Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Turning a cracked bowl

Posts

Turning a cracked bowl

#1

Turning a cracked bowl

Pete in Holland, MI

First off.......I know it's risky turning a cracked bowl. Nuff said. Guards/shields will be used.

But......I have seen several bowls on this site with significant cracks turned and finished. I have several 8-12" diameter rough turned & dried bowls with fantastic grain that cracked during the trying process, but want to finish turn them, then decoratively lace/wire the cracks together.

Thinking several layers of nylon fiber packing tape. This will work on the ID, but what about turning the OD?

Seeking your wisdom & experience

Pete

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#2

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

Philip Duffy

Pete. Suggest you use a filler material, ie, epoxy with ground stones, for example, to fill the cracks BEFORE you start turning. It goes without saying that the wood is not going to be stable (in the same plane) if it is not in one solid piece. You cannot turn wood that is unstable without a severe risk of hurting yourself - - -I speak from experience. As the wood spins and you apply force with the gouges, it will move. If you are lucky it will keep together. If not so lucky, it will explode. Cracks that occur in green wood should be filled in the same manner before turning to a finished form. Good luck and be careful! Philip

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#3

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

John Lucas

I know it's hard to toss a piece. Lord knows I've worked on some that were dangerous. The trick is to simply turn more. I put the pieces up on a shelf figuring I'll fix them some day. Now I've turned enough new bowls that I'm not attached to the others anymore so they will eventually get tossed. Also my turning and drying skills have improved so I simply don't have as many cracked.

Now what I would do to turn the outside is do just a little at a time. The strapping tape works well. If your concerned about the finish apply blue painters tape first and then the strapping tape over it. If you use just strapping tape mineral spirits will remove the residue easily.

Wrap the bowl and turn the first few inches. Then put the tape there and work your way down another inch or so. Then tape this up and move down, etc. Wrap the tape clockwise so if air gets under a loose end it won't rapidly unwind (don't ask how I know that).

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#4

Steven Antonucci

Those are firewood.

steven antonucci

Unless you can fill the entire crack with something like epoxy, I wouldn't waste time. If you were trying to fill it with epoxy, I would make a cardboard backer and clamp it to the interior of the bowl, and then fill the crack to overflowing. You can always turn away the overflow.

Steve

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#5

Re: Those are firewood.

Roger

Check out www.fredwilliamson.com specifically the globes section. He uses super glue and lots of packaging tape to get them thin and safe.

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#6

Firewood, or.....

Dick Coers

take a chance with your life or skull fractures. Your choice. Read Lynne Yamaguchi's blog http://www.lynneyamaguchi.com/wordpress/

or about Brian McEvoy having a platter blow up, or (can't remember her name) who died at the lathe last year. Sure the grain might be pretty, but not worth it!

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#7

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

Pete in Holland, MI

All right all right.

Off to the firewood pile they go. First, I have to study them to figure out why they cracked in the first place.

Thanks !

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#8

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

robo hippy

It can be done, but.........

I am guessing that you are twice turning these as in turned green, they cracked, and now you are going to turn them again to round them out. First, I would make sure there is enough wood to turn away and still have some thing left. Mounting on the lathe and spinning by hand, or less than 100 rpm will let you know that.

Second step would be to fill the crack with whatever. If you try to turn it cracked, the wood will move around the crack as you turn, and it will look pretty ugly, though nothing that 80 grit can't take out, but you would still have to re sand it. When filling the crack, remember that almost any epoxy/glue/filler will shrink as it cures and dries. So, if it is fairly deep, like 1/4 inch or more, it may have to be layered in to prevent honey combing. I would let it cure for days, not 24 hours, or try using CA glue and accelerator and think it is cured.

If it is already close to final thickness, and you can't return it, I would sand it out most of the way, then fill, then sand again, or do the lacing method.

