Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

purely subjective... a poll

Posts

purely subjective... a poll

#1

purely subjective...  a poll

GaryG in MD

OK, I'd like to do a little poll here...

Please think about this, visualizing both possibilities carefully, and then give me your opinions.

I have a thick maple burl bowl with a wide natural rim containing "points".

It has some nice figure on both the inside and outside.

It is my determination that I AM going to color either the inside or the outside with red dye (perhaps a multiplicity of dyes surrounding a basic red color -- maybe purple/red/yellow or blue/red/yellow, sanding back between applications) to try to achieve one of those nice results we see in the work of Joe Landon, Chris Pytlik, and Andy DiPietro.

I can't decide whether to dye the inside or the outside.

I can see both in my mind's eye, and both have some merits.

If you were doing it, which would you do, and why?

TIA, GG

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#2

What is the shape of the bowl?

John Lucas

If it's a really open bowl then the outside won't show much. You could color the outside to make it pop more or you could color the inside so that's where your eyes are forced to go. It this case coloring the outside might simply make you notice the outside more but it probably won't dominate the piece because it's on the shadow side of the bowl.

It if's a closed bowl then the outside tends to be more dominant naturally. If you dye the outside it's really going to stand out and the inside would be much more subdued. However if you dye the inside red it now could compete with the outside for attention because red is such a dominant color.

The rim from the sound of it is going to grab your attention whatever you do. So I think you could color both the inside and outside and leave the rim. Use a dark color red perhaps fading into black like a reverse sunburst. This would make the rim really stand out.

I'm purely speculating base on what my mind thinks your bowl looks like and I could be completely wrong. :) wouldn't be the first time.

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#3

Steven Antonucci

I would color it, and then probably burn it.

steven antonucci

Seriously, I have very little luck trying to emulate the effects other people get with color. They never turn out the way that I want them to look.

Good luck with it, though. If you figure out how to do it, you can show me.

Steve

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#4

Re: I would color it, and then probably burn it.

Don in Central Illinois

I just dyed a bowl, outside only and finished the inside with a wipe on poly. This shows the dyed look while showing the natural beauty of tbe wood on the inside. If I get time I'll post a pic later today.

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#5

Re: I would color it, and then probably burn it.

Bill Turpin in WNC mouintains

Neither! I don't color any turnings

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#6

Re: purely subjective...  a poll

robo hippy

I am one who tries to understand why any one would want to color any wood. I prefer the natural colors. Plus, my color sense is just about as good as my fashion sense as in 'fashionably unconscious'.

robo hippy

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#7

Re: What is the shape of the bowl?

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your thoughtful reply, John, and good point.

This bowl is relatively "tall" -- nearly "square" (almost, but not quite as high as it is across), but the top is a NE scallop so the height of the rim varies considerably, and the view into the center varies with the angle of observation. That's what makes this an interesting project because the fraction of inside to outside that you can see varies with orientation. From a typical viewing angle, you can see both at the same time. ...GG

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#8

Re: purely subjective...  a poll

phillip medghalchi

Gary, John Lucas had a very good point and even w/o a pick his visualization is very good. I was thinking about this program that you take a picture of and article and then on your screen you can dye it and change stuff around and it gives you an idea about how the finished product will look like. I try to ask around to see if I can find the name of it for you. This will help not to distroy the long hours you put in to create your bowla nd visually give an idea of who to change it to your liking. Of course the final product will look much better, since I have seen your creation on the IAP penturners site. I hope this helped.

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#9

Bob Moffett

Re: purely subjective...  a poll

Bob Moffett

I would color the outside and leave the inside the natural color. I just like that combination better.

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#10

Thanks, all, for your thoughts...

GaryG in MD

I think I'm prone to dying the outside and leaving the inside natural.

I'll let you know when I do it. ...Gary

Re: purely subjective... a poll

#11

good idea, Phillip...

GaryG in MD

There are undoubtedly photo programs out there that will permit that kind of alteration. I'll keep that in mind. ...GG