With large cherry bowls--and not small ones--I often seen that when the oil dries (I use tung oil cut with mineral oil), there are visual 'flat' spots where the oil has not taken the way it should. It leaves a blotchy finish, at times. The only thing I can think of is that I've mixed in too much mineral oil--that, or is there something about cherry that I should know about?
I also would like to ask why you are using mineral oil to "dilute" the tung oil.
Tung oil (derived from seeds of a small tree related to poinsettias) is one of the natural "drying" oils, which complexes with oxygen and polymerizes to a relatively hard finish (among the hardest oil-based 'penetrating' finishes).
Mineral oil never "cures" or polymerizes, and its use when mixed with tung oil likely interferes with the polymerization of the tung oil.
The most frequently used diluting solvent for reducing the concentration of pure ("raw") tung oil is mineral spirits, typically in a 50% (1:1) dilution. This will allow deeper penetration of the oil into the wood, and when the mineral spirits (solvent) evaporates away, the tung oil can still polymerize by incorporating oxygen linkages between the molecules comprizing the oil (fatty acids).
Using this oil-oil mixture might be the reason for the aberrant behavior you are describing. (?)
The grain of cherry will oscilate back and forth. So when you cut through it, you are basically looking at a small portion of end grain. This will absorb more oil than face grain. Folks seem to constantly complain about blotchy finish on cherry, especially the ones that are trying to stain it. It's a natural characteristic, and to me, makes it the beautiful wood that it is. I would never stain cherry, so that is not a concern to me. I suspect that you will never get an even sheen with a thin oil finish. You can wet sand the oil with 400 grit and the slurry may fill it a little better, but it will take shellac, or other film finish to fill the pores.
I use a Danish type oil on all my cherry bowls without any issues. Cherry is not like Walnut where the pores need to be filled for a visually smooth finish.
I have never heard of mixing a non-drying oil with a drying oil. I agree with those who have questioned the mixture.
HI Aage, One possibility is that the heel of your tools is bruising the wood, especially on the inside of the bowls. If that's it, grind the heel away. I would not mix mineral oil with anything..yuk! One thing I do is mix pure tung oil with small amount of polyuretane; been doing that for years. Apply, let it soak in, and wipe dry.
Many years ago I did a test and ended up using 7 parts tung oil to 1 part poly. This was on furniture and I applied it with 600 grit paper. It was a long process but produced a beautiful smooth sheen after multiple coats. I played with the different dillutions by seeing what left streaks and how fast it would build. Since I was applying it with 600 grit paper and building up a sort of slurry thinner worked better. 1 to 4 might work if you apply with a cloth and then wipe it off. It's kind of forgiving so just try it on a test piece. If 1 to 4 doesn't flow out well dillute it further.
Just make it easy and use Walnut Oil. I use Cherry all the time with Mahoney's Walnut Oil and have never had a problem. Dries quick and leaves a beautiful finish.
John, I was involved in a study by Lily, who was my lacquer supplier in the early 70's. They came out with a poly-wiping oil.....I still have a small chest I finished with the stuff...looks brand new 40 years later!
The problem with cherry is that the 'straws' are easily crushed by tools that aren't sharp. When I was starting out I'd get streaks of different absorption around bowls and spindle work until someone told me about this. Since I prefer highly figured wood, this can also happen whenever they turn a different way and I'm not optimally cutting them. You can't see if you've done this until you apply finish, so I always start sanding with a much higher grit than needed (100 or lower) to be certain I've removed any closed ends.
I've used tung oil almost exclusively for over six years now and agree with the mineral oil comments. I use a 40/60 mix of Waterlox original and completely natural mostly, to get reasonably fast curing times. For less color, completely natural works best, but can take a week to cure. It's a great food safe and waterproof finish.
Only time I have ever had a problem with cherry is if I did not have my tools as sharp as thy should be and had some torn grain that didn't show until finish was applied. Either that or I bruised the wood with the gouge. You really can't sand bruising out...it needs to go back on the lathe and be cut out. I use Waterlox and get beautiful finishes on properly prepared cherry.