I could use some help on bottle stopper threads. I've blown out the threads on the last three walnut pieces I have. If anyone has a foolproof method, I'm all ears.
my failing process, for the record, is drilling the hole (i've tried 11/32 and 5/16) on the lathe and using the hand tap. I've tried two differnet taps and I've blown out threads with both. For such a simple process, i'm at a loss.
Are you saying that you actually tap threads into the wood? I just drill a hole slightly undersized and then screw the SS (Niles) stopper in. In soft wood I glue it in with Med CA, In hard woods no glue necessary. Never had a problem.
Need more info on how your tapping the threads. Are you doing it by hand or under power on the lathe? I agree with the above. On soft woods I just drill the appropriate hole and then screw it on. On hard woods I use a hand held tap. You should screw it down slightly and then back it up every so often. this breaks up the chips and keeps the tap from clogging. The chips fall into the flute of the tap.
Very good info so far. Walnut is very difficult to tap well. It chips out as you describe. While categorized as a hardwood, it is actually quite soft. Sometimes wax can help or even some CA glue to solidify the wood in the hole to help while tapping.
Tapping threads in wood is not the easiest thing in the turning world. I use a point in the tailstock to help guide the tap in straight. There are devices called tap followers (I think) that can help also. Availble from Enco, MSC, etc. With my blank mounted in a chuck, I brace the cross bar of the tap handle against the tool rest, turn the spindle in the normal rotation by hand and at the same time advance the tail center by hand a little. As John said, you need to back the tap out a little every so often just like when tapping metals. A new, sharp tap can make a big difference.
Hard to describe in words but it works well. I should figure out how to do videos someday.
If you are blowing out the threads during the turning process;
Slow down, and also sharpen the tools. Bring up the live center during the rough out stage, and partially through the turning. Leave a little nub on the wood as long as possible, then turn that off and finish sand. If it is still trouble, I suppose you could use a brass insert in the walnut that has the appropriate internal threads. I hate installing those inserts because they can mess up the wood getting started. A large countersink can reduce that tear out, and you can start with an oversize blank, and trim it after you install the insert.
I've had good luck threading walnut bottle stoppers using a 21/64" drill bit. However, your 11/32" (22/64") should work.
What you Must do, when starting the tap, is apply pressure to help it advance into the hole. Simply turning the tap and depending on it to screw itself into the hole will not work, not for me at least. Once the tap has engaged several threads, it will then advance on its own.
Also, you must keep the tap lined up properly. If you let it wiggle around, you will break the threads as they are formed. The critical phase is when you are first starting the tap into the hole.
Advance the tap with a back-and-forth motion. That is, go forward then back up a little. Keep the tap loose in the hole.
After drilling the whole, I flood the hole with thin CA by filling the hole a little less than half full and then holding the blank in a near horizontal orientation while rotating the blank slowly to allow the CA to coat the sides of the hole. After a few rotations, I dump any remaining CA into the next blank and repeat the process. I allow the CA to cure without using accelerator. It might take more than five minutes for the CA to cure, so be patient. If I'm prepping several blanks, by the time I'm through with the last one, the first is usually ready to turn.
If I'm using the Ruth Niles mandrel (which is almost always the case), I simply twist the blank onto the mandrel and turn. If I'm using another mandrel, I use a hand tap to cut the threads. After cutting threads all the way to the bottom of the hole (turning a full turn, backing up half a turn, turning a full turn, etc.), I reinforce the newly cut threads with another application of CA. After the CA has cured, I then clean the threads with the tap and mount the blank onto the mandrel.
After the bottle stopper has been turned, I use epoxy to mount the wood stopper top onto the metal stopper bottom. Others use medium CA. Still others do not use any glue at all. I prefer gluing the parts together because wooden threads, no matter how well cut, will not stand up to repeated use -- particularly when the mating thread is metal.
Thanks everybody for the advise. To clarify, I locked the chuck and hand tapped the piece on the lathe.
