Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Power carver suggestions?

Posts

Power carver suggestions?

#1

Alan Zenreich

Power carver suggestions?

Alan Zenreich

I am looking to add a reciprocating carver to our little tool arsenal (likely used most by Lauren).

So far, the current choices are a standalone carver like the Automach, or a carver hand piece for our Foredom flex shaft tool.

Each has its own benefits. If price were no object, which would you choose, and why?

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#2

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Donna Banfield

Alan, price being no object then Automach is your choice. It is well made, will hold up for a long time and will not heat up in your hand as you use it.

I started power carving several years with the WeCheer. This is a knock off of that very popular but no longer available Ryobi carver. It held the reciprocating blades and rotary burrs in the hand-held machine, but also had the flex shaft with separate handpieces that did both - reciprocate and rotary carving. This was fine if you were only going to do very occasional carving - and I do mean occasional - a few times a year, bit less than an hour or so. I burned the WeCheer up carving a Ron Fleming-type piece, 11" high, 6-7" across at the widest part. I was carving 4-5 hours a day for about 3 weeks. Not non-stop, because it got hot, very fast. Many breaks to let the machine cool down. It didn't matter if I was holding the machine, or using the flexible shaft attachment and handpiece. Too hot to hold, and I was wearing leather gloves.

Any type of system that has the cable or flex shaft will create heat, and transmit that to your hand. Another disadvantage is the cable cannot have much of a bend to it. It works best when that cable is straight, with very little bend or curve. Start to bend it, and it will heat up faster. If you're in the middle of carving, and you're focusing on what you're carving, you may not be paying attention to the kink that you're starting to put in that flexible shaft ---until it's too late.

I replaced that machine with two separate dedicated systems; the Automach for the reciprocating carving, and the NSK Evolution, an electric micromotor carver, that runs at 40,000 rpm. Neither one was cheap, but like most top quality tools, you only cry once - when you pay for it, and not every time you use it.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#3

What Donna said.


Re: Power carver suggestions?

#4

Re: Power carver suggestions?

John Lucas

I asked this question a while back because I was looking at the Foredom. Hands down the response was to go with the Automac. I like using the Foredom for rotary carving but the cable does get in the way sometimes. I have the Ryobi which is why I haven't jumped on the Automac. So far it has done what I need but it does have a lot more vibration than the Automac. Of course you can't by it anymore. Most people who responded to my question did not think the Foredom reciprocating handle was very good. Of course there's a huge difference in price.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: What Donna said.

Alan Zenreich

Looks like it will be the Automach.

I wonder just how many husbands can buy tools as holiday presents for their brides...

Lauren is looking forward to this one.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#6

Re: Alan, if this is any help...

Donna Banfield

My husband bought me my lathe and turning tools for Christmas in 2001. It was a surprise. I have no background in woodworking or turning before that. I just was fascinated by the demonstrators under the Guild of NH Woodworkers tent at the annual League of NH Craftsmen Fair that we attended for many years.

Since that first gift/surprise, anything woodturning or carving is expected. Let's see, in the past years, it was a Stihl chain saw, the outboard and riser block for the Oneway 2436, (that was the 25th anniversary gift), and a number of smaller things - tools, burrs, etc. Now I just give the catalogue/web page/hyperlink to anyone inquiring about gifts. Makes it easy, and I'm thrilled!

The point is, if you're on same page, woodworking/woodturning, how can you go wrong?

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#7

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Mike Foster

I have not tried the Automach, but have a Ryobi. I also have a Weecheer reciprocating handpiece which I like for a couple of reasons. The Ryobi is a rather large tool to hold in your hand if you are using it for more detailed carving. I took a class with Jacques Vessery last summer and we tried many variations of reciprocating carvers. Jacques likes the Weecheer for the same reasons I do. It is a smaller hand piece and the motor can be set at the speed you want and you don't have to try to keep the speed constant with the pedal like you do if using a Foredom. Like Donna said, you want to keep the cable straight as you can. I have not had the heating problems, but never used mine a constantly as what Donna mentioned.

I have numerous carving machines including dental air driven drills and handpieces, a unit similar to the NSK (made for the dental world), belt driven old style dental hand piece, Foredom, Weecheer. I use them all, and will have them all set up so I can put a handpiece down and grab another with a different bur. I just invested in a new handpiece for the Foredom, which was a really good move. I found a Swiss made handpiece with a quick chuck that accepts 1/8" bits at a jeweler supplier. I was just out using it for the first time tonight, and can say it was worth the money. (like Donna said, better tools are usually more expensive, and this hand piece was more like 200, compared with some that Foredom sells for 60 or so but they don't accept 1/8" burs).

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#8

Bob Moffett

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Bob Moffett

I use an Arbortec Reciprocating Carver. I was introduced to it by Emanuel Samuels. I have also used the Automach and the Arbortec is much more powerful It will move a lot of wood in a hurry or you can do detail carving with it. It is an agressive tool and needs to be held with two hands but I like it much better than the Automach. It has a variety of chisels that can be used with it. It is loud but not as loud as the Automach. I also have a Proxxon power carver but it is not nearly as stong ast the Arbortec. It is designed more for lighter, detailed carving. I would buy onethe Arbortec again.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#9

Re: Alan, if this is any help...

John Lucas

My friend Kim Winkle who will have her candlesticks on the cover of the next American Woodturner expects woodworking gifts from her husband every christmas. Of course her Husband Graham Campbell is the wood instructor at the Appalachian Center for Crafts and of course I'm sure he gets wood working tools also.

Kim was kidding me that I need to find a wife who loves woodworking so "we" can get more toys each Christmas.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#10

Alan Zenreich

Re: Alan, if this is any help...

Alan Zenreich

John,

So many turners I know have to sneak new tools into the house so their brides don't see them (or the invoices)

In my home, Lauren pays all the bills, so there's no sneaking anything in.

Fortunately, she likes tools (especially when her name is engraved on them).

So for HER to suggest that I tool I causually mentioned would be a good gift for us both, is a fine fine thing.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#11

Betty Scarpino

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Betty Scarpino

I have an Automach that I use frequently. It's great! I also have and use an Arbortech reciprocating carver. They're great, too, but for a different application, usually larger work where lots of wood needs to be removed quickly.

I don't always want to remove wood quickly. Remove too much and the curve changes to something undesirable. Even though the Automach doesn't remove as much wood as quickly as the Arbortech, it's still a powerful, professional-quality tool. I'd go with the Automach, which you've already decided anyway. Just reinforcing your decision.

Keep in mind, though, that the Automach needs to be kept away from sawdust (oddly enough) and steel-wool shavings. If those get into the housing, it can short-circuit the tool and it dies (learned that the hard way ....). Smokey Mountain Woodcarvers company repairs them.

Also, keep the carving head area greased regularly.

Have fun, I'm sure you'll enjoy the Automach!

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#12

Alan Zenreich

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Alan Zenreich

The Automach arrived today... nice toy, errrr, tool.

It appears to be well made, and has very smooth handling.

I have a few roughed out bowls that might make good practice pieces.

Re: Power carver suggestions?

#13

Bob Moffett

Re: Power carver suggestions?

Bob Moffett

You will enjoy that tool. It is loud so it would be a good idea to wear some hearing protection of some sort.