Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

The Rule of 10,000

Posts

The Rule of 10,000

#1

The Rule of 10,000

charlie belden

You've probably read or heard about The Rule of 10,000 - you have to do something 10,000 times before you've mastered doing it. And the implication is there's no exception to this rule - and that it will take years and years.

If it takes an hour or two to turn a bowl, and you turn 8 hours a day, 7 days a week, that's 56 bowls a week, it'll be close 3 to 6 years to get to your 10,000th bowl.

But what if . . .

you could cut that time in half or by a quarter?

You CAN - if you turn miniatures.

You can turn a Mini in 10 or 15 minutes. AND you don't use much wood, don't have to sharpen as often, don't need a big powerful lathe, a rack full of turning tools nor have to sweep up - and dispose of - garbage cans full of shavings. The cuts you use to turn a mini can be the same as those used for full sized turnings and the tools to make those cuts can be the same type(s), just at a different scale.

Why aren't new turners started off turning miniatures? The types of turning tools can be the same, just smaller. The fundamentals are the same, just with a smaller range of motion. The tool control is the same, perhaps even tighter than for full sized pieces . The forms can be the same, just at a smaller scale - proportions are proportions, regardless of the scale at which they are applied. And a catch while turning a miniature is much less dangerous than a catch while turning a full sized or BIG piece.

For new turners, confidence is often an issue. After all, shoving a sharp tool into a piece of spinning wood seems like a really crazy thing to do - unless you understand the mechanics of the process and know how to apply that knowledge. What better way to acquire that knowledge and learn the fundamental skills than turning miniatures?

Just something to think about - or not . . .

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#2

I can name that tune in 5 notes...

David Walser

Charlie - I think the 10,000 rule was written for slow learners. Some of us can master bowl turning in only 9,958 bowls. (I say "some" because I just turned my 9,941st bowl and I'm feeling pretty close to master-hood. Another two dozen and I think I'll be ready to apply for the certificate.)

More seriously, I think the issue turns on the definition of "master". If by that term, you mean "know all there is to know" or "no room for improvement", it might well take 10,000+ bowls or Christmas ornaments to become a master. On the other hand, by the time most of us have turned our 100th bowl, we can be said to have gotten the process down. Sure, we are still learning and are still improving, but the training wheels have been off for a long time.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#3

Steven Antonucci

100 Bowls doesn't mean you are any good...

steven antonucci

I disagree that repetition means proficiency. I know many guys who have made many bowls and are still basically beginning turners. Being able to remove wood without killing yourself is not a mark of proficiency. If you have seen Glenn Lucas cut a bowl, you'll know what I mean.

Mastery is a knowledge gained through years of trial and error, experimentation and repetition of good technique. The reason it takes 10,000 hours is that we often do not know what we do not know, and until we learn it, we're still beginners.

Steve

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#4

Steven Antonucci

Define miniatures?

steven antonucci

In my class, we turn small bowls. I usually keep them around 4" in diameter, since I can show the class how to reverse them over the chuck to finish the foot. If you work too small, it is really hard to teach them the motions needed to do bigger work.

But, yeah, I get your point... and I agree mostly. Nothing big on the lathe in my class. I get the physics part too...

Steve

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#5

Re: The Rule of 10,000

John Lucas

Charlie I have to disagree. You can get by with a lot of bad techniques turning miniatures. Granted you do learn form if you look close enough but you can ride off the bevel and scrape and not have a problem with a miniature bowl. Do that with a big bowl and you've got problems. Sanding a big bowl is also much more difficult I think than sanding a small bowl.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#6

Another consideration is the fact.....

