Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Oil finish question?

Posts

Oil finish question?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Oil finish question?

steven antonucci

First, aside from the oil turning into a gelatinous mess (curing), can oil (specifically Watco, but generally- any?) go bad?

I put a coat of Watco on a vessel I made last night. The vessel had been sprayed with some kind of varnish that I used as a sanding sealer. It was complete dry, and then sanded through flush to the surface. I put a thin coat of Watco over it, and it was still tacky this AM.

I don't use oil all that often, so am I just not waiting long enough, or is the oil bad?

Steve

Re: Oil finish question?

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Oil finish question?

Dick Hines

An oil finish needs to soak into the wood. The sanding sealer kept it form doing so. Next time just use the oil or sand the sanding sealer down to the bare wood.

Re: Oil finish question?

#3

Re: Oil finish question?

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Take a look at Watco Danish Oil ingredients; 60% mineral spirits, 1% aromatic petroleum distillates, raw linseed oil, vegetable oil, and resin. Yes, product deteriorates with age and exposure to air. Not sure that is only problem you have. Suspect solvent ingredients softening varnish already applied.

Would have same problem if applied Watco first and did not let it dry thouroghly before applying varnish.

Re: Oil finish question?

#4

Re: Oil finish question?

waltben

Think it was Wood Magazine that did a review & comparison of various oil finishes years ago. Back then I was using Minwax antique oil. They wrote that there was only two they'd classify as a wiping varnish or antique oil (there's no standard for what it's supposed to be), and Minwax was one of them. Watco's antique oil was the other, but they also listed what was in many of the common Danish oils (again, no real standard for what's in them). I don't recall what they said about Danish oils, but I know that the result of the entire article was my switching to tung oil as it's waterproof and food safe when cured.

Re: Oil finish question?

#5

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Oil finish question?

Lyle Jamieson

Steve,

Ive been using Watco Danish for 40 +years. I have used it from an old can that has started to thicken with age with no problems on bare wood. It is a true wiping varnish so it takes a long time to cure...like a week, for the first coat. Once the first coat cures down weep in the fibers the next coatings can be in frequent intervals a day or two apart. The can says "ready to use in 8-10 hours". I would never buff or recoat that fast. The second coat will soften the first coat and it will take a month to cure deep into the wood.

Re: Oil finish question?

#6

Re: Temperature?

Steve Criscenzo

Steve

I have found that I sometimes have problems when my shop temperature gets cool. I have also found that I can sometimes get a sticky oil finish to set by placing it near a heater (or in the summer I just set it on the deck in the sun). I have saved many a finish by applying gentle heat.

Good luck

Steve

Re: Oil finish question?

#7

Did you wipe off the excess?

Don Orr

If you don't, it will stay tacky for a VERY long time. It build very slowly especially over a sealer. As Lyle said, it is it's own sealer but needs to cure a while before a second coat.

Danish Oil basics:

Apply liberally

Allow to soak in

Apply more

Allow to soak in again

Wipe off any excess

Allow to cure in a warm area

Dispose of oily rags properly

Add as many coats as desired in above fashion.

HTH

Re: Oil finish question?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Monday, 3:30 PM and still mildly tacky

steven antonucci

reminds me why I don't use oil finishes all that often... ugh!

Steve