Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
http://www.necn.com/10/03/12/1-arrested-for-cutting-stealing-tree-bur/landing_mobile.html?blockID=783499
Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
Posts
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#2
Happened here too
steven antonucci
Not as obvious, and certainly not as frequent as this guy, but there used to be a big burl on a tree down the road from me, and one day it was just gone. Glad they caught the guy.
Glad he's not one of us too...
Steve
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#3Re: Man arrested for stealing burls
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN
We had a demonstrator at our club a few months ago who was very proud of his battery powered electric chainsaw -- he said it allowed him to harvest burls in a National Forest without getting caught. I don't believe he was kidding.
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#4If they ever invent a muffler for.......
JamieDonaldson
...chainsaws this problem will really explode! Thieves are found to have stolen trees from our local national forest by skidding them out at night with horses rather than a noisy tractor.
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#5Re: Man arrested for stealing burls
phillip medghalchi
Nice, now we are going to get bad wrap for getting our burls legally. there always have to be someone who will spoil good things? 
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#6
Re: If they ever invent a muffler for.......
Mike Stafford
My dad owned a 35 acre piece of land that was shaped somewhat like a slice of pie. It was much wider at the back than it was on the road frontage.
Most of the property was forested but back in the widest area where we gardened it was mostly clear. We had a huge garden back there and on one corner there was a massive walnut tree growing out in the open. It must have been close to 3 feet in diameter.
One day my dad and I went down to the garden and the entire tree was gone. Someone had come in through a neighbor's property without the neighbor's permission and stolen the tree. They took everything that was bigger than your forearm including the root ball. My dad said that the root ball was valuable as gun stock material.
So if you want to keep a valuable tree you have to chain it to something and even then they might take it from you.
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#7Re: If they ever invent a muffler for.......
Tony Memphis
You know, before I started trying to steal trees or burls out in the woods, I'd think long and hard about the fact that wood thieves make good compost for the trees! And that there aren't many witnesses around. If a wood thief gets shot in the woods, doesn anybody hear about it?
Sad.
I've noticed a few burls on trees along my route to work. Haven't noticed any missing yet. A big thing around here was Japanese maple trees being stolen. Fortunately, that started after ours out front was grown up - they would need more than a shovel now! Amazing how much that thing has grown in 14 years.
Tony
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#8
My buddy and the Forestry Management Program
steven antonucci
A buddy of mine has a property in Upstate NY and has a Forest Management plan for it. He gets the tax break, and the Forest Service tells him which trees stay and go. So he calls the local tree guys and walks the property to show them which trees are marked and they give him a price and they shake hands.
He goes away for a couple of days, and when he gets back, 2 very large cherry trees have been "accidentally" cut. If had been a day later, the logs would have also been taken. It's not just burls... and it is actually pretty common.
Steve
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#9
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls
Dick Hines
Every time I go on the Blue Ridge Parkway I look at all the burls. It seems like every second tree I see has a burl. I guess the Park Service will have to be on the look out for people cutting them. As if they did not have enough trouble with people shooting bears and deer.
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#10
Not much of a defense possible, I hope...
Rob Wallace
Back in the late 1990's I got a call on my University office phone from an attorney looking for an expert witness to assist in the defense of his client who was caught cutting and removing parts of trees, including burls, from a state or county park (I can't remember which). He was charged with something like willful defacing of public property, or another charge of similar wording. The lawyer wanted me to testify that burls were 'abnormal growths' on a tree. The defense argument being proposed was that the guy who got caught was trying to do a 'service' by cutting-off the abnormal growths, so the trees would 'look normal'.
Needless to say that as a botanist, I could accurately state that burls represented anomalous growth on various parts of a tree, but I further explained that I would also need to say that they cause no harm to the tree, and cutting them off might increase the risk of internal infection by fungi or bacteria that could cause long-term damage or loss. (Unfortunately for him, the botanist he had contacted that day is also an avid conservationist, as well as a woodturner!) Apparently the lawyer did not like my honesty nor the scientific facts. I never heard from him again, and I never learned of the outcome of this case. (I also probably lost out on a $ 500 - $750+ witness fee by being ethical and completely honest.)
It sounds like the guy in Boston had been doing burl theft for a while, and was blatant about it. Good to know that he got caught, and perhaps his stupidity can be made an example of with sufficient publicity. This report has also been going around Facebook on several of the wood and woodworking groups.
Rob Wallace
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#11Re: Not much of a defense possible, I hope...
Hugh
I used to live in the Sacramento Valley - Claro Walnut was the hot item there. The theives would go out on very stormy nights with chainsaws with carbide chains, a flat bed truck and a backhoe. With the stormy weather covering the noise they would cut around the base of the tree, cut off the limbs and use the backhoe to dig out and lift the burly stump onto the flat bed truck. Down the road they went. Some of those trees would fetch about $10,000 - $15,000.
Hugh
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#12Re: Not much of a defense possible, I hope...
phillip medghalchi
So, would you say that now we have to pay prime price for any burl we want should we desire to make soemthing of it? I guess now the suppliers got the upper hand to increase their prices. 
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#13Rob, that wasn't a very skilled .......
JamieDonaldson
...attorney if he didn't review your testamony before putting you on the stand! 
Re: Man arrested for stealing burls *LINK*
#14
Re: Rob, that wasn't a very skilled .......
Rob Wallace
I agree Jamie! I never got a chance to actually testify, and I was not used as a witness - he never called back after the first call. I assume he was scared that I would not keep my statement narrowed to just the burl's abnormal growth part....?? 
One of the more interesting cases that I did give a deposition on several years ago was for a case involving a marijuana grower caught growing plants on a farm in the eastern part of Iowa. The police burned nearly all of the evidence, and the plant scraps kept to identify the plants could not be definitively identified as the marijuana cultivar of Cannabis. I had to state that these plants could just as easily have been the hemp cultivar of Cannabis (which is a common weed throughout the midwest) that is found almost everywhere, and is spread easily by birds. Due to bad police work, the guy probably got off with a hand slap.....
Rob



