Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

How not to turn a box lid

Posts

How not to turn a box lid

#1

How not to turn a box lid

John Lucas

I as using a jam chuck to turn the top of this lid. I always drill a hole in the blank so if I can't get it back off with my fingers I can stick a dowel through the headstock and gently push it out. I guess I had it thinner than I planned. When I pushed with the dowel it came through the lid. Time for a break I guess.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#2

Re: How not to turn a box lid

Tom in Alaska

I wish I could say this never happened to me... To remove a stuck lid I grab the lid as good as I can with one hand then I smack the first hand with the second. That jaring action is usually effective and does not mar the lid... but at times you still end up with "eggshell shards".

Take a mulligan and tee-up another!

PS - wear gloves so that you lessen the chance of getting oversized "splinters" in your palm when removing a stuck lid in case it does collapse.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: How not to turn a box lid

Mike Stafford

I've never done that...... :b :

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#4

Nor have I.................

Richard Jones

yeah, right.................

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Nor have I.................

dick hines

I have the t-shirt to prove I have een there.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#6

Re: How not to turn a box lid

Doug Adams

John

I have had good luck with a blast of air

Doug

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#7

Good tip-I'll try that

John Lucas

Of course then I'll probably blow the top across the room and break it anyway :)

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#8

Rob Wallace

Is that elm???

Rob Wallace

If so, elm can get kind of brittle, at least in my experience. Punching through end grain is something I have done a few times on thin-walled elm pieces..... ....not much fun!

Hope you've got another piece of stock that will match-up with the bottom....

Rob

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#9

It's cherry-already turned another top


Re: How not to turn a box lid

#10

Re: How not to turn a box lid

Galen Vetterick

I am a slow learner. I've had to put two lids in the freezer to free them from a jam chuck because I keep failing to drill a simple hole to push them off if needed. I'm just lucky that has worked twice.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: It's cherry-already turned another top

Mike Stafford

John, when you said it was cherry I just had to say another word or two.

I have just about quit using cherry for boxes because of its brittleness. I have had so many cherry boxes shatter, particularly the lids, on the end grain that I either leave them thicker than I like or I don't turn cherry for boxes.

I first noticed this problem with breakage in a gallery where I had my product. Then later I had turned stage samples, boxes turned to various stages of completion to pass around at demonstrations to provide visuals to show what I was doing. All of my stage samples were turned from cherry and a couple were dropped during the passing and what happened- the thin end grain broke, chipped or shattered. I quit using cherry for my samples.

Somewhere I remember reading an article by Mike Mahoney where he addressed the characteristics of wood and talked about how cherry was brittle and not suited for certain applications in turning. Well, I learned that the hard way. That said I have certain boxes from cherry that have held up perfectly despite hard use. But if you drop them on a concrete floor........????

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#12

Mike Stafford

You need a new turning tool.....

Mike Stafford

Galen, you are not the only person who jams a lid on and then cannot get it off. It happens all the time.

I added a tool to my box turning kit just for that reason. I always carry a thin bladed fillet knife in my demonstration kit to slip in between the lid and the body to gently pry off the lid. I keep a couple in my shop and they have saved many a lid for me.

I find Rapala makes the best turning tools for this application. :b

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#13

Re: It's cherry-already turned another top

John Lucas

Interesting I've worked a lot with Cherry and like it. I haven't had those problems but maybe I was just lucky. In this case the lid was a hair loose so I sprayed the chuck with water. It swelled enough to really hold well. Probably tool well. I pushed on the rod and the lid didn't come off but that's not uncommon. I tapped gently with a mallet and blew the end out. As you can see it was a little less than 1/8" at some points. That's probably what did it.

As it turns out the "sticks" I found for the stick house were also cherry so this whole project will be cherry except for the straw on the straw house.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: It's cherry-already turned another top

Mike Stafford

You know it could be you get a better quality less brash cherry where you are. The hardwoods in my neck of the woods are not at all what they should be. I guess the climate is too warm and the soil is too poor. I have taken to using the cherry I get locally as waste block stuff....

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#15

Steven Antonucci

Tight jam chuck trick

steven antonucci

I've never pushed through (because I haven't used the hole thing yet), but I have snapped lids prying them off.

If you get yourself in this predicament in the future, use a parting tool to waste away the jam chuck and just break the inside tenon off.

Steve

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#16

Re: Tight jam chuck trick

John Lucas

Steve done the parting tool thing but in this case I need to be able to put the lid back on to trim the sticks a little after i glue them on the lid. See the photo above.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#17

Joe Bradshaw

Re: How not to turn a box lid

Joe Bradshaw

John, once you turn your jam chuck and fit the lid, cut a slot parallel to the grain of your jam chuck. Lin up the slot with the side of one of the jaws. Use as usual.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#18

Re: How not to turn a box lid

John Lucas

I've done that but it can throw the alignment off a little. In a worse case scenario I CA glued the jam chuck to my metal chuck. Then cut 4 slots all the way through the jam chuck on the bandsaw. This essentially gave me 4 smaller wooden jaws. The kerf from the bandsaw was more than enough to be able to compress the jaws to hold the lid. Sometimes when it's late at night and you need to get a project done you get creative.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#19

brash cherry

Stuart Johnson

Mike, Would you describe what you mean by brash? I once bought a couple Cherry platter blanks that were very nice looking but seemed to crumble rather than cut.

Re: How not to turn a box lid

#20

Mike Stafford

Yeah, what is brash cherry?

Mike Stafford

Stuart, I don't know if brash is the correct term but another turner used it when I described the problem. He said it was wood that was grown fast but in poor soil conditions and without sufficient cold weather which certainly describes the conditions in my area. Sand is the soil of record here in the coastal plain, our winters are mild and trees do grow quickly.

It did not crumble when turned but seemed to be very brittle and chippy particularly on the end grain. The wood box models I was describing broke easily when dropped. The lids shattered like an egg shell or chipped out sections on the short end grain. They were all turned from the same tree section. The wood looked normal but it was not very "strong" wood.

Some of the timber experts who know more about trees can probably enlighten us both with the correct terminology and cause for this crappy wood structure.