JamieDonaldson

...that many beginners want to turn a BIG bowl, often far too large to fit on their first small lathe. Until they have had the experience of being physically abused by a BIG blank spinning in their face, the "BIG is better" dream is hard to quell. After that often painful first process, when the arms and shoulders are no longer sore, they find the prospect for turning another less inviting. And besides, there's no market for wooden bird bathes! ;) I made the conscious decision long ago that if I can't easily lift a piece of turning stock high enough for mounting on the lathe, I have no interest or reason to be turning that beast.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#7

Steven Antonucci

bird baths and dog dishes


Re: The Rule of 10,000

#8

Re: The Rule of 10,000

charlie belden

> You can get by with a lot of bad techniques turning miniatures.

Good technique is good technique, regardless of the scale at which it's used. The converse is also true. The main difference is the consequences for bad technique. If taught good technique - properly sharpened tools, the right tool choice for the task at hand, the right method of using the tool, etc. - the differences between small and "regular sized" is minor. The differences in forces involved however are signigicantly different. Bigger involves MUCH MORE kinetic energy and torque.

> Granted you do learn form

In the end, isn't that what is the end goal? If the form is bad, how well it is was turned and finished can't fix it. HOW one gets from chunk of wood to that end goal doessns't matter much to the viewer, assuming the viewer is not a turner.

> . . . but you can ride off the bevel and scrape and not have a problem with a miniature bowl. Do that with a big bowl and you've got problems.

True a mistake in technique on larger pieces can have more severe consequences than on a miniature piece. But when a mistake in technique occurs - even when turning a miniature, you KNOW IT, because the tool and the wood will tell you you screwed up. But, I think it's better to learn about spiral cuts and catches on a small turning rather than on a large one. I'm assuming that the turner is paying attention to what's going on while making a cut. NOTHING can prevent a careless person from being injured, maimed or killed. I cite a 16 year old unexpeprienced rider on a Crotch Rocket as an example . Every weekend that the weather is nice, one of them is spatulaed off a guard rail or out of a grill of an oncoming car up on Sky Line (a great mountain ridge road to drive or ride - if you're careful. John Jordan can vouch for how great a ride Sky Line is - if you're ).

> Sanding a big bowl is also much more difficult I think than sanding a small bowl.

Not sure if it's more difficult but certainly takes longer ; )

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#9

Re: 100 Bowls doesn't mean you are any good...

David Walser

Steve - I don't think we are in disagreement. Practicing poor technique will only make you faster at turning out junk.

On the other hand, assuming the practice of sound fundamentals, for most turners the learning curve is fairly steep before fairly quickly becoming a fairly gentle incline. Once you've turned a few dozen of something, you're apt to be learning far less with each new iteration than you did with the first few items. At that point, the basics have become almost second nature, but you're still growing as a turner -- refining the form, becoming more consistent with an increasing number of hits to misses, better able to read the wood to avoid problems, more efficient in your process so more of your focus is on how to improve the outcome and less energy is spent trying to figure out the next step, etc.

When a turner is on this gently upward sloping part of the learning curve, can the turner be said to have mastered that aspect of the craft of turning bowls, pens, pepper mills, or whatever it may be? No, not if by "master" we mean having nothing more to learn. The learning curve is still going up, albeit slowly. But, if that's the standard, Ray Key and Richard Raffan would not be considered master box turners. No one ever would be considered a master of anything because none of us can ever truthfully say we know everything about a given subject. None of us have so perfected our craft that we produce a perfect item every time.

So, to me, as defined above, "master" is a meaningless concept since no one can ever hope to achieve that status. On the other hand, if the concept is defined more reasonably to where you are well onto that gentler part of the learning curve, then it's something most of us could aspire to become. Of course, most of us won't because once we've turned a handful of one thing we're off to the next, never taking the time to get off the steep part of the curve.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#10

Re: The Rule of 10,000

robo hippy

Back in the days when I used to sew and sell footbags (known to most as Hacky Sacks), I would teach people to sew. I developed a theory then that seems to hold true in teaching people to turn. It takes 50 to 100 finished bags or bowls to get the process down fairly well. It takes another couple hundred down to fine tune the process, and who knows how many to perfect it. I can teach tricks that I figured out on my own that will save people a lot of figuring on their part, but there is no substitute for experience.

robo hippy

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#11

Re: The Rule of 10,000

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Many people here have more than ten thousand hours at the lathe. Some people a lot less time on the lathe. Woodturning craft can be instance success or instant failure no matter how many hours you have on the lathe.

