Re: Demonstrators – Your Ideal Video System?
charlie belden
I really am LISTENING - and learning. That's why I asked the question and posed it to demonstrators specifically and have gotten back lots of ideas to think about. If I asked questions about a particular suggested set up, it's because I see an issue that I have a question or two about. It's not that I feel the need to defend one method because I came up with parts of it. I asked for input - and you and others have responded.
Thank you and others for participating in this discussion.
With that out of the way . . .
The single experienced camera operator and zoomable camera mounted on a "fluid head" dollied tripod, with a long cable (and a Cable Handler) connected directly to the audience video display, and shots directed by the demonstrator who will stop turning until the camera is in position to get the shot he wants - is the Ideal set up - for an experienced demonstrator who has worked with video before and knows when the use of video will enhance the audience experience. It has fewer components, is less expensive, easier to set up and take down, is more versatile assuming good coordination between demonstrator and camera operator and doesn't require much storage space when not in use.
As you noted, not all demonstrators want to, or have the skills to, direct the camera operator. In our club's case, and I'm guessing for other clubs, the monthly meeting demonstrations are being done by club members, some doing their very first demonstration.
For the less experienced or completely inexperienced demonstrators, it would seem a good idea to have a Pre-Demonstration Orientation Meeting before the demo to familiarize the demonstrator with how to use whatever video system is to be used - to ENHANCE their demonstration. Video is an ENHANCEMENT to a LIVE demonstration, NOT a replacement for it. With the exception of situations where there's something the audience needs to see up close or can't see from their vantage point - the attention of the audience should be on the the demonstrator and what he or she is saying and doing - NOT on the video display. If the demonstrator were to say "Now if you'll turn your attention to the video display I'll show you in a closeup, how I do this . . ." it would cue the camera operator for the shot wanted and the audiences' attention to the video display.
For the example you gave on the use of a laser pointer when hollowing, it seems an overhead shot, zoomed in so the laser's red dot was clearly visible on the audience display screen, would show the entire path of the cut and the laser dot, regardless of whether it's being made near to the top or bottom of the hollow form. With a single camera, the camera operator would have to be to your right for the top cuts and have to cross behind you and be to your left when you're working on the bottom half of the hollow form.
With either system the Laser Dot Drop Off, indicating the desired wall thickness has been reached, could be seen clearly by the audience on their large video display.
Regarding the Demonstrator's Monitor
- where would you prefer to have it?
..(over the tailstock end of the lathe, up and to the left of you,
..directly in front of you?)
- how small can it be and still give you the visual feedback you need?
..(would one the size of a piece of paper or a little smaller be adequate?)
Regarding a mic and amplified sound
- your point that some (maybe most) audience members have hearing
..difficulties is something I hadn't considered - even though, thanks to power
..tool use without hearing protection, I've got a 25 percent hearing loss.
..Add THAT to the design criteria considerations.
- face shields, especially ones that also act as a respirator, present a challenge
..for wireless mics, what type of mic have you found works best for this situation?
Regarding the AAW video system used for the San Jose 2012 Symposium, we agree that it had several problems.
The cameras and display were HDMI, and that caused the Dreaded Blue Screen problem when switching from one camera to the other.
The two fixed location video cameras required someone to aim each one and manually zoom them which meant that person had to play camera operator for each camera AND Switcher of which camera's signal was going to the audience display. While the Switcher was close to one of the cameras, the other camera was at the other end of the FRAME. To change that cameras aim or to zoom it required leaving the Switcher to make the camera view change and returning to the Switcher to switch its video to the audience display.
The location of the audience display, at least for the demonstrations I attended, was too far to the side of the demonstrator. That meant you had to watch the video display OR the demonstrator but not both at the same time since they weren't both in your field of vision. Getting the audience display closer to the demonstrator. But that meant that the lighting on the demonstration area could wash out the audience displays. A black out curtain or shade could minimize that problem though.
Regarding the AAW FRAME limiting the movement range of the demonstrator, it seems there's not much need for much space around the headstock end of the lathe. There can be, as you pointed out, a need for room around the tailstock end of the lathe as well as between the lathe and the audience. My question is HOW MUCH ROOM?
To get from the turning side of the lathe to the audience side of the lathe, the demonstrator must get around one of the lathe's ends. Does it matter which end? I ask because the FRAME I've illustrated, is completely open on the tailstock end ( ie tailstockk end ______| Headstock end ). And if the front plane of the FRAME is within 2-3' of the lathe's center line, the demonstrator can stand on the audience side of the lathe without the FRAME getting in the way because it would be behind him or her.
We are in total agreement on The Goal - to get The Best Shot for the Viewer/ Audience to ENHANCE the demonstration and the audience experience of it. How that's accomplished is up for discussion, not debate. This is not a Zero Sum Game were someone must "lose" for someone to "win". And in a discussion, the more people constructively participating, the more ideas can be brought up and considered and the NEEDS vs the WANTS can be identified, along with options for meeting the NEEDS, and maybe even some of the WANTS.