Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Can you sand too smooth for finish?

Posts

Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#1

Can you sand too smooth for finish?

John Lucas

I'm asking this because I hear it repeated from time to time. That if you sand to 1000 or 2000 grit the finish will not stick. I've never had a problem that I can remember and when I test finishes for flow out I apply them to glass and they stick really well. I know glass is smoother than 2000 grit. What is your opinion of this?

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

Mike Stafford

I don't have a definitive answer for your question. I have sanded many boxes to 1200; a few higher than that if the nature of the wood still showed scratches to my eye i.e. cocobolo, kingwood, etc.

However, it doesn't get much smoother than glass and most film finishes will stick to glass. If course they might peel off later also.

I cannot imagine it is possible for there not to be enough "tooth" for the finish to adhere. Maybe someone could ask Bob Flexner or one of the other finishing experts their opinion.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

Leo Cuellar

Some paints don't do as well if the wood is sanded past 180#. There were some threads on this awhile back on the messages board.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#4

Depends

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If aggressive sanding gets the lignin hot enough, it will tend to fuse and seal some of the wood pores thus interfering with the penetration, especially in the transition area between face and end grain. Result is usually uneven, splotchy color and weaker adhesion in some areas.

If the abrasive gets too hot to hold with your hand, you may have a problem.

BTW, using a lighter touch, letting the abrasives do the work, will give better results and will also allow the abrasive to last longer as it won't get as easily/quickly coated with lignins that act to stick the fibers to the paper clogging the abrasive surface.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Depends

Mike Stafford

Yep, with what you said about sanding until the wood is hot I do agree. I try desperately to never heat up the wood. The first person I ever took a turning lesson from emphasized letting the paper do its job without undue pressure.

I suppose the effect you describe is the same as burnishing the wood which is what I was told would happen if one sanded with too fine of a grit before its time.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#6

Exactly


Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#7

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

robo hippy

The theory as I heard it is that the finer grits can actually burnish the wood. I would imagine that this would be more so if your abrasives are dull, and you are pushing too hard. If you have to use a backing pad so your fingers are not getting too hot, you are pushing too hard. Paint has a problem sticking to wood that has been sanded too fine. Paint is mostly pigment, and not binders, which is why primer is used. I would think that surface finishes would have more problems sticking to a slick surface. If I have sanded really fine, I will tend to thin down oil/solvent/penetrating finishes for the first coat or so. Then use full thickness for build up coats.

robo hippy

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#8

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

vamatt

I had adhesion issues with minwax stain on hard maple that was sanded to 320. I might have burnished the wood through poor sanding technique, although I do not remember the wood getting too hot. I gave the "wand" as a gift "unfinished", so I'll have to follow up to see how the piece faired once it was sealed.

matt

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#9

JL

Yes

JL

For some finishes.

For some finishes you need a "tooth" for the finish to be able to "bite". The wood (even when sanded) has many fine fibers.



When you sand too much, you eliminate all the fine fibers and you smooth the wood too much for the finish (or glue) to be able to stick. You are essentially doing that when you burnish or when you heat the wood up too much. You are eliminating all the fibers, filling up all the pores and generally making things too smooth.

For glue, I never sand it much below 220 grit. For urethane finishes - maybe 300-320 grit. For lacquers - I've taken it to 400 grit or higher. For oils, maybe 300 grit.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#10

Re: Yes

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Why do we sand our woodturnings? Guess we want to even out wood surface, remove tool marks, before apply a finish. How much sanding we do depends upon damage we did to wood, species of wood, and finish going to use.

Did not forget intended use of the item we turned. Some instances exist where no finish used so may sand to higher grits. So no sanding bare wood to 2,000 or 3,000 grits not always necessary but does not hurt anybody when needed.

Might want to sand to higher grits if going to use oil or oil blend as a finish. Have read where cannot see scratches after sanding with 400 grit, we know that is not true.

Film finish manufacturers seldom recommend sanding higher than 320 grit. If select a film finish that benefits from rubbing out might want too wet or oil sand using higher grits.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#11

Re: Yes

John Lucas

I've been sanding my hand mirrors to 400 grit for years with not problems. Many different kinds of wood. I use lacquer or minwax wipe on poly 90% of the time.

On woods like Cocobolo and blackwood you can easily see sanding marks up to 600 grit. Especially cross grain lines. I sand with the grain as much as possible.

I sanded some Brazillian Rosewood to 600 grit this morning and applied some thinned lacquer. Then followed that up with minwax wipe on poly thinned with lacquer thinner. It seems to be OK.

I use new sandpaper all the time and try my best to never let it get hot.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#12

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

I will offer another opinion. With the proper hardwoods if you sand it fine enough, it does not need a finish. Perhaps only a little wax is enough.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#13

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

I probably over sand with higher grit sand paper than necessary before applying finish. Have no idea why continue to do so especially after reading manufacturers sanding recommendations.

Know am wasting time and money especially when find tool marks or sanding scratches after applying a finish.

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

#14

Re: Can you sand too smooth for finish?

steve worcester

If I am going to put a film finish on it, I go to about 320 or 400. It may be a throwback from the days of you have to have something for the finish to bite, but really the finish is (for me) going to be so several coats built up and the finish will be what you feel, not the wood. So any more sanding is wasted time and materials.