

earring stand comparison

John Lucas

Well I finished the last Christmas present. I hadn't planned to make this one but my friend was over and saw the last one and asked if I could make one for his wife. So I did. I put both of these together with no plans and no real design. They came out OK but sure could have been a lot better. I thought it would be fun to get your thoughts on design.

If I designed them from scratch I would make the base more like the one on the left. I like the wide stance. I might make the maple proud of the walnut a little to make it more like a plaque possible with a very small bead on the top and bottom. The top of the one on the right is too small. It works but for wider earrings it might get kind of crowded and I think if I make the bottom wider like the one on the left then the top should be also.

For the middle I think I would experiment with having a sort of womans silhouette form. The one on the right sort of looks masculine like a guy at attention. Which might work as a design for my gay friends. This would make it sort of Academy awards kind of trophy but maybe that's not a bad thing.

I'm still trying to learn to use my new scanner and if I have time to work out the bugs I'll make a sketch and show you what I'm thinking.



Re: earring stand comparison

#2

Re: earring stand comparison

John Veerkamp

John,

to me both of the bases look too heavy. I like a little more delicate look. I agree that the top diameter and the bottom diameter should be roughly equal. If the user has longer dangly earrings It could also be a bit taller,

My nickel's worth.

Re: earring stand comparison

#3

Re: earring stand comparison

John Veerkamp

I forgot to say I do like them, nice work.

Re: earring stand comparison

#4

Re: earring stand comparison

bob davis

ditto, john

Re: earring stand comparison

#5

Re: earring stand comparison

Dick Coers

Looks like a lot of height and wood to hold those tiny earrings. I know that they will work with hanging earrings, but still pretty tall. Very nice craftsmanship.

Re: earring stand comparison

#6

Re: earring stand comparison

Cynthia Gibson

I like the second one better for a number of reasons but I would definitely make the wheel larger to hold more earrings. Your pyro on the bottom is MUCH better on the second one....sometimes it's good to score a line with your tools while it's on the lathe to help with a crisp straight line as a guide for your writing. Excellent work, John!!

Re: earring stand comparison

#7

Re: earring stand comparison

John Lucas

Cynthia I did use a 5hb pencil to make lines. Just like my hand writing and maybe my life I'm not very good at following lines. :)

Re: earring stand comparison

#8

Don Leydens

Re: earring stand comparison

Don Leydens

John, I agree about making them a bit smaller. Also like your idea about the rim bead (top and bottom). So many places you could go with these. Excellent work as always!

Re: earring stand comparison

#9

Re: earring stand comparison

John Lucas

Yea it sorta depends on how you really want it to look. I have a couple of ideas. One is make the top more of summer hat wide brim sort of look and then make the finial much more feminine. The base would then need to be smaller and more of a base rather than a pedestal although there is hidden meaning in putting her on a pedestal.

The other concept is to shorten the finial perhaps even a sphere with a small flat base that the sphere sits in. Then you could put the ring on top with another sphere to hold it in place. Then it would be sort of planet or outer space kind of look.

Barbara Dill could have a good time with this with off center turning for both the column and the ring.

I have another idea based on cantilever shelves that would be fun. I'll have to sketch on that one and see how it goes.

Re: earring stand comparison

#10

Don Leydens

Re: earring stand comparison

Don Leydens

Seems like you have more ideas than time to make them all. I like the female profile idea a lot (think big boobs)(sorry, couldn't resist). The hat idea sounds like a keeper too. Look forward to seeing where you take this.

Re: earring stand comparison

#11

Don Leydens

Re: earring stand comparison

Don Leydens

Forgot to say, the hat on a lady form would look cool.

Re: earring stand comparison

#12

Re: earring stand comparison

John Lucas

Don I was thinking sort of this kind of form.

Re: earring stand comparison

#13

Don Leydens

Re: earring stand comparison

Don Leydens

Now we're talking! o o

Re: earring stand comparison

#14

Re: earring stand comparison

Barry Irby

I made one years ago for a young lady that was a friend of my son. I made the bottom bigger but not as tall. Basically the bottom was turned out a inch thick piece of wood and it was larger in diameter than the top. It had a trench turned in it to serve as a tray for stray fittings. The top was large an thin. There was a very small point left on the bottom "on purpose" to serve as a pivot. There was a knob on top so you could balance it and turn it to the pair of ear rings you wanted. The trick was to get the pivot Just Right so that the piece was not listing too badly but could still turn.

I like yours and wish I could do the writing on mine. Anybody got a typewriter that will type in a circle? I like the feminine form Idea.

Re: earring stand comparison

#15

Re: earring stand comparison

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

A small taper to the top spindle allows it to be a finger ring holder. A little larger diameter of holes allows multiple earrings to be placed in one set of holes for the gals that have dozens of pairs. We have sold several at shows for $30/35 when $20 for a slimline was too expensive.