Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
steven antonucci
Riding the bevel or a sharp tool?
Steve
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
steven antonucci
Riding the bevel or a sharp tool?
Steve
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
Bill Turpin in WNC mouintains
Riding the bevel is a technique. Sharpness is absolutely necessary. It is possible to turn without riding the bevel.
Can't vote for both, Bill
steven antonucci
I agree that both are important, but I am asking which do you think has a more profound effect on the results...
A Sharp tool off bevel vs. a dull tool on bevel...to be clearer.
Steve
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
Barry L Elder
Yes! 
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important? *LINK*
Lyle Jamieson
What’s the consequences??
Don’t have bevel support?? There is no direction or control to the depth of the cut. It will likely get a catch. Best case scenario is there will be tool marks and a rough surface behind. With the bevel you are in complete control of the depth and direction of the cut.
Using dull tools also causes problems. But it is on a sliding scale from
* sharp.
* used, but still sharp enough to do some things.
* dull, but usable with force and excessive sanding required.
* dull to the point where it is dangerous to use.
What is the consequence of forcing a dull tool to cut?? Result, hard work, torn out grain, and poor surface behind that needs excessive sanding.
Conclusion: using a tool improperly without bevel support can lead to more severe problems then sanding.
I just posted/loaded 40 YouTube clips. These are not sales oriented but snips from my demonstrations and teaching.
One shows how to line the bevel up prior to every cut.
http://youtu.be/HV9C7O0wUjU I hope this works, I don’t know how to post a link.
Bevel supported cuts
Depends on
Leo Cuellar
the tool, you don't need to ride the bevel with a scraper 
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
John Lucas
Kind of ambiguous question. You can turn without rubbing the bevel. The cut won't be as clean and you don't have the control to give a good shape. A sharp tool will help some in this case. so if your comparing a really dull tool rubbing the bevel vs sharp tool not rubbing the bevel then your going to get tearout with either.
Why not just sharpen the tool and rub the bevel. 
thanks Lyle - helpful YouTube links
Re: thanks Lyle - helpful YouTube links
Lyle Jamieson
Thanks Henry,
I have had a ton of great comments on the videos. For those unfamiliar with the way YouTube works. I'm still learning. Go to YouTube home page, search for Lyle Jamieson. If you want to subscribe to my channel click on one of my clips (Not Craft Supplies, or others posting about me). You can see the entire listing of topics from my channel.
Re: Opinion Poll: And the point is ????
Denis Putland
??????? I wonder what uses we can put the results of a poll such as this to use doing. or not doing???
Just curious ????
You do not happen to work for the goverment do you
:):):)
Denis
PS; By the way I rate both as a ten in a score from 1 to 10.
The point is to spur conversation
steven antonucci
and I suppose my question back to you is "why are the both 10 out of 10?"
It's pretty common for people to repeat what other people say, but repeating it doesn't mean that you understand it. People throw around words like bevel and sharp, and having an intimate knowledge of the relationship these things have to a clean surface is not as common as you think.
If you still own 80 grit sandpaper, you don't understand.
Steve
Re: Depends on
Coyne
I just flew (commercial) home with my whole family from Oregon to Florida. I am glad that we did not have an inflight discussion as to which was more important to the success of the flight--the engine or the wings.
Coyne
Re: The point is to spur conversation
Jim Breeden
60 grit - just in case 
Re: Depends on
Jim Breeden
No wings - no lift. 
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
Paul Vechart
I turn bowls all the time without riding the bevel. The David Ellsworth's technique for turning bowls does not have you riding the bevel at all. I can see that riding the bevel on the inside would give a better finish and require less sanding. Of course you have to have a sharp tool.
I did NOT vote for both!
Bill Turpin in WNC mouintains
Turning with dull tools is always bad. Good turning is possible without the use of the bevel (but not always). So Sharpening is more important. Let's spread the poll: DO YOU HONE FOR A BETTER EDGE?
Rubbing the bevel but it has to be sharp
Terry Scott
If it has a bevel I can turn with it '
And Ive used some strange things
2 weeks ago I did a demo were I turned with a claw hammer and a nail
Had to be sharp or I wouldn't have gotten any shavings coming off.
