Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Bandsaws

Posts

Re: Bandsaws

#2

Re: Bandsaws

Ralph Lindberg

I have it's little brother; the smallest in that series, the 14inch 2HP I am very happy with it and feel that there is no way you would think this one is underpowered.

Re: Bandsaws

#3

Unless you're feeding big tree ....

JamieDonaldson

...sections to a big lathe, an 18" bandsaw with at least 2+hp(220 v) should handle most blank prep needs. I have played with a Laguna 14 SUV saw at Woodcraft that is a power monster, a 3 hp Leeson motor, and a reasonable price about $600 less than the saw you mention.

Re: Bandsaws

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bandsaws

Keith Tompkins

Dale, I have used one....it's a monster saw. For the money, I was impressed. My personal dream bandsaw is a 20" General.

Re: Bandsaws

#5

Harry Robinette

Re: Bandsaws

Harry Robinette

I have the 18" Rikon 2.5 hp and it takes everything I've thrown at it. I cut 25" bowl blanks with a 1/2" 3tpi

and have no problems. What is it your cutting.

Re: Bandsaws

#6

Re: Bandsaws

Josh Bowman

Dale,

To muddy the waters more, I have the laguna 14 SUV. It has cut easily at capacity. Only 2 things I don't like about it. The blades are an odd size at 125" and after talking with the sale department, I feel like I've dealt with some of those as seen of TV sales people. Other than that, it's built simply and has great precision for cuts, if you need it. I mainly use it for bowl blanks and I have never ever choked it down. When the Leeson motor starts, it sounds like industrial equipment cranking up! I've cut some 20 year old walnut tree trunks into boards for a friend and it never offered to slow down.

Good luck with your decision.

Re: Bandsaws

#7

Re: Bandsaws *LINK*

John Lucas

I have a 14" Delta with riser block and it has cut everything I've wanted. I would like more throat depth on occasion and better dust collection but I've easily cut the full 12" deep with a cheap 1/2" 3TPI blade with no problems.

However if we are going to dream this is the saw I would like. Saw it at the Atlanta woodworking show and it is extremely well made.


http://www.powermatic.com/Products.aspx?Part=1791800&cat=332112

Re: Bandsaws

#8

Don Leydens

Re: Bandsaws

Don Leydens

Hi Dale! I have the Grizzly 17" (2 hp). Love it. The only hassle I've found is changing the bottom guides and such when I have to put on a new blade. They're a bit tricky to get to with Allen wrenches. Same size blade changing is a breeze. I've cut tons of log pieces into blanks and she's still running perfectly. Very nice saw. Good luck, that big boy should really do the job!

Re: Bandsaws

#9

Re: Bandsaws

Dale Bonertz

Thanks for the responses folks. Harry asked what I use the saw for and it is to cut bowl blanks from 12" to 20" and anywhere from 5" deep to 10" deep. I have been avoiding using my saw because every since I purchased it it would bog down and even stop altogether (so it is like brand new - anyone want to buy it). So I have been cutting rounds at my buddies place (where we keep the logs) and his saw is old and now having major problems. Mine is 1 1/2hp so maybe I am swinging the pendulum to far with looking at a 5hp but I get frustrated when the equipment doesn't work as hard as I do. :) John my pocket book keeps me from dreaming but I am going to replace this piece of #### so I want to make sure I get a saw that will do what I want it to do. I cut about 20 to 40 rounds on most Saturdays and I need a hard working tool. I am less interested in accuracy since rounding bowl blanks I only need it to be within 1/4" accuracy - most any saw will meet that criteria. :) I need power to plow through the material and a bed big enough so I don't have to fight the blanks. Thanks for your input.

Re: Bandsaws

#10

Re: Bandsaws

robo hippy

From what I have seen of bandsaws (I have a Laguna 16HD, 16 inch cutting height, 4.5 hp motor) they really aren't designed for cutting bowl blanks, mostly for resawing. The tables are too small, mostly on the outfeed end, and the side away from the blade. This means you have to make what you need. I haven't seen a band saw yet that had add on tables as an accessory or standard. I do like mine for cutting out bowl blanks, and we seldom need more than 16 inch height as those bowls are more of a specialty market. With the 1 1/4 inch blades I use (Lennox bimetal Diemaster) it cuts almost as fast as a chain saw, but is way more accurate. You get a slab with parallel sides, so when you cut the round, you don't have to worry about your blade binding. This is a huge time saver when turning as you can start turning at a higher speed, and you have less roughing to do before you get the blank balanced, and turn the speed up. I do love the ceramic blade guides on the Laguna. Far superior to roller bearings, especially on the wider resawing blades.