I think I'll use a drill press to bore the hole (after I ensure eveything is cut at 90 degrees) and try mounting directly on the mandrel without using the tap. Worst case, i'll use CA in the bored hole prior to tapping and see if that firms things up. I was hoping to avoid using the glue as I'm doing a bunch of these. FWIW, I bought the taps from the same woodturning catalog I bought the stoppers from, so they should be the right (coarse) thread. I should have made a few prior to agreeing to make a bunch of these as christmas gifts. and on that note...
Strange I would never had thought of threading the wood
I just drill a hole slightly under size drop in some Pva and wind in the thread (I have already put the thread in the stopper so use the stopper as a handle to wind in '
To me they are bash bash get the cash so time is of the essence drill a hole screw in out the door
I think no matter how accurate your drill press is, the stopper won't sit squarely on the blank when finished. When I make stoppers, I mount the blank in the chuck,true up the end, make a divot to center the drill, and drill with the tailstock. If the wood is hard, put the tap in the tailstock chuck, keep pressure on the tap with the handwheel, and turn the blank by hand reversing every so often. Everything is now dead nuts. To turn, I mount one of Ruth's threaded mandrels, spin on the completed blank, and turn. I true up the end, drill and tap if necessary before the stopper is turned...much easier than doing it later.
I use the same method as Keith and hedge with a little CA in the hole before threading and after threading like David ( only not quite so much CA). I also provide a bit of a recess for the shoulder of the hardware to sit into. Epoxy is my choice once the stopper is turned and finished to secure it to the plug. Haven't had any complaints or returns so far. I only have experience with Ruth's stoppers as I've not see better.
Are you "blowing out the threads" while trying to start the tap, with the last turn, or something elsel?
I simply filed V grooves in a hex bolt the right size, mounted it in a wood disc and screwed that to a faceplate. I thread the blank as I screw it onto the bolt, then turn in place. Didn't have a problem with the two mahogany and two walnut toppers I made. Beginner's luck.
I first mount in a chuck a square blank long enough to make two or three stoppers, bring up a 5/16 short bit (screw-machine or stub length) in the tail stock, and drill a appropriate depth hole. I then swap out the chuck for a 60-degree live-center, bring it up to the hole, round the block up to the chuck, part off the first blank, take it out and toss it in a box. When I have twenty or so - actually when I get tired of swapping and drilling - I take each block in one hand, a tap in the other and tap the hole. I don't tap on the lathe as I find it easier to tap with a standard T-wrench by hand. I follow Doc's process of being sure to start straight and provide some pressure at the start to get the threading going. No CA, nothing fancy, just sit down and tap a bunch of them.
When I have twenty or so blanks rounded (except for the still square section that was in the chuck on every third or so blank) and tapped, I start turning stoppers. I mount them on a threaded mandrel and, create a very shallow recess on the end with the hole with a 1/16" parting tool made from an old commercial hacksaw blade. Be careful to not hit the mandrel too hard, you can trim off the last 1/32 or so by hand later. Sometimes I use the tail stock (with a cup center to not introduce a hole), and sometimes not and I really can't tell you why I do or don't, it just feels fight for some pieces and not necessary for others. When I finish turning each one; putting on a coat of finish (I use my own concoction of walnut oil, bee's wax,and carnauba similar stuff Mike Mahoney provides), I unscrew it from the mandrel, put a couple of drops of Titebond II in the hole, screw in a stopper, tightening it with a good sized pair of pliers with well padded jaws and some elbow grease and set it in a drying rack made of a piece of plywood with holes through it and four wood screw legs. I then run the whole mess through the Beall buffing set, skipping the aluminum oxide if the wood is particularly dark and I don't want to outline the grain pattern.
I have not had one come apart, I have only blown out a couple of sets of threads from hundreds of stoppers, and they seem to hold up well with time.
For production purposes, starting with the square stock, they take me about 15 minutes actual labor once you divide out the time in each step (plus some drying time after finish and before buffing).
This is far more information than was asked for, but perhaps it will be helpful.