Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Demo Audience Input Request

Posts

Demo Audience Input Request

#1

Demo Audience Input Request

charlie belden

Having gotten videographers' and demonstrators' perspectives on the use of video to enhance a demonstration I'd like to get some Audience's perspective.

If you've been in the audience of a demonstration that was to be enhanced by the use of video

1. did the use of video actually enhanced the demonstation or detract from it?

2. was the audience display a large flat screen, or a projection screen?

3. was the projected video display quality poor, fair, good or excellent?

4. did the lighting at the demonstrator's area reduce the effectiveness of the display?

5. did you mainly watch the demonstrator and only look at the video display to see details you couldn't otherwise see - or - did you mainly watch the video display?

6. were there things the demonstator was doing that you couldn't see and the video display couldn't either?

7. if there were moveable cameras on tripods with operators, did any prevent you from seeing things you might have been able to see if the operator(s) and camera(s) weren't in the way?

8. if there was a structure around the lathe supporting cameras, lights, etc., did it obstruct your view or was it a distraction?

Anything else that you liked - or - disliked?

Re: Demo Audience Input Request

#2

Joe Fleming

Re: Demo Audience Input Request

Joe Fleming

Charlie,

Here are my comments:

1. did the use of video actually enhanced the demonstration or detract from it?

(joe) Added to it. I sit in the back and the video brought it home to me.

2. was the audience display a large flat screen, or a projection screen? Projection.

(joe) Works well, but the room needs to be darkened.

3. was the projected video display quality poor, fair, good or excellent?

(joe) Very Good

4. did the lighting at the demonstrator's area reduce the effectiveness of the display?

(joe) When trying to zoom in, the light was sometimes too bright and the image lost

5. did you mainly watch the demonstrator and only look at the video display to see details you couldn't otherwise see - or - did you mainly watch the video display?

(joe) Video

6. were there things the demonstrator was doing that you couldn't see and the video display couldn't either?

(joe) We have two cameras - one from tailstock end and one directly overhead. These are pretty good angles.

7. if there were moveable cameras on tripods with operators, did any prevent you from seeing things you might have been able to see if the operator(s) and camera(s) weren't in the way?

(joe) Camera operator stays out of the way pretty well.

8. if there was a structure around the lathe supporting cameras, lights, etc., did it obstruct your view or was it a distraction?

(joe) Camera is overhead and out of the way.

Anything else that you liked - or - disliked?

(joe) Too many camera operators try to zoom in on the cutting tip. That shot is really worthless for learning. The action is in the demonstrator's body and arm position. I MUCH prefer a camera shot that shows the tool motion and position.

(joe) Don't toggle back and forth between cameras all the time. Most operations can be covered by one angle. Switch when the operation changes.

(joe) In San Diego, our camera guys have it wired. They do a very good job of setting up and getting out of the way.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Demo Audience Input Request

#3

Re: Demo Audience Input Request

Bill Howatt

1. did the use of video actually enhanced the demonstation or detract from it?

Enhanced in most cases

2. was the audience display a large flat screen, or a projection screen?

Cameras to a computer and computer driving a projector.

3. was the projected video display quality poor, fair, good or excellent?

Very good but lighting is important.

4. did the lighting at the demonstrator's area reduce the effectiveness of the display?

At times, proper lighting is important and it will depend on the cameras, room lighting, etc

5. did you mainly watch the demonstrator and only look at the video display to see details you couldn't otherwise see - or - did you mainly watch the video display?

Depends on where I am seated. Usually watch the demonstrator but look at the display for things that can't be seen such as cutting inside a bowl.

6. were there things the demonstator was doing that you couldn't see and the video display couldn't either?

It happens and this is where the camera setup is important.

7. if there were moveable cameras on tripods with operators, did any prevent you from seeing things you might have been able to see if the operator(s) and camera(s) weren't in the way?

Not usually, cameras tend to be mounted above and away and the cameras and related holding equipment is small. Operators only move into adjust a position when necessary and are out of the way.

8. if there was a structure around the lathe supporting cameras, lights, etc., did it obstruct your view or was it a distraction?

No real strucuture, see previous answer.

Anything else that you liked - or - disliked?

Plan ahead particularly for the points that are important to your presentation. You don't want the audience shouting they can't see what you are talking about. Did I mention "Plan Ahead"?

One of the most annoying things about demos, especially for new turners is the "notice the angle the gouge flute is at" statement. Usually nobody can tell what angle the flute is at and this often is not helped by video with the light shining off the steel. I saw a great device to help with this problem - a piece of wood with a hole in it that slides over the gouge. There is a perpendicular dowel several inches long that is perpendicular to the flute so the audience can easily see where the flute is pointing by observing the dowel.