Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

HELP in choosing a hollowing system

Posts

HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#1

HELP in choosing a hollowing system

Jerry Lear

I am new to hollowing but not to turning & I have a Vicmarc 300 w/21" between center. I would like to buy a hollowing system that would allow me to grow with it & not have to worry about buying another one in the future. I have done some research & the ones that stand out to me are Kobra, Monster, Gizmo, and the new Carter.

I know the Carter has about a 7" depth capacity which may be limiting. I looked on U-tube at the Cobra demonstation & it seems to be an extremely well-built machine but I can find very little information about it. I emailed the two fellows who own the company but have not received a reply, as of yet. As far as Monster goes, I can not find any video except for the Monster Mini, which I do not want. The Gizo seems well built but very limited information available.

Given the fact that I have a Vicmarc with a relatively small bed & is also set-up about 18" from the wall, what would you all recommend as a hollower? As I said, I would like to have one that I could grow with & I would like to buy only one as opposed to regretting the first buy.

Appreciate any help. Thanks to all of you.

Jerry

PS - I understand Cobra has a long waiting period. Does anyone know how long?

Back to top

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#2

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

David Walser

Any of the articulated arm systems, with the possible exception of the Elbo Tool, should work well for you. So, too, would one of the captured bar systems that use a rear rest -- as long as you are willing to build a stand to hold the rear rest. (The problem with the Elbo Tool is that it uses the tail stock for support. Given your short bed, there's not much room left for your blank.)

I, too, have a short bed lathe and have the Monster articulated arm. It works very well and allows for a fairly long blank to fit on the lathe. The depth you can hollow is limited by the thickness of the bar. The Monster will accept large diameter bars -- as long as the end of the bar is machined to fit within the Monster's receiver. The monster is a quality tool and will NOT be the limiting factor on your hollowing. I recommend it without reservation.

Kobra is a little more compact than the Monster and other articulated arm tools. It, too, is a quality tool and would serve you well. I’ve not seen the new Gizmo in person, but it looks very interesting. Since you own a Vicmark lathe, you might want to consider Vicmark’s articulated arm tool. Lots of options. All would serve you well.

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#3

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system *LINK*

Fred Holder

I have several hollowing systems, but I prefer the Vermec Easy Hollowing system which is available from Woodworkers's Emporium in Las Vegas. I've had this system for several years. It does not require a long bed lathe. It is a stabalized boring bar that pops into the Tool Rest Base. I've found it very easy to use and is good for short bed lathes. Vermec is an Australian manufacturer, close relation to Vicmarc. You can see a couple of pictures of in on Woodworkers's Emporium's web site.


http://www.woodworkersemporium.com

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#4

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

dick gerard

Give me a call or email and I will put ypu in touch with Jerry Arnold and/or Al Crandall (co-owners and inventors of trhe Kobra system). Precision engineered to last a life time. Difference between it and all the others is difference between Rolls Royce and and anything else ... and of course price. Kobra is at the high end of the price chart, but you can put it in your will for your children and grandchildren.

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#5

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

Dick Coers

One of the biggest difference between the uses of captured and articulated is how easily you can get through a small entrance hole. The captured will have to be relocated to reach a large undercut through a small hole, then moved back to reach deeply. The articulated snakes right in, and go to the bottom. To me, the Carter will be very limiting for undercuts. I have a Jamieson captured and a homemade articulated. Right now I am always using the articulated.

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#6

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

Jerry Lear

Hi Dick, if you could give the contact info I would grateful. Thanks, Jerry

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#7

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

dick gerard

Call Al Crandall at 317-485-5129

Jerry Arnold 765623-4672

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#8

Hollowing Systems Compendium *LINK*

charlie belden

Not sure if this is up to date, but it covers the hollowing systems that were around three or so years ago when I was looking.


Hollowing Systems Compendium

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#9

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

Ralph Watts

Jerry,

Most of the systems you mentioned will work OK. However, having tried most of them, the Kobra is, IMO, the best of the bunch. It is rock solid, construction is first rate, the laser guide is very stable, and service from Al and Jerry is outstanding. Plus, the base for the Kobra can be off-set from the end of your lathe so you have a little more operating room between the pivot point and your work. It is easy to mount even though picking it up is like grabbing a barbell where everything rotates. The Kobra is the best purchases that I have made for a lathe accessorie. Best regards, Ralph

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#10

Kobra!!

Jorge

I got mine long ago and love it... Most of my work is on the bigger size.

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#11

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system *LINK*

Josh Bowman

I've got this one and love it.


Monster

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system

#12

Joe Fleming

Re: HELP in choosing a hollowing system - LONG

Joe Fleming

Jerry,

I do not have any vested interest in any hollowing system. Having said that, nobody asked the important questions before recommending hollowing systems.

What size(s) and shape(s) do you want to hollow?

I have the following hollowing tools/systems. I have used them all a fair amount and I have my favorites. Here is the run-down:

For 2-3" hollow forms like ornaments, I have Packards mini hollowers and Kelton mini hollowers. I like the Packards. Keltons are too flexible. These are either handled or I use a handle. No captured systems.

For 3" to 6" hollows, which I tend to turn roundish, I have the 1/2" Kelton small, homemade 3/8" Ellsworth style, Jordan 3/8", Jordan 1/2", Stinger system, Sorby 3/8". Sorby tool is bad. The shape of the hook is wrong. I love the Keltons and Jordans. All handled tools.

For 5" to 10" hollows, I have 1/2" homemade Ellsworth style, 1/2" Jordans, 1/2" Kelton small, Don Derry captured system. Mike Jackofsky 1/2" hook and straight tools, I generally use the Derry system for vessels in this range. Derry system works well on a shortbed lathe. I use it on a Stubby lathe with the bed all the way contracted with no problem. The Keltons and the Jordans are a little short for the upper range of this vessel size.

For vessels over 8" to 10", I have Exocet (not sure it is on the market anymore, Jordan 3/4", Stewart system, Scorpion system, and a 5/8" Sorby handled tool. Again, the Sorby hook shape is bad, but I use it with a broad scraper to smooth out the interior. Exocet is one of the original cutting tools. The straight tool is fast and excels at taller, thinner vessels. The hook tool is crap because the shape is bad. Takes a little practice to get the appropriate cutting angles down. Love my Jordan hollower in an armbrace. I have a homemade 3/4" straight bar to complement the Jordan and Stewart hooks.

Without going to the toolbox, there's a good chance I forgot something here, but this gives you an idea of the range of tools. The main point is that the idea that one tool will be the end-all is not realistic unless you just plan to turn one shape and size.

I'm sure there are a bunch of tool junkies in the group here. Lots of good advise. Since hollowing systems are spendy, I would not buy anything until you try them out. The first hollowing tool I ever used was a Jerry Glaser hollower. Borrowed it from a friend when I was a new turner. The tool sucked, at least for me. Saved me a couple hundred dollars, though, because I tried before I bought. I went to an American Woodworker trade show a couple of months later and they only had one turning vendor in the show. I spent the entire day there watching and trying the Exocet tool. Loved it and bought it.

As my tastes in form have developed, I have gravitated to vessels raging from 4" to 10". Some of these tools gather more dust than use because I don't turn those sizes or shapes much anymore. Select a form and size, then focus on the tools that excel in that range. Borrow, borrow, borrow, before you buy.

I live in San Diego in case that is close to you.

Joe Fleming