Most of the time, this type of piece never gets turned by me, and if I do have one that cracks, I toss it. Just not worth all the extra time. Exception: Oh, we used to swing in that tree when we were kids......

robo hippy

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#9

Contact Bucks Turners

Craig Daymon

Norris White use to turn somewhat large hollowforms from American Chestnut. Most of these vessels were from wood with cracks. Norris would stitch up the cracks with boot lace. (Additionally impressive in that he was stitching by coming in through usually about a 1" hole.) Norris lived to 87 and did not die while turning, though that may well have been the way he wanted to go, so it can be done safely. Precautions should be taken.

Here's a link to the "Step Up" document from the AAW that features Norris' "Tools of the Trade" hats, bat, balls, glove and catcher's mit on the cover/first page.

http://www.woodturner.org/gallery/aaw_exhibits/StepUp.pdf

If you contact someone at the Bucks Turners, they may be able to pass along any tips on how Norris repeatedly accomplished this. I would suggest, Mike Kehs.

http://www.bucksturners.com/

There is an inherent danger in woodturning. Hopefully, being able to see some of those dangers before we begin will make us more alert and cautious. If you think you can safely turn it, I'd say go for it.

-Craig

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#11

Amen

Bill Howatt

You've got that right.

Besides, I don't think I've ever seen a "patched" bowl with clever embellishments that I liked anyway. Probably because I know it is a patched bowl.

It just isn't worth it.

Some famous turner said, "life is too short to turn crappy wood", well I'll paraphrase and say "life is to dear to turn dangerous wood"!

Bill

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Those are firewood.

Brad Vietje

Steve is right, as usual!

Pete -- if you look back about 3 - 4 days you'll see a discussion of epoxy for filling cracks. If you would like to complete these as bowls, I would get some West System 105 resin and 206 hardener. Mix it for a thin viscosity so it will soak into the wood fibers. Making a thicker batch might be good for second or third applications.

If done right, the epoxy is far stronger than the wood, and bonds to in very well. You may need to spend $40 or so the get the stuff you need, but it can work. However, for a lot less money you can get a copy of "turning Green Wood, by Michael O'Donnell, and solve the basic problem of your rough-turned bowls cracking in the first place.

I'll also agree with the firewood crowd, or add wood sculpture as another option. I like to turn multiple rough-outs when I get some nice green wood, and I lost a number of them when I was green. I also experimented with denatured alcohol ("DNA"), soaking in a soapy solution, boiling, microwaving, etc... All these methods have merit, but mostly as a time-saving device (boiling excepted where extreme curl is involved -- it can be essential for some highly figured woods).

Nowadays I take a little precaution and care with my rough-tuned bowls (orientation, shape, thickness, beveling sharp edges, sometimes waxing end grain, and especially where and how they are dried...) and I'll bet I don't lose more than 1% - 2% to checks and cracking. Since I tend to push the limits on natural edge vases and hollow forms turned right on the pith, I may lose 5% of those, but I can't think of a single bowl blank rendered unusable cracks in over 10 years, and I'll happily give Mick O'Donnell the credit.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Turning a cracked bowl

#13

WAIT!  TRADE W/ME FOR PRESTO LOGS?

mjonesrdg

Pack those bowls in a box and send 'em to ME! I'll pay the shipping...AND, I will send an equal weight back in genuine Presto Logs! But WAIT! Act now and I'll double my offer and I will send DOUBLE the weight in Presto logs for your burning enjoyment! POSTAGE PAID!

Burning pretty wood is BAD KARMA. I'll take your bowls and plunk 'em into a bucket of water for a couple of days and when the cracks swell up I'll glue 'em up.

Then I'll take a bit of nylon twine, put the 'ol truckers hitch on it and squeeze the rim up tight. and I'll tighten that squeeze up a few times as the bowl shrinks. In about two weeks (allowing for the winter weather) they be ready to turn to finish.

PrestoLogs for fantastic figured wood?.........Anyone?