I have never seen a dust port/collection set up on a bandsaw that works for what we do as woodturners. They might work okay for furniture wood, but not for green wood. They clog up in the bottom, and the ports will not pull in the wet wood. I may have to design and build my own some day......

For the blades, most larger cities have places that will custom make blades for you. There are also several other companies where you can order blades made to your specs. Ellis is one. I am lucky to have a Lennox dealer here in town.

robo hippy

Re: Bandsaws

#11

Re: Bandsaws

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Robo but that is more than I care to spend on one. I also am concerned with Laguna's customer service. I know they have a good bandsaw reputation but I know to many people that have had to many problems with the after sales service. I know of one as we speak who burned up a 3hp and 5hp motor and is having a tough time with them.

For the rest of you, the buddy that I alluded to in my earlier post has a grizzly bandsaw and has used it hard for about twenty years. It is a 3hp and has done a great job until lately - it needs a major overhaul. I was looking at the grizzly web site and the 21" 3hp (20amp) is the same price as the 21" 5hp (30amp). It makes sense to purchase the 5hp over the 3hp in my opinion if they are the same money. Is there something that I am missing in that train of thought.

Thanks again,

Dale

Re: Bandsaws

#12

Re: Bandsaws

robo hippy

Agreed that Laguna service is poor. I have had mine for a while. I have always been wary of the Grizzly tools. Their 'professional/industrial' grade machines are fine, but the lower end ones leave a lot to be desired. Woodcraft is now carrying the Laguna saws, and that might help with their customer service.

robo hippy

Re: Bandsaws

#13

Re: Bandsaws *LINK*

Michael Mocho

Hi Dale,

I own a 21” Grizzley bandsaw, and it has been great. I’ve used it mostly for resawing very hard woods for furniture and instruments, but have also cut lots of both green and dry bowl blanks using a 1/2” x 3tpi blade - 165” long.

Like all saws, it requires proper adjustment and maintenance, but although it isn’t as heavy-duty as an older machine like a Tannewitz or a Northfield, it was certainly worth what I paid for it (used). the saw frame may be a little less riid under heavy tensions, but so for it has cut steady. I have the 3 HP motor, and although it dims the lights when starting, I have never bogged it down.

Sooner or later it will need new guide bearings- get replacements from your local bearing house or online- specify rubber rather then metal seals- they hold up to the dust a bit better.

Good luck!


http://www.mmocho.com

Re: Bandsaws

#14

Re: Bandsaws

Ralph Lindberg

Grizzly

I own, well, several Griz tools. I can say that my 20+ year-old TS is not as good as today's Griz TS.

My BS is top notch

I also have a lot of faith in the dust collection gear I have. I have had zero issues getting parts (I do my own repairs). Their customer service has been excellent.

That being said, I have not seen a Griz lathe I would love. I (and some others) got on the owner really firmly here a few years ago (he was active on another forum) about some of the design choices they had been making on Lathes. Must have done some good as there were changes. Head-stocks starting changing to standard sizes, speeds changed to ones people would actually need and use.

For me, with the headquarters for Griz being "close", I would never hesitate to urge people to buy their tools. A few years ago I was in their main showroom, looking at a HEPA airfilter they had, there was a question on the price due to a sale flyer they had, that appeared to contradict the posted price, the clerk called "up-stairs" to learn what the price was, and the owner came down and straighten the issues out, and I took home the HEPA filter.

Part of Griz tools are often reasonable choices, is the owner is also a woodworker.

Re: Bandsaws

#15

Re: Bandsaws

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Michael, that is good to hear. I spoke with another friend yesterday and he has the same saw that you have. He has only had it a couple of months and is very pleased with it. It was good to hear from someone who owned it for awhile. Thanks to all who have responded it has helped my decision. Now to have patience and wait for a sale or free shipping.