In the old days they never rubbed the bevel everything was done with a file scraping but Id say I can get a finish 20 times better rubbing the bevel.
Oh and I never hone waste of time as I always roll over the edge and make it worse
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
robo hippy
Well, you can't cut with a dull tool. So pretty important.
After watching Stuart Batty on Thursday evening, it reinforced the idea that 'riding the bevel' is a difficult concept to get into our heads. Mostly, you barely kiss the bevel, not ride or rub, and most of us use WAY TOO MUCH PRESSURE which leads to all sorts of minor cutting errors, and/or deviations from the intended path.
robo hippy
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
George Guadiane
A while back, I stopped "riding" the bevel and started "resting" the bevel as I turned. "Riding" suggests pressure and could end up crushing the grain. By "resting" I mean like when I wash my feet in the shower... I lean on the wall JUST ENOUGH to keep from falling over. Light pressure as a guide rather than heavy pressure like a crutch
And OF COURSE, with a sharp tool.
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
Dale Miner
This is an apples or oarnges situation.
I like apple pie better.
You can't cut rubbing the bevel it the edge isn't sharp. In order to make a dull edge cut, it must be lifted ever so slightly off the bevel to make the edge penetrate. Or another way of looking at it, the bevel on a dull tool becomes increasingly extremly small, and the original bevel becomes secondary.
So... If forced to vote for an apple or an oarnge, I will vote for sharp.
My take on the topic
steven antonucci
First and foremost, both are important and critical to getting the best finished surface. Given the choice of turning with dull tools or finding another hobby, I would probably take up knitting.
I am a very average carver, and I belong to a carving club. By carving standards, all turning tools are butter knives. We consider a grinder edge as "sharp", but any average carver would throw away that tool because you wouldn't be able to cut with it at all.
I was at a club meeting with a new carver and she had no practical understanding of wood, sharp, bevels... any of it. I lent her a small, kind of sharp, palm gouge because she wanted to cut a channel in a small pine block. The difference of a few degrees in her presentation changed her cut from being ragged to polished.
I will submit that given the opportunity to present the tool with the bevel in proper contact has a greater effect in final surface quality than the quality of the edge. I am not suggesting that we all stop sharpening, but I have used a lot of tools in demonstrating at craft fairs that are beyond a useful edge, and you can still get a serviceable result if you've got good bevel contact.
Steve
Both but...
Don Orr
...I also agree with you last paragraph Steve. I have changed to describing my approach as "bevel support" instead of riding or rubbing which causes bruising as has been mentioned. And you don't need a long bevel either. A small primary bevel with a relieved secondary bevel seems to work well for me, especially with hollow ground tools. Allowing the wood to cut at it's own pace and not forcing the tool into it makes a big difference. (Even with less-than-optimally-sharp tools)But we all know that already. I actually turn with a crazy-sharp carving tool when I need to cut something off cleanly without pulling fibers out for a nice finish-mostly on spindle-oriented projects.
Another good topic for thoughful discussion!
Do I hone? You know I do
steven antonucci
but that is a completely different set of topics...
Steve
Re: Opinion Poll: Which is more important?
robo hippy
Well, the interesting thing is you can turn an entire bowl without touching a bevel, and get a good surface. Most of us will shear scrape, both with gouges and scrapers, which is not a bevel rubbing cut. You can cut very deep with scrapers, and I have never had one that would self feed. It only cuts when I push on it, and I can rough as fast as any one I have ever seen. Of course the finish from a roughing cut is rough because it is a roughing cut. You can cut very shallow without rubbing the bevel, and they can be very delicate and controlled cuts. Just depends on how you present the cutting edge to the wood. I am sure some of you have at least heard of Michael Mouse on the AAW site and Woodnet. He is rather opinionated about cutting with a continental style (another form of SRG) gouge with a flute shaped like this ). His finish cut is with a high shear angle, and not rubbing the bevel, more like a shear cut. IT works for him.
robo hippy