Not everybody wants to devote their time at the lathe turning bowls.

So forget the rule of 10,000 hours! Instead, approach woodturning with patience, practice, and persistence no matter what you attempt to turn on a lathe.

Throw away the clock, and learn to please yourself first!

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#12

Throw away the clock, and learn to please yourself

John Lucas

Perfectly said Bill. the late Charles Alvis used to say when starting a demo "what are we here for". The knowledgeable members would respond "to have fun"

Turn should be about fun and discovery. It's not about the tools, or the lathes (although god knows I love that tool). It's about creating something with your hands and mind.

I look back and wonder how I made some of the things I did many years ago. I certainly didn't have the skills or the tools but somehow I got them made. I might have beat them into submission with a scraper and sandpaper but somehow they exist.

Here is a good example. My Biological Clock piece. I was really good with a router and table saw but really lousy at the lathe and had never carved anything. I managed to get the spalted dogwood pieces turned and inserted into the routed opening for the biological symbol. The legs were carved using a coping saw, wood rasp, a Dremel with only 2 tools, a jewelers saw to cut the toes and several fingernail files and a chisel. It took lots of patience but I got it done.

A funny story to go along with this. I have a degree in Physical Education and have been lifting weights forever. I know muscles and how they should look. What I don't know is how baby fat wraps around the legs. So I needed to do some research. I went to Walmart and starting looking up the skirts of all the dolls to learn about the baby fat. Well you know what that looks like now. At the time I didn't think anything about it. I'm probably on some training video that walmart shows to employees on how to catch a child molester. :)

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#13

Steven Antonucci

Mastery is hard to define, but easy to see

steven antonucci

I belong to a club with a lot of members (100). Many of them have been turning longer than I have been alive. Can you be a beginner turner with 40 years of experience? I would say you can.

To master something (whatever that means), I think you need talent, will, and passion. You also need to recognize that some of your work will not be very good, and being self-critical and open to criticism from other helps you get better. You have to be willing to fail and learn from it. You have to be a "knowledge sponge".

It's a long road with many steps, and mostly uphill. Once you get to the top of it, you see that it's just a plateau and the road continues upwards to the next plateau...

Steve

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#14

Re: Throw away the clock, and learn to please your

matt overton

That is a great message, John. This thread reminds me of an employee I once had who worked for me for 7 years. He didn't have 7 years experience, he had one years experience 7 times.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#15

Re: Throw away the clock, and learn to please your

John Lucas

Matt I had a secretary once who had little experience and didn't use what she had much. She spent the day calling her friends to discuss what the National Enquirer had to say about things. She didn't last long.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#16

"Mastery is Asymptotic"

charlie belden

To illustrate David's Learning Curve - the horizontal axis is time/energy/effort/learning .... The vertical axis is knowledge/skills/abilties


I read an article somewhere entitled "Mastery is Asymptotic" - approachable, but never attainable. Seems an accurate description

My premise :

Start by learning to turn miniatures, THEN, using the knowledge, skills and abilities developed, apply them to "normal sized" turning." The fundamentals of good turning practices are basically the same, regardless of size. As the turning size increases, additional knowledge and skills - and precautions taken to avoid injury - are added. But the Basics can be learned much quicker, and safer, turning miniatures,

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#17

Re: Another consideration is the fact.....

charlie belden

It's interesting that if you make something small enough - or BIG enough - it is viewed and experienced - when seen in person at actual size differently than "normal sized"pieces. It may be that though the basic aesthetics are the same, each brings an additional aesthetic unique to its scale,

THAT is one of the things miniatures have. While a normal sized version of a nice piece might be appreciated, a sufficiently small enough versions of the same form, maybe even of the same wood, seems to impress more, probably because it is examined more closely. It may also be the the WOW Factor - how on earth did you DO that!?

