Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Is Magnolia any good?

Posts

Is Magnolia any good?

#1

Is Magnolia any good?

John Lucas

I have access to a whole bunch this afternoon. I didn't look at it closely but it looks pretty plain. Should I get a bunch or just cut a few small pieces to learn how it turns. If it's really good I'll fill the truck up and give it away to other turners because I don't need that much. If it sucks I'll just cut off a little to play with.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#2

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

Hal Taylor

Magnolia is good John. I've turned a number of things - bowls, hollowforms, ornaments. It's reasonably hard and stable.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#3

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

Jorge

I turned it once after a trip to Georgia, it was very similar to poplar.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#4

Thanks guys

John Lucas

I'm headed out now so I'll just bring a fair amount home and turn something and see. I can always give it to my neighbor to burn if it isn't really decent.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#5

It spalts magnificently!!


Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#6

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

I've turned a good deal of magnolia and it has been my experience that there is a lot of variation tree to tree. Some wood remained light colored; whereas, other pieces darkened. My favorite magnolia turnings remained light in color with beautiful purple streaks.

Regardless, the wood is fun to turn -- easy to work, non-irritating, even a faint citrus aroma, and fairly stable. When I just want "a piece of wood" to turn, I reach for Bradford pear, poplar, holly, or magnolia -- all dependable and friendly woods, if rarely spectacular.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#7

Steven Antonucci

Only tried once

steven antonucci

It cuts well and is very plain (at least the piece I had). It doesn't sand blast very well.

Ruined a good vessel trying, though...

Steve

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Only tried once

Dick Hines

If it's free , it's good wood.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#9

Betty Scarpino

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

Betty Scarpino

Emmett, any time you want to get rid of some of that "plain" pear, let me know .....

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#10

Would you believe they hauled it off

John Lucas

I went home and got the chainsaws sharpened and filled. Ate lunch and went back and they had hauled all the wood off. Bummer. Typical of my old job. One hand never knew what the other was doing. OH well, saws are ready for the next windfall.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#11

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Betty, I cannot believe there could be a shortage of Bradford Pear anywhere in the United States. Around here, every time there is even a modest windstorm, these trees come down by the hundreds, if not thousands. I just wait a few days, then drive around and make my selection of cut and stacked pear. A few years ago, a homeowner came running out and asked me what I would charge to haul off all of his downed Bradford pear.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#12

I'm surprised at you John! A woodturner...

JamieDonaldson

...should have his saws ready to travel at a moment's notice!! :D

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#13

Re: I'm surprised at you John! A woodturner...

John Lucas

Your right Jamie. I should have custom Chainsaw cases for all my vehicles.

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#14

Don Leydens

Knowing you John...

Don Leydens

you'll find a way to make custom chain saw cases out of wood!!!

Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#15

turned of course. 


Re: Is Magnolia any good?

#16

Don Leydens

My thoughts exactly!