Miniatures are usually looked at differently - examined more like you'd look at a gem or piece of jewelry than as a piece of furniture or vase. The aesthetics of miniatures may be very similar to that of other turnings, but with an added level of attention to details.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#18

Steven Antonucci

Mastery is an illusion

steven antonucci

First, I agree with you violently about limiting the size of the turning whilst you learn. Reality is that it is going to be hard for every beginner to recognize the dangers when they have a 20" swing.

Mastery is about how others perceive you, not how you self perceive. You may be the best woodturner you know if you haven't seen that many people. Someone may think you are the best woodturner if they haven't seen many woodturners. I see it all of the time at the craft fairs. The guy at the lathe must be an expert, because he's standing at the lathe at a craft fair...

There is always someone better at something than you are... so mastery is an illusion.

Steve

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#19

I disagree with you Charlie, but the.....

JamieDonaldson

...definition of "miniatures" is key. At a certain scale point the tools to turn "tiny" miniatures are entirely different from "regular" tools, creating additional problems such as sourcing, seeing, holding and manipulating those specific tools. "Normal" sized tools and projects allow viewing and manipulating that are necessary for learning the basics, and everything else follows those methods learned, regardless of size unless carried to size extremes. ;)

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#20

Keith Tompkins

Re: The Rule of 10,000

Keith Tompkins

Funny, at a demo I did last night, the topic came up about 10K hours. A motorcycle analogy.....I read an article where a cyclist decided to take a road racing course. He had ridden for 17 years, and figured he would blow the rest of the students away. Much to his surprise, he was destroyed, even by the beginners! What he came to realize is he only had ONE year of experience; he had just repeated it 17 times. All he had done is reinforce bad habits, and it required him to relearn all he though he knew about riding.

I have had turners come for lessons with many years of experience, yet they were at the beginner level...with so many bad habits I recommended they simply start over, forgetting just about everything they knew. On the other hand, I've seen newbies just take off and progess far rapidly than they should have....sometimes it's just aptitude. (I've played guitar for 30 some years, and I still suck) I hate it when some 9 year old little b@##@#$$d makes me look bad!

I don't think the vast majority of turners even want to reach the "master" level...it's just a hobby to them. Do I think the title applies to some...Yes.

Large vs. miniatures....I don't know about that, but I stress spindle turning skills...after that bowl turning is easy.

Re: The Rule of 10,000

#21

Terms & Definitions *LINK*

charlie belden

Terms & Definitions

Nano miniatures: Require a scanning electron microscope to see

Micro miniatures: Require a microscope to see

Mini miniature: Requires hand held magnification to see

Miniature: Requires no magnification to see

Diameter no larger than than your thumb and index finger can surround

No taller than the width of your index and middle finger

Regarding Special Tools

Miniatures, using the above definition of the term, can be turned with traditional turning tools, merely smaller than those used for a "normal sized" turning, and readily available from sources that provide "normal sized" turning tools - ie 1/2" roughing gouge, 1/2" or 1/4" skew (or 1/4" bench chisel), 1/4" shallow flute or regular flute spindle gouge in place of a bowl gouge and an optional 1/8th inch parting tool.

The only "special tool" that you need to make is a hollowing tool, which you can make from a 1/4" diameter

steel rod with your sharpening grinder and a small rat tail file.

The big difference between turning miniiatures and "normal sized" pieces is the strength of the turning tools. The tools used to turn miniatures would likely be destroyed by the forces involved with turning "normal sized pieces".

Attached is a link to a YouTube video on turning a miniature hollow form with blended finial. Only two tools were used - a 1/4" bench chisel with a 20 degree bevel and a 1/4" shallow flute spindle gouge with a fingernail grind.


Turning a Miniature HF with Blended Finial